The 6 Best Amish Made headstalls (2023 reviews)

The headstall is a must have add-on for your regular usage. These spur straps are even more beautiful in person. Love this breast collar because it’s adorable and great quality. The leather is soft and flexible but has a good body to it and is well made. The beaded is very well made and nicely stitched. The leather is a dark rich oil color, and the beading is so detailed. The beaded is impeccable and the little details you see in person are more than you can expect from the picture. The beading is impeccable and the little details you see in person are more than you can expect from the picture.

Why We Like This:

Much prettier in person and very soft
Beautiful breast collar but runs small
Delivers what they promise

Best For hackamore: Weaver Lear FAVORITE Bridle

Buy on Amazon

The weaver lear favorite bridle is capable of outshining several other headstall featured in this list in overall features in its price range. This headstall is made of very pliable leather and is nicely oiled. It features floral engraved conchos and nickel brass spots at the browband. It adjusts on both sides allowing you to fit it on many different sized horses. It looks fabulous with the weaver leather horizons and split reins. The bit "buckles" are somewhat thick and bulky. This headstall is heavy and fantastic in quality. It allows you to change out what mouth gear you want.

Why We Like This:

Amazing quality and super soft leather, no need to break in
Looks great, has a nice butter feel, and easy to change bits
Good investment for long term

Best With Throat Latch: Weaver Lear Amish Made Headstall

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase headstall for their daily usage, but the weaver lear amish made headstall would be an anomoly. It should work, this is a headstall made for big horses. It looks great and of high quality construction/material. It is adjustable for length. This is a beautiful bridle, the leather is very soft. It is also available as a roper rein. It’s well made and nice looking.

Why We Like This:

Black premium english bridle leather highlighted with nickel brass spots
Precise stitching pairs with smoothed and darkened edges for a refined look
Good quality leather, good quality hardware, great attention to details

Best With snaffle Bit: Nrs-Berlin custom Leather Amish Made Headstall

Buy on Amazon

The nrs-berlin custom leather amish made headstall is the best reliable headstall on the market today. It is easy to adjust, and like a rope halter, it can accomodate a wide range of head sizes. It is made of strong, durable 1/4" diamond braided polypropylene rope with a core. The slits for the ears are very nice and easy to move. It stays on very well without a brow band or throat latch. The quick change adjustments allow you to go as small or big as needed.

It fits many different sizes and it is designed to fit a wide variety of horses from colt to older. The rope is not too stiff, but not too soft or limp either. The rope is not too soft, but not too soft or limp either.

Why We Like This:

Can adjust it quickly to accommodate for horses of different size needs
Fast adjustment for bits and sizes
Delivers what they promise

Best With Silver: Tough 1 Amish Made Headstall

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention tough 1 amish made headstall for daily purpose. It slides across the crown to go over either ear. It fits well, no rubbing or pinching anywhere. The hardware is good quality too and is very easy to change out bits and adjust. It comes with basketweave throughout and a square cheek design.

Why We Like This:

Nice stitching, quality leather, suited for average sized horses
Good investment for long term

Best head stall: Challenger Amish Made Headstall

Buy on Amazon

The challenger amish made headstall is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage.

Why We Like This:

Double stitched with a soft latigo liner
Very well made, quality is impeccable
Very good leather quality and construction