The 7 Best Apple Cinnamon Butter (2023 reviews)

We consider a apple cinnamon butter to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Musselmans Apple Cinnamon Butter READ REVIEW

Best Runner up: Buy: Dickinsons Apple Cinnamon Butter READ REVIEW

Best with most recipes: Buy: Green Jay Gourmet Apple Cinnamon Butter READ REVIEW

Best For ages: Buy: Amish Valley products Apple Cinnamon Butter READ REVIEW

Best Quality Product: Buy: Dillman farm family owned since 1970 Apple Cinnamon Butter READ REVIEW

Best For spreading on breads: Buy: Jake & Amos Apple Cinnamon Butter READ REVIEW

Best premium: Buy: Kauffman'S Fruit farm & market Apple Cinnamon Butter READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Musselmans Apple Cinnamon Butter

Buy on Amazon

The musselmans apple cinnamon butter is long-lasting, rigid and fits well with your daily purpose like a dream.

• Much healthier than most jellies, jams, preserves
• Great on biscuits, toast and peanut butter sandwich
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best Runner up: Dickinsons Apple Cinnamon Butter

Buy on Amazon

We are personally inclined towards dickinsons apple cinnamon butter, it is not so pricy, but it overachieves its purpose and outstanding in important aspects. Recreating the flavor of a baked-from-scratch pie, Dickinson's Fruit Butters are rich, dark and thick, with hints of cinnamon and sugar. They make a variety of fruit products all extremely well. This is chunky like fine apple sauce and has the tartness of fresh apples.

• Very flavorful & easily spreads as it's not too thick
• Ingredients apples, high fructose corn syrup, corn syrup, vinegar, sugar, spices, salt
• Good brand reputation

Best with most recipes: Green Jay Gourmet Apple Cinnamon Butter

Buy on Amazon

Green jay gourmet fruit butters bring to you the familiar, comforting butter experience with a whole lot of fruity, spicy flavors you won’t find elsewhere. Apple pecan butter, with its rich flavor profile, is a perfect addition to your favorite foods, from sandwiches & grilled chicken to parfaits & croissants. It’s crafted meticulously to maintain consistency that works with most recipes & foods.

All green jay gourmet fruit butter flavors use all-natural, real food ingredients. It is made with juicy apples, nutty pecans & laced with cinnamon, green jay gourmet apple pecan butter is just about as delicious as fruit spreads or fruit butters can get. The rich, fruity, spicy flavor profile is made even more luxurious with its creamy, crunchy texture. Green jay gourmet fruit butter products contain no corn syrup, preservative or msg.

• Gluten-free & trans-fat free apple butter for guilt-free gourmet indulgences
• Fruit spreads that can deliciously replace the same-old, boring butter
• Real food ingredients, bold flavors, no junk & the sheer joy of gourmet

Best For ages: Amish Valley products Apple Cinnamon Butter

Buy on Amazon

The amish valley products apple cinnamon butter is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily usage. If you're an apple butter lover, this one will not disappoint. It’s good apple butter for ages. It is made in ohio's amish country 16 oz glass jar. It has a great balance between the sugar, spices and apples. This has that fresh apple taste and it has no added sugar. This is so good on a biscuit. It is perfect for the apple butter-lover in the family.

• Great basic recipe without sugar added
• Very good product for the holiday seasons as well
• Great and best apple butter ever

Best Quality Product: Dillman farm family owned since 1970 Apple Cinnamon Butter

Buy on Amazon

The dillman farm family owned since 1970 apple cinnamon butter's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. This apple butter is absolutely delicious plus it's guilt free with no sugar, no artificial sweeteners and no additives. It's tart with just the right amount of natural sweetness and cinnamon flavor. It is made with sweeter apples that have more natural sugars and taste too sweet. It also fits into a low carb lifestyle at just 2 grams of carbohydrate per tablespoon serving.

The Tasty product has the right amount of organic cinnamon and the best part is that it is made from organic apples on a family owned farm. It tastes sweet enough even though there is no added sugar.

• Exceptional organic apple butter with only 2 ingredients
• Won’t break the bank in terms of calories
• Thick, exploding with apple and cinnamon flavors and enhanced by the absence of sugar

Best For spreading on breads: Jake & Amos Apple Cinnamon Butter

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate butter. The jake & amos apple cinnamon butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. Bold apple flavor blends perfectly with warm spices and just the right amount of sweetness, resulting in rich color and fabulous texture and flavor. It is great for spreading on breads, rolls, muffins, toast, pancakes, adding to cottage cheese or as a dessert ingredient.

• Good brand reputation
• Good investment for long term

Best premium: Kauffman'S Fruit farm & market Apple Cinnamon Butter

Buy on Amazon

The kauffman's fruit farm & market apple cinnamon butter is long-lasting, rigid and fits well with your daily purpose like a dream. This is an excellent product,it's very tasty and great for people who have to watch their sugar intake. It is very tasty on toast, english muffins, etc. It is much lower in sugar than regular apple butter. It is a family staple that is ordered in the 6 jar quantity every few weeks.

The sugar in this delicious apple butter is only the natural sugar found in the apples, apple cider and cinnamon, this is as simple and tasty as you can get. The jars are packaged well, and there is no breakage, spillage or mess. This is wonderfully smooth with just enough spice to make it a great apple butter. The jars are large and definitely worth the money.

• Nice cinnamon bite to it and the consistency is just right
• Use on toast, bagels, butter bread, and ice cream
• Wonderful for anyone trying to limit sugar intake
• Fresh apples, freshly-pressed apple cider, and cinnamon