The 8 Best 5 Gallon Water Jug Screw Caps (2023 reviews)

If you often find yourself scrambling for good cap, gofriipai 5 gallon water jug screw cap should be your first option for buying. These are great if you’re refilling your own jugs. They're easy to puncture when putting on the dispenser, and since it's reusable, it should save money in the long run and no more wasting caps. It is used for a screw bottle when the bottle stands up. It can be stored on their sides with no fear of leaks.

These are easy to get on and off but the plug does not always stay in place well. It is great for alternative to the hard plastic caps. These are perfect to fit on 5 gallon refillable water jugs.

Why We Like This:

Dishwasher safe, when get dirty just put into dishwasher, easy to clean
Material is similar to those high heat resistant silicone
More plastic caps that are hard to pry off and waste money

Best For Spigot: Sanitro 5 Gallon Water Jug Screw Cap

Buy on Amazon

The sanitro 5 gallon water jug screw cap is specially designed for your daily usage and has all useful features. These lids fit this bottle easily and it easily fits the Primo dispenser. They are replacement bottle caps. They are THREADED caps, not caps for the type of bottle that Crystal Geyser uses with the round lip. They fit standard 3 gal water jugs just like they're supposed to & they don't leak. They are white and easy to find.

The bottle's outer diameter at the top of the neck opening should either measure 48 mm or 53 mm. It does not pop on or snap on.

Why We Like This:

Perfect fit for 5 gallon carboy
More drip drip drip during transport
Perfect match of the original screw top
Works great, will fit 5 gallon, 3 gallon

Best For Plastic Water Bottles: Striludo 5 Gallon Water Jug Screw Cap

Buy on Amazon

The striludo 5 gallon water jug screw cap's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. These refilling 5 gallons lids are a great solution for indoor and outdoor water storage and all kinds of water dispensers. This 3 pack-5 gallon water jug covers are made of good quality silicone and they work great so far. They just pop in and seal off the water perfectly. They fit well and are a great replacement for the store.

This 5 gallon water bottle caps has no drips, spills or leaks, even when you put the kettle on its side. It is designed for plastic water bottles and glass bottles.

Why We Like This:

More plastic wrap and rubber bands
Fits perfectly over the 5 gallon bottle
Perfect fit for primo 5 gallon 55mm lids
Works great for 5 gallon jugs

Best For Water Storage: MYLOLF 5 Gallon Water Jug Screw Cap

Buy on Amazon

Mylolf makes beautiful and great cap with classic and smartly choosen materials. The MYLOLF [6PCS] 3 & 5 Gallon Water Jug Cap makes storage and refilling of five gallon containers very easy. These are the caps you want, if you don't want to deal with a jug that tipped over and leaked all over. They come assembled properly with the retaining loop and cap on the inside so after you wash them put them back together the same way and you’re all set. These are pretty light and will get blasted around the dishwasher by the jets.

These are perfect to have on hand if you need a replacement cap for larger water jugs. It comes with food-grade silicone material like the reusable water jug cap, and made thicker processing to make it more sturdy and durable, does not break easily. They are very helpful for refilling and reusing water jugs.

Why We Like This:

Saves water and mess with no leakage
Need to worry about the plug falling into the water jug at all
Works with the primo water jugs

Best For American Maid Bottles: Toymis 5 Gallon Water Jug Screw Cap

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another cap that manages to win our hearts. It's the toymis 5 gallon water jug screw cap and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient cap you can buy. These silicone water bottle caps are very useful, widely used in home, office, school, camping, sports activities, match, etc. It fits the american maid 5 gallon water bottle. It comes with an inner buckle that can be removed, so it can be used in a water dispenser.

This water jug cap has worked very well. It is easy to clean and reusable, saving you time and energy. The caps are easy to put on and off. They are easy to remove and make changing out the bottles in the cooler easy. It is perfect for american maid bottles.

Why We Like This:

Works with primo pump and american made bottles
Great option for hard to find screw on tops
Delivers what they promise

Best Cap: Yevheniys 5 Gallon Water Jug Screw Cap

Buy on Amazon

The flexible silicone cap is easy to install and remove, suitable for home or office use. It works for transporting and storing the jugs. Although the caps fit snug on the bottles, they are super easy to remove but not so easy as to allow the caps to pop off on their own.

The caps fit in the neck of the bottle snuggly and they have a lip that fits over the opening well. They keep the water secure. It can prevent dust from entering the bottle, ensuring that your drinking water remains pure and fresh. It is easy to clean, soak the cap in warm water for a while before using it for the first time.

Why We Like This:

A little snug going on but fits great and doesn't leak
Worked good and do not leak
Fits three gallon and five gallon jugs
Secure fit that’s easy to remove

Best idea: Zerone 5 Gallon Water Jug Screw Cap

Buy on Amazon

The zerone 5 gallon water jug screw cap's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. They are pretty tough to get off too. They thread on and stay on without any fuss. It fits more secure into the dispenser to prevent water leakage when replacing the water bottle on the unit. It is fit for a 5.5cm outlet water bottle with screw thread, refill your water jug for recycling use and saving money, no need for disposable water caps. They are made of food grade plastic material, this is safe, harmless and reusable.

Why We Like This:

Superior quality food grade plastic material
53 mm bottles with screw-on caps
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For keeping debris: Koomduk 5 Gallon Water Jug Screw Cap

Buy on Amazon

The koomduk 5 gallon water jug screw cap's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. These caps are perfect to keep the water clean and from splashing out in transport. Not only are they durable, but they are also reusable, making them an eco-friendly choice. Because they are soft silicone, they will last a lot longer than the hard plastic ones. They stay in place and prevent leaks and spills. They're durable and easy to clean, but the center stoppers in them don't stay sealed all that well if you're moving the jugs around.

These caps are made of thickened silicone and are built to last. The small inner cap makes it easier to put them in a water dispenser with less spillage. They're very nice, however, for if you use any sort of configuration of hose-fed water pump, because they allow the bulk of the opening to be sealed while still giving you a hole to pass the supply tube through.

Why We Like This: