The 8 Best Cherries That go In Manhattan (2023 reviews)

We are personally inclined towards luxardo original maraschino cherries best cherry, it is not so pricy, but it overachieves its purpose and outstanding in important aspects. This is one intense cherry, perfect for a cocktail. The Luxardo cherries have the wonderful flavor that puts the cookies over the top. It has excellent flavor, is firm, has a very deep, dark red color and are packed in a very thick, sticky cherry liquor. The texture is luscious, like a confection. It can be used in homemade ice cream and even in greek yogurt for breakfast.

These dark cherries come packed in a thick, rich syrup. If it is used for garnishing an adult libation, a jar will last a long time. The jar is not too large to store in the fridge, and the wide mouth allows easy access.

Why We Like This:

Perfect addition to a high-end cocktail
Great for a good bourbon or cocktail
Makes the quintessential old fashioned perfect
Very dense, flavorful cherries that put the perfect finish on a manhattan

Best For Manhattan Cocktail: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Cherry That go In Manhattan

Buy on Amazon

The luxardo original maraschino cherries cherry that go in manhattan is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features for the price point. Luxardo cherries are deep and luscious and real-cherry-tasting, have an extraordinary firm texture, and subtle rich fragrance. They have wonderful flavor & texture. This is just the best stuff, especially if you like making cocktails. The fruit is dark purple, and sweet, and the juice is almost tart, resulting in a sensory delight.

These exceptional candied cherries are an exclusive italian import with unbeatable flavor. It is way more economical than the small jars. This is a premium, incredible taste.

Why We Like This:

Delicious, will change the way you feel about cocktail cherries
Served over ice cream with the syrup,delicious
Best cherries ever for old fashioneds
Makes manhattan time an even better time

Best For baking: Toschi Cherry That go In Manhattan

Buy on Amazon

The toschi cherry that go in manhattan should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. These cherries have a full, rich flavor that blows away the super-sweetness of typical cocktail cherries. The cherries are larger than ones that usually come in the Luxardo tin, fully plump and not shriveled and packed in delicious syrup. It shines as a glaze for pork or chicken and will even turn Brussel sprouts into a favorite side. These cherries are very tasty and great in drinks.

These candied sour black cherries are used at home and in restaurants and bars around the world. It is great in yogurt or tarts.

Why We Like This:

Just delicious cherries and the cherry "juice
Great for cocktails or over dessert
Delicious, great as an easy dessert
Excellent value for a high quality product with great taste and texture

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve Cherry That go In Manhattan

Buy on Amazon

The woodford reserve cherry that go in manhattan should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. These are the only cherries to use for a great manhattan. It is made from natural ingredients, these cherries bring a brightness along with hints of kentucky's finest bourbon to recipes. They are not excessively sweet which is nice. These are flavorful to add to your cocktails or ice cream for dessert option.

The Bourbon flavor is very mild. It is great for entertaining, 1 jar lasts approx 2 nights of drinks for a group of. They are on the pricy side but totally worth it for those special occasions. They are perfect for an old-fashioned cocktail.

Why We Like This:

Makes a delicious manhattan and does not contain harmful chemicals
Save the juice and reduce for dessert topping
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For non traditional stuff: green Hills Cherry That go In Manhattan

Buy on Amazon

The green hills cherry that go in manhattan should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. This is what every home bar needs for a perfect Manhattan. Combine that with an orange bitter that is fresh and unique and unsweetened, and it's the perfect cocktail starter kit for someone with taste. It is great for non traditional stuff like the tequila old fashioneds. The Regan's Orange Bitters is, likewise a great tasting, high quality product. These are the best flavor, texture syrup.

These are two very high quality ingredients for your home bar. The Regan's bitters are flavorful and play well with many other ingredients to give fun twists on classic drinks. These are so good, much better in Manhattans than more common brands of maraschino cherries.

Why We Like This:

Perfect taste for making old fashions
Make the best old fashioneds and the bitters
Good investment for long term

Best For So many different recipes: Traverse City Whiskey Co Cherry That go In Manhattan

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for appropriate and satisfactory cherry, traverse city whiskey co cherry that go in manhattan should be your first option for buying. These cherries are large and plump like a traditional soda fountain cherry (minus the stem), but have a luscious dark color and rich flavor more like luxardo cherries. They are small to medium sized cherry. They have such a rich, thick syrup they are packed in and add great flavor to your favorite cocktails. A few drops of the syrup in the drink will elevate your cocktail and have people impressed with your creation. It is great for a desert ice cream topping though.

These cherries add great flavor, and beautiful presentation that goes way beyond any cherries you can buy in your local grocery store. They are great tasting cherry for the perfect cocktail. They are great for manhattans or atop ice cream or other desserts. It is good for a desert ice cream topping though.

Why We Like This:

Perfect cocktail cherries when you make an old fashioned
Perfect for manhattans and old fashions
Nice and suftly crunchy, super sugary and sweet, and thick
Taste is great and would recommend for a traditional old fashioned

Best For Old Fashioned Cocktail: Ved Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The ved cocktail cherry should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. A cocktail cherry on top of an ice cream sundae is great, but there are few things as satisfying as a Maraschino cherry at the bottom of an old fashioned cocktail or Manhattan cocktail glass. The Ved cocktail cherries are hand-picked of the finest marasca cherries in the rich mountains of Italy and offered in tightly sealed jars that will keep them fresh and delicious for longer.

Unlike the red cherries of the ice cream parlor, these gourmet cocktail cherries come in a burgundy-red hue that adds luxury to your drinks. It is suitable for any healthy diet. These are non-gmo, gluten-free, and vegan. It is looking for the vibrant black maraschino cherries you find on top of the whipped cream in restaurants.

Why We Like This:

Looking for mouth-watering old fashioned cherries for your cocktails or baked delicacies
Candied fresh, offered in safe jars
A great addition to any healthy diet

Best For any healthy diet: Ved Cherry That go In Manhattan

Buy on Amazon

The ved cherry that go in manhattan is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features in its price range. A cocktail cherry on top of an ice cream sundae is great, but there are few things as satisfying as a Maraschino cherry at the bottom of an old fashioned cocktail or Manhattan cocktail glass. The Ved gourmet cherries are your go-to destination for ice cream and pastry decor.

Unlike the red cherries of the ice cream parlor, these gourmet cocktail cherries come in a burgundy-red hue that adds luxury to your drinks. These are non-gmo, gluten-free, and vegan. It is suitable for any healthy diet.

The Ved cocktail cherries are hand-picked of the finest marasca cherries in the rich mountains of Italy and offered in tightly sealed jars that will keep them fresh and delicious for longer periods of time. It is looking for the vibrant burgundy red maraschino cherries you find on top of the whipped cream in restaurants.

Why We Like This:

A great addition to any healthy diet
Candied fresh, offered in safe jars
Looking for mouth-watering old fashioned cherries for your cocktails or baked delicacies