The 5 Best Black Willow charcoals (2023 reviews)

The speedball black willow charcoal is long-lasting, rigid and fits well with your daily purpose like a dream. There is a great range of sizes. It gives the working characteristics typical of willow in a large form factor. Physically it handles like most willow charcoal you'll have handled. They draw prefect shadows. The ease of application combined with the comparatively large size also encourages a loose style which is well suited to the early stages of a drawing.

These charcoal sticks, while very good quality, are very soft and break easily. They come in many different sizes, you will love the huge one for toning up the page, the super thin ones do break pretty easily. This is what to buy if you need giant charcoal sticks for background when you are drawing in white with an eraser or cloth in art class. It is made from grape vines.

Why We Like This:

Great set of willow charcoal sticks
Good adaptability to various mark sizes
Good willow charcoal with a nice selection of sizes
Nice size and consistency of charcoal for sketching and marking patterns

Best For figure Drawing: Pacific Arc Black Willow Charcoal

Buy on Amazon

The pacific arc black willow charcoal is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. This big stick charcoal draws smoothly on any paper or sketchpad. It is great for figure drawing, still life drawing, loose sketches and any other fine art where a smooth and consistent charcoal is needed. One stick of this soft willow charcoal, a gum eraser, and index fingertip is all that's needed for the full range of tone, line and texture. It is great for large area shading, easy to use.

This charcoal works really well for a college level drawing class. It is perfect for creating everything from wispy sketches to bold drawings.

Why We Like This:

Covers a lot of space on the paper but also good for detail work
A nice range of hardness in the set
New and hot release

Best For Soft Charcoal: Grumbacher Vine Charcoal

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another charcoal that manages to win our hearts. It's the grumbacher vine charcoal and it's widely considered as charcoal that has the most suitable features. This is a good choice for soft charcoal. These are not pencils, they are natural burned vine sticks, so the entire piece is one piece of charcoal, no wood or lacquer. It glides on like liquid almost. It is convenient if you need a quick refill of the product. It allows blending without crumble or excess powder. It is easy to blend & remove with gum eraser. It works very well on newsprint paper.

Why We Like This:

Soft and smooth, but can break easily
Easy to maneuver and easy to erase
Fun to rip apart and shade with, and very affordable

Best For laying down preliminary sketches: Grumbacher Black Willow Charcoal

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate charcoal. The grumbacher black willow charcoal is exactly that - it's a simple charcoal that hits all the right notes. The Thick Willow Charcoal measures approximately.3125” (.79 cm) in diameter. It is made from burning natural, uncompressed willow rods to create charcoal in a range of diameters.

Why We Like This:

Good brand reputation
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For Sketching: Kuidamos Black Willow Charcoal

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other charcoal in this category, the kuidamos black willow charcoal has a convenient design. This brushed charcoal is specially made of high-quality materials, very easy to color, not easy to break, so you can use it comfortably. It is mainly used for oil painting, chinese painting, design modeling, and has different brushstroke effects in the field of art painting and painting.

The sketch charcoal pen has a comfortable feel, the specification is 25 pcs in a barrel, and the diameter is.

Why We Like This:

Smooth coating and good use effect
Good brand reputation