There are several advantages of having a broiler tray. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: General Electric Broiler Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Large Roasts: Buy: Farberware Broiler Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Baking Cookie: Buy: Teamfar Broiler Tray READ REVIEW

Best With Solid Weight: Buy: Chefmade Broiler Tray READ REVIEW

Best With Overall Good Buy: Buy: Range Kleen Broiler Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Small Roasts: Buy: Range Kleen Broiler Pan READ REVIEW

Best For Nonstick Coating: Buy: Chicago Metallic Frying Pan READ REVIEW

Best For Oven Baked Bacon: Buy: Chicago Metallic Broiler Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Smal Meal Broiling: Buy: Norpro Broiler Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Light Weight: Buy: Sur La Table Broiler Tray READ REVIEW

Best Overall: General Electric Broiler Tray

Buy on Amazon

General Electric has been making good-quality trays for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and high-end materials. The General Electric Broiler Tray is great for light weight, right now and has a sturdy design. The Manufacturer says: At Ge appliances, our parts and filters are approved by third party regulators including underwriters laboratories, the national sanitary foundation, and the uniform plumbing code. This high - quality genuine oem ge appliances broiler pan ( wb48x10056 ) catches drippings from broiling foods.

The tray is best with great size and it is great for overall quality. In addition, it is indispensable for broiling, It would be perfect with excellent construction and has perfect design. Finally, the general electric broiler tray is a genuine replacement part, the model number and name for the following item.

Most buyers quickly discovered that the tray is great for oven - cooked bacon. In addition, a few say that the tray fits the anova oven plus fits a pound of bacon. Further, a few say that this pan is very sturdy and easy to clean. Overall, most buyers agree that the tray suits them best, and no one questions it.

• This is good for meat or vegetables.
• This is great for overall dimensions and it is designed for a great price.
• This will last for many years.
• This has molded steel, is great for convection roasting meats and it is black.

Best For Large Roasts: Farberware Broiler Tray

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another tray that manages to win our hearts. It's the Farberware Broiler Tray and it's widely considered as one of the most convenient trays you can buy. The farberware broiler tray feels substantial, is larger and it lasts for ever. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, this is suitable for heavy construction, is easier to clean and it is pretty flimsy.

The tray is used for very non - stick and it makes for a great gift. And, the tray is very useful and it is black. Most importantly, the farberware broiler tray is very nice, makes for nice quality and it works perfectly.

Almost all customers agree that the tray is perfect for husband's cooking needs. And, they say that the tray comes with is flat and very high quality. And, they also found that this pan has a nice heft and is reliably non - stick. Without any doubt, this product passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This is a great piece of cookware.
• This is used for 3-2 lb meatloaf's, cooks beautifully and is easy to clean.
• This pan is a sturdy roaster that, so far, is remarkably nonstick.
• This can bake, roast or broil.

Best For Baking Cookie: Teamfar Broiler Tray

Buy on Amazon

The Teamfar Broiler Tray's superior materials make sure that it ages well with use. The teamfar broiler tray features a smooth roll edge and round corner, no sharp spots hurting hands, comfortable to hold and transfer. The Teamfar toaster oven tray with rack set, is made of high quality stainless steel, which is solid and durable for your healthy daily baking and roasting. The toaster oven pan and rack are made of high quality stainless steel without any coating or other materials, enjoy a healthy and non - toxic cooking experience.

The tray is a breeze and both parts are dishwasher safe. And, it is a great size and it is helpful. Most importantly, the teamfar broiler tray is good for light weight and it looks great.

Most buyers agree that the tray fits inside the pan for roasting or grilling. And, a few say that the tray fits perfectly and keeps food from dripping onto the bottom of the oven. Moreover, a few strongly agree that the bottom gripped the pan more firmly than Kate Winslet held onto that floating door.

• This works for both the broiler pan and rack are dishwasher safe.
• 2.please clean them with a soft dishcloth, avoiding scratching the shiny surface.
• This is suitable for high temperatures, using instructions and it is disposable.
• It looks so much nicer than the aluminum.

Best With Solid Weight: Chefmade Broiler Tray

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention the Chefmade Broiler Tray for daily usage. The chefmade broiler tray makes for easy clean-up, is rectangular, It is good for even if covered in honey and has a solid design. If you’re not thrilled with its construction or performance, please let us know. And, this is best with great size, fits well, it is larger and has a perfect design.

Lastly, the chefmade broiler tray is great with solid weight, It works very well and has a deeper design.

Most customers agree that the tray is not recommended to burn or bake directly by fire or through rocks or brick kilns, which can easily cause more coating damage and food adhesion. Moreover, they say that the tray is made of a good - grade metal with a good nonstick surface. In addition, a few say that the tray is a very sturdy pan and you should have no problems on a stove top. Overall, many customers have used the tray for more than a few months without any complaints, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This is easy to wear. I have to look for some other sizes.
• This comes out even with soaking and scrubbing.
• This pan is seeing a lot of use.
• This cleans perfectly and it makes for nice quality.

Best With Overall Good Buy: Range Kleen Broiler Tray

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a tray. The Range Kleen Broiler Tray is exactly that - it's a simple tray that hits all the right notes. The range kleen broilertray allows users to quickly cook food in a healthy way. The Manufacturer says: Our broiler pans for oven non - stick material is built tough. The grill pan allows fat to drip away from food, where it is collected in the base pan below.

