The 10 Best Backyard Horseshoes (2023 reviews)

We consider a backyard horseshoe to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Franklin Sports Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For Horseshoe pit: Buy: Champion Sports Great Set READ REVIEW

Best For outside Play time With The grandsons: Buy: Triumph Sports Backyard Horseshoe READ REVIEW

Best For an Outdoor wedding: Buy: Franklin Sports Backyard Horseshoe READ REVIEW

Best For indoors: Buy: Champion Sports Backyard Horseshoe READ REVIEW

Best With ball: Buy: Baden Backyard Horseshoe READ REVIEW

Best flip Shoe: Buy: Thoroughbred Horseshoes Horseshoesonlinecom Backyard Horseshoe READ REVIEW

Best For money: Buy: Armstrong home Solutions Backyard Horseshoe READ REVIEW

Best High Quality Horseshoe: Buy: Elakai Backyard Horseshoe READ REVIEW

Best For All genders: Buy: NQV Backyard Horseshoe READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Franklin Sports Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

Here, we review horseshoe that manages to win our hearts. It's the franklin sports horseshoe set and it's widely considered as one of all-around great horseshoe you can buy. This set comes in a nice bag that is relatively compact for storage and tossing in a car. It comes with a nice zipper carry bag, two pair of horseshoes and a pair of spikes and instructions. It is made of metal, is weighty and can easily endure the punishment of years of regular use. The horseshoes are sturdy and come in a handy zip up bag. It’s heavy-weight and well finished.

The stakes are strong and sturdy and the shoes are of good quality. It is great for bbqs, picnics, or other outdoor events. Each set comes with a carrying case included so you can quickly pack the game up and bring it on the go, or store away easily when not in use.

• Perfect for the beach, backyard, an outing or your next party
• Hours of family fun and great for bbqs, picnics, or other outdoor events
• Delivers what they promise

Best For Horseshoe pit: Champion Sports Great Set

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate horseshoe. The champion sports great set is exactly that - it's a simple horseshoe that hits all the right notes. This is a heavy duty horseshoe set. It includes 4 solid steel pitching shoes and 2 durable 24 inch steel metal stakes. The weight is very nice and the posts are also heavy-duty. They look sharp...right out of the package. It is made of cast iron. The travel case is nice though if you want to put it in a camper for mobility. This set will help them build muscles.

• Nice and heavy for outdoor use
• Made very well and love that hard case
• Good brand reputation

Best For outside Play time With The grandsons: Triumph Sports Backyard Horseshoe

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention triumph sports backyard horseshoe for daily purpose. These are forged steel. It's steel, it'll last a long while and take a lot of use. This set is very durable and holds up nicely. It includes two 20" stakes with a silver hammer finish. The Case is very light and easy to pack around. It has a carrying handle and keeps everything from clanking around. It's made of good solid steel. It can be used in the backyard for years to come.

• Good for beginners and playing with kids
• Great for beginners and those teaching them
• Heavy duty, well made, nicely boxed

Best For an Outdoor wedding: Franklin Sports Backyard Horseshoe

Buy on Amazon

Franklin Sports offers a variety of horseshoe for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. This set of horseshoes are just about perfect for an outdoor wedding. The recreational horseshoe set comes complete with 4 steel horseshoes and 2 steel forged scoring stakes so you have everything you need to play. The stakes are less than 20" long, leaving you less than 6" of stake underground to (supposedly) hold up to throwing heavy pieces of metal at it. It's nice to tell the difference with the different colors when you're playing.

The steel construction of this set makes sure it is ready to play in all weather conditions so you can get the game going rain or shine. It is easy to pull out of the ground.

• Wedding reception game made great memories
• Hefty, good quality and great finish
• Easy to set up, just watch your underground piping
• Good fun with these horseshoes at thanksgiving with family

Best For indoors: Champion Sports Backyard Horseshoe

Buy on Amazon

Young and old love these Horseshoe Sets, they can be used indoor or outdoor. It is great for small backyard games. It comes with 4 horseshoes, 2 rubber mats with center pegs, and 2 red plastic dowels, this horseshoe set comes with everything needed to start a game in your backyard, on the playground, or in the gym.

