The 5 Best Apple Butter spreads (2023 reviews)

It is important to have the well suited apple butter spread. In the following post, we will help you to select the best apple butter spreads.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Eden Apple Butter Spread Buy: READ REVIEW

Green Jay Gourmet Apple Butter Spread Buy: READ REVIEW

Redhawk Farms Apple Butter Spread Buy: READ REVIEW

Jake & Amos Apple Butter Spread Buy: READ REVIEW

Walden Farms Apple Butter Spread Buy: READ REVIEW

Eden Apple Butter Spread

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate spread. The eden apple butter spread is exactly that - it's a simple spread that hits all the right notes. This is made from organic apples. It is good on everything including toast, muffins, crackers, and even by the spoonful all by itself. It only requires enough force to make that center button on the center of the lid to pop up. There are no added sugars or spices to mask the taste and quality of apples.

It’s also very comforting as a spread when one is under the weather. There's enough sweet to keep it from being tart, but enough to keep just a hint of the tart and to bring out the flavor. It is so tasty and not a lot of sugar.

• Organic apples, 2% organic apple juice concentrate
• Other added sugar, no preservatives, no spices, no unnecessary additives
• Good investment for long term

Green Jay Gourmet Apple Butter Spread

Buy on Amazon

The green jay gourmet apple butter spread is specially designed for your daily usage and has all useful features. All green jay gourmet fruit butter flavors use all-natural, real food ingredients. It tastes so fresh and natural. It works with most recipes & foods. It is made with premium, juicy apples & laced with hints of cinnamon & secret spices, green jay gourmet apple butter is just about as delicious as fruit spreads or fruit butters can get.

The consistency is VERY, VERY runny and watery, too difficult to coop and spread with a knife, and a little too sweet for some uses. The peach butter is extremely yummy on bread, biscuits, and it has a very fresh taste. If you like a hawaiian style flavor, this would be an absolutely PERFECT glaze for a baked chicken breast smothered in sweet peppers, or even an oven roasted pork chop with some red onions and sweet pepers.

• Taste good and not too sweet
• Great on cracker/cream cheese, biscuits or just a spoonful out of the jar
• Tastes peachy and not overly sweet

Redhawk Farms Apple Butter Spread

Buy on Amazon

The redhawk farms apple butter spread is capable of outshining several other spread featured in this list in overall features for the price point. Sugar is actually a form of natural preservative and it does have a bit of sugar. It's a yummy apple butter. It's nice and thick, but easily spreads. The ingredient list gives a bunch of sweeteners separately, "sugar" and "brown sugar" as well as apple juice concentrate, a slightly deceptive practice. It is made from responsibly sourced, premium ingredients, and cooked with care in small batches in ohio’s amish country.

The apple butter has a smooth consistency and is perfect for adding to toast with butter, oatmeal, yogurt, smoothies, and more. It is not too thin that this runs and not so thick you can’t spread it.

• Flavor is really balanced, not too sweet, no ingredient/spice overpowers
• Really good balance of flavor and thickness
• Fantastic flavor, not too spiced or sweet

Jake & Amos Apple Butter Spread

Buy on Amazon

The jake & amos apple butter spread should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. Bold apple flavor blends perfectly with warm spices and just the right amount of sweetness, resulting in rich color and fabulous texture and flavor. It is great for spreading on breads, rolls, muffins, toast, pancakes, adding to cottage cheese or as a dessert ingredient.

• New and hot release
• Good investment for long term

Walden Farms Apple Butter Spread

Buy on Amazon

Start your day off right with this apple butter spread and your entire day will be awesome. A balance of real apple and natural flavors, this apple butter fruit spread is the perfect way to start your day. It offers a full line of specialty condiments and food enhancers with zero calories, zero net carbs, zero sugar, zero fat. Make this amazing spread to impress guests, serve at parties, or simply enjoy magical mornings every day.

For a more exciting breakfast time, spread this apple butter on toast, muffins, pancakes, and oatmeal, or add it to cottage cheese, yogurt, and other baked goods. It is made with concentrated fruit extracts and natural flavors and is perfect for toast, bagels, muffins or as a mix-in with yogurt. It can be used as a flavor enhancement and it is perfect. The Orthodox Union certifies all Walden Farms products to be Kosher.

• Lot of satisfied buyers
• Good brand reputation