Lastly, the range kleen broiler tray is made for excellent replacement and it can cook for a nice sized broiler.

Most buyers opine that the tray looks like it will last for decades. Further, a few strongly agree that the tray makes a popping sounds as it deforms and un-deforms. In addition, they say that the tray cleans the same as others, little large though.

• This is a great broiler pan, really good quality for the price.
• It is easy to clean but the non - stick cooking is already coming off.
• This does warp when over 400 degrees f though.
• This right now and it works very well.

Best For Small Roasts: Range Kleen Broiler Pan

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate tray. The Range Kleen Broiler Pan is exactly that - it's a simple tray that hits all the right notes. The range kleen broiler pan fits well, fits in the dishwasher and it can cook in nice size. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. This American - made set is safe for use for up to 1025 degrees f and has oem ( original equipment manufacturer ) quality.

The tray comes with great pans and it is designed for a great price. Furthermore, it is perfect for fish, meat and veggies. Most importantly, the range kleen broiler pan is thick enough and it fits well at an excellent price.

Almost all customers opine that the tray is exactly like a full - size broil pan, only smaller. Also, they strongly agree that the tray is easy to clean and doesn't warp at all. And, they say that the tray is easy to clean and works like any of those that comes in ovens.

• It is easy to clean and has no problems with warping.
• This is easy to store, and is versatile for both baking and broiler use.
• This worked as expected and it allowed for easy cleaning.
• Cook and clean with ease: the ingredients are easy to clean and dishwasher safe.

Best For Nonstick Coating: Chicago Metallic Frying Pan

Buy on Amazon

The Chicago metallic frying pan should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. The Chicago metallic frying pan is a great size and it cleans the grill. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. This petite broil and roast pan is essential to creating any type of baked goods in a toaster oven.

The tray is made worth the money and it is made well. And, the tray is good value and it is ideal for countertop ovens. Above all, the Chicago metallic frying pan is dishwasher safe, however hand-washing is recommended to extend the product 's life.

Almost all customers agree that the tray cleans up easily, yet for $12.00 it should have been at least 50% larger. And, they also found that the tray is a perfect little pan for someone living alone or for a couple. Further, a few say that this nice heavy - duty pan and rack has one big problem. In conclusion, many have used the tray for more than a few months without any problems, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• The oil is not adhering to the pan but being absorbed by the food.
• This has a good non-sticking ability and cleans up easily.
• This includes components, even more and it includes testing for high temperatures.
• This is designed with a non-stick coating for easy release and it is rectangular.

Best For Oven Baked Bacon: Chicago Metallic Broiler Tray

Buy on Amazon

Chicago Metallic has been making great trays for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. The Chicago metallic broiler tray is dishwasher safe, however hand-washing is recommended to extend the product 's life. Manufacturer says: At Chicago metallic, we believe that serious baking requires serious bakeware. The pan holds up to 25 pounds of meat and measures 18x1334 inches.

The tray is stable, is easier to clean, it works great and has a great design. In addition, this is made well, it is made for virtually no maintenance and has a versatile design. Most importantly, the Chicago metallic broiler tray is used for plenty of room, is very useful, It is perfect for roasting meats and has a flexible design.

Most buyers agree that the tray is great for roasts, roasting vegetables, chicken, etc. Also, they also found that the tray comes with a 25 - year warranty. Also, they say that note: if the weight of this pan says anything, it should last forever.

• This is not a broiling pan, hand wash only and no harsh detergent.
• This is great for two Cornish hens or a small roast.
• This is a flat-stamped sheet-steel pan with a non-stick coating on both sides.
• This makes cleaning the rack a breeze.

Best For Smal Meal Broiling: Norpro Broiler Tray

Buy on Amazon

The Norpro Broiler Tray's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The norpro broilertray is good for light weight, It is stainless steel is durable and has a durable design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Further, it is designed for a great price, It looks great and has a versatile design.

The tray is consistently at the forefront of product innovation. Above all, the norpro broiler tray is made with sturdy quality and it makes for very nice quality.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the tray looked like it would be easy to clean, too. And, a few strongly agree that the tray is coated with potentially harmful chemicals. And, they strongly agree that the tray cleans easily at great quality for the price.

• This is great for smal meals broiling.
• It is big enough for 1 or 2 people-sized steaks.
• They are not very thick and hence have very sharp edges.
• This is the absolutely perfect size, shape and function for a toaster oven/broiler.

Best For Light Weight: Sur La Table Broiler Tray

Buy on Amazon

The Sur La Table Broiler Tray is the most suitable tray on the market today. The sur la table broiler tray is good for easy cleaning, it fits right for the right size and has a practical design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Further, this is ideal for broiling meat, heavy enough and it is practical.

The tray is best great size, is built with solid stainless steel, It makes for a great gift and has a solid design. Further, it is made with good value, suitable for light weight, It is easy to handle and has a sturdy design. Above all, the sur la table broiler tray is easier to clean, is larger, it is really nice and has an excellent design.

Most buyers opine that the tray cleans easily with a brillo or sos pad and a little elbow grease...easier or harder depending on how burnt the food gets. Moreover, they say that the tray is easy to find at reasonable prices. Moreover, they say that the tray is very good quality at an unbelievably low price.

• It is easy to clean, with no fear of scratching anything.
• This is perfect for broiling two steaks and sausages as well.
• This is from the outside edge to the outside edge.
• This is the perfect size for a couple of steaks.