These lightweight horseshoes are easy to throw and aim compared to traditional metal horseshoes, and their soft design also makes them safe to use for kids and adults. It is eaiser to twist them into the ground, instead of trying to hammer or push from the top, as they will split. The base is very lightweight and falls over easily but its good enough to have some fun with. This horseshoe game is suitable for indoor or outdoor use as it will not damage floors or walls during games and is sure to stay in place.

• Sturdy, nice, heavy shoes, and well made
• Fun game for everyone and the hard rubber horseshoes are perfect
• Great for the kids birthday party
• Excellent choice for children who are too small for regular horseshoes

Best With ball: Baden Backyard Horseshoe

Buy on Amazon

The baden backyard horseshoe is capable of outshining several other horseshoe featured in this list in overall features for the price point. This is a great set for the backyard. It comes in a 1680 denier durable nylon bag with reinforced pockets, dedicated storage compartments for horseshoes and stakes, and velcro handle for easy carrying. The shoes and stakes come in an attractive carrier which is nice to transport everything and also good if you are giving this as a gift.

The stakes and shoes are good quality also. They don't break, and are easy to carry. It will last for a long time.

• Up and a fun time for everyone from kids to adults
• Very sturdy, played all day and evening after building a horseshoe pit
• Well made set with carrying bag

Best flip Shoe: Thoroughbred Horseshoes Horseshoesonlinecom Backyard Horseshoe

Buy on Amazon

Thoroughbred Horseshoes Horseshoesonlinecom offers a variety of horseshoe for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. If you love tossing irons, these puppies are sweet. It is the most universal horseshoe in the thoroughbred line-up. It is the ultimate backyard shoe and it reaches far beyond that, as it is commonly pitched in league and tournament play all over the country, especially in doubles and team competitions. The option for the complete game set includes two official size cold rolled steel stakes, 1 " x 30 " and a guide booklet for playing horseshoes anywhere.

The symmetrical double-sided cleats on the tips provide great counterweight for easy flipping and turning. If you are sick of burs slicing your hands up, this softer iron is great. They should all last quite a while even with heavy pro-level usage. It is good in the hand and are easy to pitch.

• Meets official weight requirements & pairs match by weight
• Unique iron alloy that resists burring, and deforming
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For money: Armstrong home Solutions Backyard Horseshoe

Buy on Amazon

The armstrong home solutions backyard horseshoe is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily purpose. It is a family tradition game with the dads. It comes with an actual metal spiked pole set as opposed to those flimsy plastic stumps. The colors are nice and vibrant but the horseshoes are plastic and very light weight. It is great for ages two to five. The stakes are great heavy duty metal. It comes with a carrying case to store and make it more portable. It will still be rust-free after years of playing.

• Great horseshoes for kids at the beach
• Bright red and blue color horse shoes allow for easy scoring from far away
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best High Quality Horseshoe: Elakai Backyard Horseshoe

Buy on Amazon

Elakai is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist horseshoe for people on the go, and its line of elakai backyard horseshoe definitely falls in line with that reputation. If you are looking for wholesome family fun, this classic is a great addition. This is a great horseshoe set. It is composed of steel, they are sturdy, long-lasting, and have the ideal weight for throwing. The carrying case is superb also.

This is a very nice high quality horseshoe set. These are well constructed and look great. It works fine and is of course a fun game. It comes in a nice carrying case.

• More weight forged into tips for maximum balance and control
• Come in a convenient zippered pouch
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best For All genders: NQV Backyard Horseshoe

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase horseshoe for their regular usage, but the nqv backyard horseshoe would be an anomoly. This is a nice horseshoe set minus a few things. The Horseshoe game kit includes a custom nylon carrying bag for easy transport and storage of your horse shoes in the car, truck, van, or even while walking. The horseshoes are distinctly colored silver and black, and they do not scratch easily. The stake is two pieces which makes it easier to ship but it doesn't feel as solid in the ground. The set works well, plays well, and is durable.

Each horseshoe weighs around 2lbs and the stakes are very heavy duty and are threaded for more compact storage. It comes in is fairly flimsy but will last for a little while.

• Would also make a nice gift the way everything is packaged in the bag
• Toxic, no color lossing, no molting
• One of the new comers and featured product