The 7 Best All Natural Apple Butter (2023 reviews)

We consider a all natural apple butter to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Amish Wedding All Natural Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best with bagels: Buy: Mccutcheons All Natural Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best For your morning toast: Buy: Green Jay Gourmet All Natural Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best with anything: Buy: Redhawk Farms All Natural Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best with Stevia: Buy: Walden Farms All Natural Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best premium: Buy: Eden foods All Natural Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best value For money: Buy: Eden All Natural Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Amish Wedding All Natural Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

There are so many apple butter products out there but this one is the best flavor thickness and goes with so many things and does not overpower it. Creamy and delicious, this apple butter is the best topping for warm muffins and morning toast. It is delicious on toast alone or with butter or cream cheese. It is good as cracker barrel’s. Old-fashioned, all-natural apple butter for prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in amish wedding foods' apple butter. It is good as a cracker barrel’s. The mix of flavors are the best ever.

• Awesome flavor and easy to spread
• Very tasty and just the right amount of sugar
• Spreadable and holds its shape on bread
• Homemade quality and flavor with a little hint of cinnamon

Best with bagels: Mccutcheons All Natural Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The mccutcheons all natural apple butter is capable of outshining several other butter featured in this list in overall features for the price point. Apple butter is a highly concentrated form of apple sauce produced by long, slow cooking of apples with cider or water to a point where the sugar in the apples caramelizes, turning the apple butter a deep brown. This is by far the most scrumptious apple butter out there. It makes a good fruit butter spread.

The Apple Butter Pull Apart Bread comes out perfect. It is made from a time-tested family recipe, it's slow cooked in small batches for a rich, mellow flavor that's lightly spiced with a hint of sweetness. It is perfect for toast, or as filling for cakes, donut or sandwiches. It is great for teacher, hostess or holiday gifts.

• Great taste and smooth the way apple butter should be
• Not too sweet and just the right amount of spice
• New and hot release

Best For your morning toast: Green Jay Gourmet All Natural Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Green jay gourmet fruit butter products contain no corn syrup, preservative or msg. It works with most recipes & foods. It is good on toast, with peanut butter and ice-cream. The consistency is VERY, VERY runny and watery, too difficult to coop and spread with a knife, and a little too sweet for some uses.

It is made with premium, juicy apples & laced with hints of cinnamon & secret spices, green jay gourmet apple butter is just about as delicious as fruit spreads or fruit butters can get. The Peach Butter is delicious. All Green jay gourmet fruit butter flavors use all-natural, real food ingredients. It is great on toast, with peanut butter and ice-cream.

• Tastes peachy and not overly sweet
• Taste good and not too sweet
• Great on cracker/cream cheese, biscuits or just a spoonful out of the jar

Best with anything: Redhawk Farms All Natural Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable butter, redhawk farms all natural apple butter should be your first option for buying. This Redhawk farms apple spread combines all natural, simple ingredients slow cooked together and jarred for peak freshness and flavor. It works great in place of any jelly/jam, and has a very sweet, thick flavor. The apple and brown sugar come through well. It is made from responsibly sourced, premium ingredients, and cooked with care in small batches in ohio’s amish country.

This is a delicious apple butter, but is so sugary that it's probably best enjoyed in small portions. The spice mix is delicate and wonderful. The Redhawk farms apple spread combines all natural, simple ingredients slow cooked together and jarred for peak freshness and flavor. It's also very festive with those traditional fall flavors.

• Flavor is really balanced, not too sweet, no ingredient/spice overpowers
• Really good balance of flavor and thickness
• Meets all expectations for taste and texture
• Fantastic flavor, not too spiced or sweet

Best with Stevia: Walden Farms All Natural Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Best part: walden farms all natural apple butter costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. Start your day off right with this apple butter spread and your entire day will be awesome. A balance of real apple and natural flavors, this apple butter fruit spread is the perfect way to start your day. It's made with concentrated fruit extracts and natural flavors and is perfect for toast, bagels, muffins or as a mix-in with yogurt. It also doesn't have all the calories apple butter has.

This has a really good apple flavor and when it's warm, it looses that medicinal taste. It makes it sort of difficult to spread on toast or a bagel, it tastes downright fantastic and for no calories, it is the best weight. If you are looking for an apple jelly this is great. It's thicker than usual apple butters, but it is still amazing.

• Tastes really good considering zero calories
• Good investment for long term

Best premium: Eden foods All Natural Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The eden foods all natural apple butter's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. This is the best Apple butter ever. It is used to make applebutter and cook it outside all day and boil cider and add apples and it is so good. It is good as flavoring in yogurt or on today or a pb&j sandwich. This is a natural and healthy apple butter and it's delicious.

This is delicious apple butter, with no added sugar or artificial sweeteners. It's such a healthy snack just alone off the spoon or you can put it on toast, waffles, bagels and graham crackers and you can even bake with it.

• Delicious, no added sugar and organic
• Spices just appple and cider no added sugar
• Best sugar free spice free applebutter
• Excellent product for baking or toast

Best value For money: Eden All Natural Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The look and feel of this butter are consistent with the decent quality we're used to from the rest of Eden's lineup. Childhood memories of the perfect apple will make your heart sing when you taste this. America's test kitchen has an easy recipe for slow-cooker onion soup that calls for some apple butter. Not only does this apple butter taste good, but there are only 2 ingredients. It's great on toast or a bagel or just by itself.

This apple butter is made without added sugar and has a terrific taste. The color is dominately brown with a bit of red that makes it, visually, more appealing. Despite the "no sugar, " this one has a delicious taste. It's a great substitute for an apple chutney.

• The most delicious apple butter ever
• Ingredients organic apples, organic apple juice concentrate
• Smooth and has an awesome taste
• High fructose, artifical, man made, nonnatural, sweetener