The 7 Best 5 Gallon Plastic carboys (2023 reviews)
We consider a 5 gallon plastic carboy to be a worthy investment in the long run.
We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.
Our review process:
Our Top Picks:
Best Overall: Buy: Fastrack Glass Carboy READ REVIEWBest with Handle: Buy: big mouth bubbler 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy READ REVIEWBest with Lid: Buy: Centralbrewshop 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy READ REVIEWBest for brewer: Buy: Fastrack 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy READ REVIEWBest quality Glass: Buy: homebrewers Outpost 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy READ REVIEWBest Plastic Carboy: Buy: home brew Ohio 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy READ REVIEWBest value for money: Buy: Vintage shop 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy READ REVIEWBest Overall: Fastrack Glass Carboy
Buy on Amazon
If you often find yourself scrambling for good carboy, fastrack glass carboy is your end point. They take a much larger stopper than a glass carboy. It will handle boiling water added to a carboy, and PET melts above 250 f. Do not directly heat, add hot water. You could easily fit a half dollar coin in this PET container. It is easy to clean and easy to move as its light weight.
The neck is 3" high and 2" around. It does not have ridges on the sides for particles to get trapped in. It is used for secondary fermentation. It is great for 3 batches of beer.Why We Like This:
- Light weight and holds up well over time
- Lots easer to lug around than the 5 gallon glass
- Lightweight, easier to move when filled
- Works great and lighter than glass
Best with Handle: big mouth bubbler 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy
Buy on Amazon
If you want nothing but the best reliable carboy, then big mouth bubbler 5 gallon plastic carboy is the one you should definitely consider, as it manages to bring a lot to the table. If you like glass carboys you’ll love this carboy’s large opening. It is perfect glass carboy for craft beer enthusiasts. If you dry the silicon and dry the glass that it touches, the lid is very firmly in place. The bottle has no threads. The glass carboy is super thick, and it is packaged very good, super easy to clean. The product is really cool and holds a lot of cider but the lid does not stay on. It can easily stick an arm in for deep cleaning. This product should come with a lid locking device and airlock with bung.Why We Like This:
- Nice solid carboy, needs tighter lid design
- Very well made and easy to clean
- Wide mouth is easy for cleaning, adding oak spirals and other flavor enhancers
Best with Lid: Centralbrewshop 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy
Buy on Amazon
We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate carboy. The centralbrewshop 5 gallon plastic carboy is exactly that - it's a simple carboy that hits all the right notes. Smooth inner walls prevent sediment from collecting and make for easy cleaning. It is ideal for secondary fermentations of beer or wine. It is completely taste and odor free, stain resistant, and impermeable to oxygen.Why We Like This:
- A heavy, pet plastic carboy ideal for secondary fermentations of beer or wine
- New and hot release
Best for brewer: Fastrack 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy
Buy on Amazon
If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable carboy, fastrack 5 gallon plastic carboy should be your first option for buying. The Fermonster gives a very positive seal. It is light weight, easy to clean, safer than glass, and you can see the krausen forming on the beer. It is nice to have a lighter choice from glass, and without the danger of breakage.
This is made of food-grade plastic. They make a tool for opening them. It is easy to clean and dismantle, and the lid is not difficult to remove. The Fermonster is a great product, make sure you follow directions, you should not put boiling wort in it.Why We Like This:
- Good investment for long term
- Good brand reputation
Best quality Glass: homebrewers Outpost 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy
Buy on Amazon
Compared with other carboy in this category, the homebrewers outpost 5 gallon plastic carboy has a convenient design. It does not hold odor, break down, or scratch like plastic. It is perfect for 5 gallon primary fermentations, as there is enough headspace to reduce the need for a blow off.Why We Like This:
- Good investment for long term
- One of the new comers and featured product
Best Plastic Carboy: home brew Ohio 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy
Buy on Amazon
Home Brew Ohio offers a variety of carboy for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. This is a great sub for the glass carboy. It cleans up so much better than the ones with ridges inside. It is great for making sure your wine fermentor is steralized. These are lightweight and work nicely for making wine.Why We Like This:
- Smoother than better bottle/easier to clean
- Lot of satisfied buyers
Best value for money: Vintage shop 5 Gallon Plastic Carboy
Buy on Amazon
The vintage shop 5 gallon plastic carboy's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. It works well with the pump. The oversized caps and bung plugs fit all pet bottles including the better bottle. The opening is the size right for the airlock plug and is clear and light to handle. It’s very easy to clean, since the sides and bottom are nice and smooth.Why We Like This:
- Super clear, sturdy, and easy to handle and clean
- Lightweight and sturdy enough to hold its contents
- Very good quality, just right thickness
