The 7 Best All natural Eye primers (2023 reviews)

We consider a all natural eye primer to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Milani All natural Eye Primer READ REVIEW

Best For more natural look: Buy: Revlon All natural Eye Primer READ REVIEW

Best For creasing: Buy: NYX professional Makeup All natural Eye Primer READ REVIEW

Best For sensitive skin: Buy: All natural Eye Primer READ REVIEW

Best For older eyes: Buy: Gabriel cosmetics All natural Eye Primer READ REVIEW

Best For older women: Buy: Ilia All natural Eye Primer READ REVIEW

Best PREMIUM: Buy: Luneaster All natural Eye Primer READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Milani All natural Eye Primer

Buy on Amazon

Here, we review primer that manages to win our hearts. It's the milani all natural eye primer and it's widely considered as one of best primer you can buy. The Milani eye primer has amazing staying power. It goes on smooth and it just takes a very little bit to stay on throughout the day. The eyeshadow colors show up much more vibrant and really help stay on throughout the day. It's an excellent base for your eye shadow though.

The intended use of the primer is purely for the eye lids. It takes a pea size amount to make any eyeshadow and makeup pop. It's easy to apply and remove. It makes show and liner stay on all day. This is a great inexpensive shadow primer.

• Goes on easy, absorbs well, keeps eyeshadow in place for a full day
• Amazing inexpensive dupe for urban decay primer potion
• Prepares eyelid nicely for eyeshadow application

Best For more natural look: Revlon All natural Eye Primer

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase primer for their daily usage, but the revlon all natural eye primer would be an anomoly. The Revlon photoready perfecting prime is a revolutionary, lightweight primer that helps soften skin and diffuses light to help minimize flaws and even out skin texture. It works well under all eyeshadow. It creates a perfect canvas so that your foundation will glide on more evenly and smoothly. It has some shimmer to brighten, but its not overly done or crazy.

It doesn’t conceal or correct color. It also creases in the eyelid. It looks natural and fresh. It is good for a more natural look (alone) but plan on using a brush or applicator.

• Covers dark circles and causes the shadow to stay in place
• Good product and keeps the eye makeup on for hours
• Delivers what they promise

Best For creasing: NYX professional Makeup All natural Eye Primer

Buy on Amazon

The nyx professional makeup all natural eye primer should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. This product puts a matte finish that keeps liner and shadow from smearing. It is super creamy with a soft blurring effect. It can be worn on it's own for a lightweight natural look. It will cover light discoloration but nothing too dark.

The primer helps keep liner and shadow in place all day and helps reduce need for reapplication. It is easy to apply and works. It is thicker like a primer and just ever so sticky. It is great to be used for any type of eyeshadow such as powdery, matte or glittery ones as it makes the eyeshadow stays all day long without any problem.

• Easily comes off with regular eye makeup remover
• Drys too fast no time to blend shadows
• Very tacky (for better and worse) not the most hygienic applicator
• Easy to apply, eye shadow still looks great at the end of the day

Best For sensitive skin: All natural Eye Primer

Buy on Amazon

The all natural eye primer is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. This primer makes your lashes long and thick and ready for mascara (blink, of course) to work its magic. It builds your lashes and it doesn't take a lot of mascara to make your lashes look full and long. It takes a bit of practice because the product is thick and the tufts of the brush are very short. The primer gives your lashes a fuller longer look naturally.

This primer makes your mascara adhere to your lashes and makes them thicker and longer. It removes automatically along with your mascara or on its own with lots of warm water. The primer is a bit heavy after a few uses. It actually could look kind of lovely for a fun makeup look.

• Makes lashes long and lush, washes off so easily
• Makes mascara go on quicker and lashes look thicker
• Really helps with the mascara and makes the lashes look longer and separate

Best For older eyes: Gabriel cosmetics All natural Eye Primer

Buy on Amazon

The gabriel cosmetics all natural eye primer should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. This product is great for people with dry eyelids. It covers what you want it to cover, and goes on smoothly. It has a moderate hazard rating for lecithin and tocopheryl acetate. It is perfect for chemically sensitive people. This is a beautiful matte grey-violet color. It can be used in a long time. It has good coverage, and only requires one application each day. This is very nice and goes on well and stays.

• Good shade for puffy white lids
• Light gray with a hint of lavender
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For older women: Ilia All natural Eye Primer

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for appropriate and satisfactory primer, ilia all natural eye primer should be your first option for buying. This brilliant eye primer creates the ideal canvas, sure to keep shadows + liner looking on point all day, illuminating eyes while locking pigments into place. It instantly illuminates your eyes with a radiant sheen. It is an anti-inflammatory that helps to de-puff. It’s great for older women.

This product is sheer with a slight shimmer, very slight. It does need an extra bit of time to dry before applying eyeshadow, but it’s worth it. It is great for older women.

• Feels nice on, not thick, mostly transparent, while providing enough coverage
• Dries fast, eyeshadow looks great after
• Helps to rejuvinate and improve moisture level

Best PREMIUM: Luneaster All natural Eye Primer

Buy on Amazon

The luneaster all natural eye primer is the best quality primer on the market today. This creamy, lightweight vegan eyelid primer neutralizes darkness, discoloration and other imperfections to create a fresh, bright. Formulated with vitamin E, licorice extract and apple seed extract, it helps to hydrate and brighten, while providing a soft-focus, illuminating base to keep eyeshadows in place throughout the day. The Licorice extract helps to support skin's elasticity, soothe irritation and reduce redness.

• Neutralizes darkness, discoloration and other imperfections to create a fresh, bright
• Helps to hydrate and brighten to illuminate the eye area
• Good investment for long term