There are plenty of options available while buying bathtub drain shoe gaskets in the market right now, and if you're confused regarding which one to go for, You have come to the right page.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Moen Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Solid Metal: Buy: Wholesale Plumbing Supply Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket READ REVIEW

Best With Polished Brass: Buy: Ldr Industries Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Heavy Duty: Buy: Westbrass Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Great Price: Buy: Artiwell Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Oil Rubbed Bronze: Buy: Kingston Brass Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Nice Look: Buy: Pf Waterworks Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Tip Toe: Buy: Dorence Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket READ REVIEW

Best Standard Design: Buy: Artiwell Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Moen Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The look and feel of these gaskets are consistent with the high quality we're used to from the rest of Moen's lineup. Moreover, the Moen Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket fits a 1-1/2" threaded drain plus it is highly reflective for a mirror-like look that works with any decorating style. Built on the moen m-pact common valve system, allowing you to update the faucet style in the future without replacing any plumbing. In addition, it is made for excellent fit and it is made with great quality. Finally, the moen bathtub drain shoe gasket is available in brushed gold and oil-rubbed bronze colors.

Most buyers quickly discovered that the gasket is a one-screw model and does not include an adapter. In addition, they also found that the gasket was a perfect fit and easy to install. Moreover, they say that the best part is that it comes with a lifetime warranty. Overall, buyers found this to be one of the best gaskets for daily purposes.

• This is assembled easily, it is made for a beautiful finish and works as designed.
• This fits larger tub drains and also fits single - hole drains.
• This is made in Taiwan and the quality is so so.
• Standard size: fits 1-1/2" threaded drain.

Best For Solid Metal: Wholesale Plumbing Supply Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate gasket. The Wholesale Plumbing Supply Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket is exactly that - it's a simple gasket that hits all the right notes. The wholesale plumbing supply bathtub drain shoe gasket works fine, It is great for good seal and has a nice shape. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, it fits perfectly and it comes with solid brass construction.

The gasket fits 1 3/8 inch or 1 1/2 inch waste elbows. Finally, the wholesale plumbing supply bathtub drain shoe gasket is very sturdy and it is attractive.

Most buyers quickly discovered that the gasket does not have the obstructions to let hair get stuck. In addition, a few also found that the gasket is much better quality for about the same price. Also, a few say that the assembly comes with a rubber gasket. use that to indicate tightness by looking for the gasket to “ swell or expand ” a bit out from the diameter of the drain fixture. Therefore, buyers were eager to recommend it to friends and would-be buyers.

• This fits perfectly and it has a very nice finish.
• This can really freeze in place after they have been in there a few years.
• This is great with a 3 year old that loves bath time.
• This works great, makes for nice quality and it is great for brand names.

Best With Polished Brass: Ldr Industries Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Ldr Industries Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket is capable of outshining several other gaskets featured in this list in overall features for the price point. The ldr industries bathtub drain shoe gasket is attractive, it looks beautiful and has a convenient design. The Lang toe style touch bathtub drain stopper is an ideal replacement for your bathtub stopper as it will give ease to your bathing experience by simply tapping close and open the drain. Further, the gasket has a push button and it is unsealed first.

The gasket fits like a charm and it is installed quickly. Above all, the ldr industries bathtub drain shoe gasket looks amazing, works great, it is super easy and has a great design.

Most customers agree that the gasket is a manual open and close device that should last much longer. And, they strongly agree that the gasket makes people think it looks crappy. And, they strongly agree that the gasket has good weight to it, finish looks great, chrome is very shiny and expensive looking.

• Includes drain rubber gasket with easy to follow do it yourself instructions.
• It is very sturdy and it does the job.
• This is a perfect job, very good value for the money.
• The manufacturer says: We are proud of the products we sell. You will be too.

Best For Heavy Duty: Westbrass Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Westbrass is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist gaskets for people on the go, and its line of Westbrass Bathtub Drain Shoe Gaskets definitely falls in line with that reputation. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. . To sum up, with a 4.5 rating and more than 4448 buyers, the westbrass bathtub drain shoe gasket stands as the best choice.

Most customers agree that the gasket is easy to adjust to any installation. And, a few say that the gasket is not plastic pipe but really that may be an advantage, with plastic offering more flexibility for alignment. Moreover, a few say that the gasket fits all claw foot tubs.

• Good investment for the long term.
• Good brand reputation.

Best For Great Price: Artiwell Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate gasket. The Artiwell Rubber Gasket is exactly that - it's a simple gasket that hits all the right notes. And, the artistic rubber gasket is designed for a great price, It went on easily and has a standard design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Further, it is designed for long-lasting durability. Above all, the artistic rubber gasket is available in 2 colors: brushed gold and matt black.

