The 9 Best Apple Butter (2023 reviews)

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a butter. The musselmans apple butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. This type of apple butter would also be a good stand. It is perfect complement to apple butter and peanut butter sandwiches. It has apples, sugar, high fruitose, apple cider, cinnamon, cloves, and corn syrup. The texture is like a smooth slightly thicker applesauce and tastes like apple cider almost. It is non gmo, non high fructose corn syrup, gluten free, dairy free and 30 cals per serving. It is simply like any jelly or preserves that you would apply on toast. It can be used in a new recipe with glazed pork loin chops.

Why We Like This:

Tasty stuff, great on toast or in a pastry
Feel great about the simple ingredients too with no high fructose corn syrup
Great alternative on pancakes and waffles
Spiced apple sauce that's simmered down thick and spreadable

Best Spread: Eden Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

If you are currently in the market looking for a reliable butter for your daily usage, you cannot go wrong with the eden apple butter. This is a versatile tangy sweet spread that makes healthy eating an easy pleasure. It doesn’t taste too sweet and it is good on everything including toast, muffins, crackers, and even by the spoonful all by itself. It’s also very comforting as a spread when one is under the weather.

This stuff is great on English muffins. There are no added sugars or spices to mask the taste and quality of apples. There's enough sweet to keep it from being tart, but enough to keep just a hint of the tart and to bring out the flavor. It only requires enough force to make that center button on the center of the lid to pop up.

Why We Like This:

A natural sweetness that isn’t overwhelmingly sweet
Fresh apple taste is most predominant without overpowering spices
Organic apples, 2% organic apple juice concentrate
Spread on bread, muffins, pancakes and waffles, or use in baking

Best For ages: Amish Valley products Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about appropriate and satisfactory butter, amish valley products apple butter is your end point. It’s good apple butter for ages. If you're an apple butter lover, this one will not disappoint. It is made in ohio's amish country 16 oz glass jar. It has a great balance between the sugar, spices and apples. This has that fresh apple taste and it has no added sugar. This is so good on a biscuit. It is perfect for the apple butter-lover in the family.

Why We Like This:

Great basic recipe without sugar added
Very good product for the holiday seasons as well
Sweetened with apple juice, wonder taste and consistency

Best Quality Product: Dillman farm family owned since 1970 Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate butter. The dillman farm family owned since 1970 apple butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. If you are eating a low carb or sugar-free diet, this apple butter is probably the right level of sweetness for you. It is made with sweeter apples that have more natural sugars and taste too sweet. It does not taste "sweet" but it is really good. It also fits into a low carb lifestyle at just 2 grams of carbohydrate per tablespoon serving.

This apple butter is delicious and the ingredient list is as simple as it gets, just organic apples and organic cinnamon. The Tasty product has the right amount of organic cinnamon and the best part is that it is made from organic apples on a family owned farm. The apple butter has a thick consistency.

Why We Like This:

Exceptional organic apple butter with only 2 ingredients
Organic, no sugar added, crisp clean taste with just the right amount of sweetness
Nice topping for bagel chips, biscuits, crackers, etc
Delicious flavor on bread, peanut butter, waffles

Best with anything: Redhawk Farms Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate butter. The redhawk farms apple butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. This apple butter meets all expectations for taste and texture. The Redhawk Farm apple spread combines all natural, simple ingredients slow cooked together and jarred for peak freshness and flavor. The ingredient list gives a bunch of sweeteners separately, "sugar" and "brown sugar" as well as apple juice concentrate, a slightly deceptive practice. It's nice and thick, but easily spreads.

The apple and brown sugar come through well. It spreads wonderfully on bread and tastes great with anything from yogurt to cheese. It's not too spicy, or too sweet. It's just 35 calories per tablespoon. It would make a nice gift with some biscuits or fresh bread.

Why We Like This:

Meets all expectations for taste and texture
Fantastic flavor, not too spiced or sweet
Flavor is really balanced, not too sweet, no ingredient/spice overpowers
Really good balance of flavor and thickness

Best For spreading on breads: Jake & Amos Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other butter in this category, the jake & amos apple butter has a convenient design. Bold apple flavor blends perfectly with warm spices and just the right amount of sweetness, resulting in rich color and fabulous texture and flavor. It is great for spreading on breads, rolls, muffins, toast, pancakes, adding to cottage cheese or as a dessert ingredient.

Why We Like This:

Good brand reputation
Good investment for long term

Best premium: Kauffman'S Fruit farm Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing less than best quality butter, then kauffman's fruit farm apple butter is the one you should definitely consider, as it manages to bring a lot to the table. It’s an authentic, homemade, small batch fruit product without any added preservatives. Instead, it’s a fruit delicacy with a spreadable consistency like soft butter that’s delicious on bagels, crackers, toast, and ice cream.

Why We Like This:

Use on toast, bagels, butter bread, and ice cream
Fresh apples, fresh-pressed apple cider, and cinnamon
One of the new comers and featured product

Best Flavor: Eden foods Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The eden foods apple butter's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. This is a natural and healthy apple butter and it's delicious. It is used to make applebutter and cook it outside all day or a pb&j sandwich. It is good as flavoring in yogurt or on today or a pb&j sandwich. This is delicious apple butter, with no added sugar or artificial sweeteners. It is very low sugar, low calorie, simple ingredients, and very tasty.

These are organic and taste pretty good. It's such a healthy snack just off the spoon or you can put it on toast, waffles, bagels and graham crackers and you can even bake with it. This is a great lean option.

Why We Like This:

Delicious, no added sugar and organic
Sugar added and spiced very well
Best sugar free spice free applebutter

Best value For money: cracker Barrell Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The cracker barrell apple butter is worth the price and fits well with your regular usage. It is good as eating at the ctacker barrel. It can be used in a recipe to "spruce up" the taste.

Why We Like This:

Perfect flavor, nice consistency, like homemade applesauce but better
Lot of satisfied buyers