The 5 Best 5 Gallon Plastic cans (2023 reviews)

The eagle 5 gallon plastic can is long-lasting, rigid and fits well with your daily purpose like a dream. This is a great design over those annoying plastic gas cans with push buttons and flow nozzles or crazy twist safety caps. Opening the flapper door by holding the D-handle against the welded steel handle is very ergonomic. The funnel is designed to catch the liquid pouring out of the spout all the way through this procedure. It comes with a spark/flame arrestor screen that is integral to the opening and also has a self relieving safety valve on the spring loaded lid which prevents gas pressure buildup. This can saves trips to the gas station and the easy pour spout is a great feature.

Why We Like This:

Great for lawnmowers and other such equipment use
Solidly made five gallon safety can with easy to pour spout
Leaks, solidly made, and the funnel insert works easily and intuitively

Best For storing gasoline: Justrite 5 Gallon Plastic Can

Buy on Amazon

These cans are designed for storing gasoline. It is a great safety can for storing gasoline safely for emergency generator use. It doesn't leak, smell, is easy to clean, and won't tip over easily. The fuel pours easily without a vent and goes in easily.

These cans are well built and have a strong spring holding the filler cap tight to the base, so no gas spills or splashes out until you pull back on the handle/lever. It is a good can of equal quality to the eagle can. It is made from high-grade coated steel, and each can is tested to ensure 100% leak-proof construction.

Why We Like This:

Odors and does not leak gas
Best reusable used oil solution for transport to auto parts for recycling
Good investment for long term

Best For weed eaters: Eagle 5 Gallon Plastic Can

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate can. The eagle 5 gallon plastic can is exactly that - it's a simple can that hits all the right notes. There is no leakage, dripping or fumes with these cans. The lever action opener works perfectly to stop the flow when you want it to. The Eagle one is well made and easy to use. It is easy to open and the plastic funnel prevents spilling of gasoline. The funnel is plastic and must be removed to refill the tank. The springs on the self closing caps are strong so it is easy to see where an elderly or handicapped or just a weaker individual will have difficulty using and filling a safety can.

Why We Like This:

Heavy duty and do not leak
Safety first in fuel storage and filling small engines
Well made and works well when you get used to the funky funnel
Very sturdy and easy to use

Best For floor: Surecan 5 Gallon Plastic Can

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other can in this category, the surecan 5 gallon plastic can has a convenient design. The Surecan 5 gallon Type-II Safety Gasoline Container is compatible with California's rubber booted gas nozzles. It is designed to meet the requirements of the california air resources board (carb), which includes compatibility with california's nozzles. It’s easy to lift, easy to operate and helps not spill so much.

The concept works well with the nozzle attached to the bottom and folding downward to reach whatever you are filling. The splash guard and spring cap also make putting any fuel stabilizer in about impossible. It is located on the bottom of the can making refueling painless. It is easy to pour with no spills, no need to lift and tip a heavy container or keep a funnel handy. The flexible hose prevents spilling and saves alot of time. This is a great can to carry on your sled, jetski or atv.

Why We Like This:

Durable, prevents spillage, easy to use when full
More lifting and turning a heavy, full gas container and hoping it doesn't leak
Good investment for long term

Best For transporting fuel: Justrite gas tank

Buy on Amazon

Dispensing fuel from the can is convenient and clean, because of the spring-handle and the funnel. The little fuel can is well built and without any internal flaws concerning delamination of any coatings, whether they paint or zinc. The funnel can bend of course, and the funnel will consume space way beyond the can, so this is NOT a space saving solution for fuel storage.

This can is so much more durable and waaay easier to use. They also do not leak when in transit and stink up the vehicle. It's OSHA approved and properly colored. This is an EXCELLENT safety can.

Why We Like This:

Perfect size for storing mixed gas for the yard tools
Extra heavy-duty, self venting cap, good carry handle, and osha approved
Good clean, odor free, but difficult to fill
Better lid to keep moisture out