Most buyers agree that the gasket is easy to install as long as everything is centered correctly. Further, they also found that the gasket was sealed between the drain pipe and the tub. In conclusion, many customers have used the gasket for more than a few months without any complaints, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• It takes only 5 minutes to complete the installation.
• This fits 1-1/2" and 1-3/8" drain shoe sizes.
• This comes with great quality, works great, it is super easy and has a simple design.
• The manufacturer says: We are proud of the products we sell, you will be too.

Best For Oil Rubbed Bronze: Kingston Brass Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another gasket that manages to win our hearts. It's the Kingston brass bathtub drainshoe gasket and it's widely considered as the gasket that has the most suitable features. The Kingston brass bathtub drain shoe gasket includes threaded adapter bushing, strainer, overflow plate and bath shoe. Available in a range of popular finishes, so your bathroom coordinates flawlessly. And, the gasket is built for durable and reliable long - term use.

The gasket can enhance and elevate a tub’s look and functionality. Most importantly, the Kingston brass bathtubdrain shoegasket looks great and it is good for fast delivery.

Most buyers quickly discovered that the gasket works well so far and can also be replaced at no cost. And, they strongly agree that the gasket includes a plastic "enlarger" which can screw on the threads of the smaller size, so it's a two-for-one. To sum up, many have used the gasket for more than a few months without any complaints, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• Threaded adapter bushing fits 1-1/2" and 1-3/8" drain shoe sizes.
• This is designed with nice materials, works great and it is good for simple installation.
• Easy to work toe tap drain.
• This is the most frequently used material for kitchen and bath products.

Best For Nice Look: Pf Waterworks Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Pf Waterworks is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist gaskets for people on the go, and its line of Pf Waterworks Bathtub Drain Shoe Gaskets definitely falls in line with that reputation. The pf waterworks bathtub drain shoe gasket has matching drain shoe, works great and it is good for nice item. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, it is made with metal construction, is built with solid weight and it is super easy.

The gasket includes free haircatcher strainers which help prevent clogs. Also, the gasket works OK and it is built with great customer support. Most importantly, the pf waterworks bathtub drainshoe gasket allows for a nice look, is built with great quality and it is available in ch.

One customer says - "Highly recommend if you battle with clogged drains due to hair collection. ". Most buyers found that the gaskets are super responsive (replying within 15 minutes to all inquiries) and very accommodating. In conclusion, at the price, they believe that they got a steal of a deal with it.

• 3/8” or 5/16” thread to match the drain shoe.
• This works fine and it is best for a nice fit.
• This includes toe touch bath tub stopper and bathtub drain shoes with matching finish.
• Available in ch, bn, pb, ab, orb finishes.

Best For Tip Toe: Dorence Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Dorence bathtubdrain shoe gasket is specially designed for your daily purpose and has all useful features. The Dorence bathtub drain shoegasket feels very, It is good for universal fit and has a simple design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, this is designed to fit bath tub drain brands.

Most importantly, the Dorence bathtub drain shoe gasket looks so good, installed easily, it is rich and has a modern design.

Almost all customers found that the gasket is easy to remove the stopper to clean hair out of the drain. And, a few also found that the gasket is also a very heavy, good quality piece. In conclusion, most buyers found the gasket is functionally comfortable and no one questions it.

• This is because there's white tape overlapping the original to "reseal" the box.
• This is designed for excellent fit and has a standard design.
• Above the floor * easy do-it-yourself installation.
• These fit with plumber's putty to seal the tub drain.

Best Standard Design: Artiwell Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The artistic bathtub drain shoe gasket should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. The Artiwell Bathtub Drain Shoe Gasket is designed to fit both 1-5/8” in.-16 unc fine thread and 1-1/2” in.-11-1/2” npsm coarse thread bath shoe size, drain strainer with beehive strainer and screw. This designer trip lever waste and overflow trim kit is the decorative solution and the perfect finishing touch for your tub. Moreover, this has upgraded your bath, comes with product dimensions, it makes for solid construction and has great design.

The gasket is made with metal construction, it is best for high quality material and has a standard design. Above all, the artistic bathtub drain shoe gasket takes only 5 minutes to complete the installation.

Almost all buyers found that the gasket match for delta parts has been a pain.

• This has a drain plug washer and it comes with brass screws.
• The manufacturer says: We are proud of the products we sell, you will be too.
• One of the newcomers and featured product.