The 5 Best creamy Tartar sauces (2023 reviews)

The kraft creamy tartar sauce's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. This item contains 200 single-serving packs of kraft tartar sauce. It is enjoyed with a variety of american and coastal dishes. It is great to bring camping if you catch fish, no need for cold storage. The box of 200 packets are delicious and work well with different types of fish but are also good in deviled eggs, potato salad, macaroni salad and on a variety of sandwiches.

The tartar sauce has a very nice flavor. It's less messy and less waste. It is perfect for serving as a dipping sauce or topping for fish and chips, fish sticks, seafood, sandwiches, fries and more. It would be a good option if you are eating out and the restraint does not provide a good variety of sauces.

Why We Like This:

Shelf-stable and convenient to transport for picnics, barbecues, camping, etc
Come in a cardboard box without any other packaging
A great way to portion your tartar sauce

Best Runner up: Inglehoffer creamy Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

If you like a good tartar sauce, you'll be blown away by this incredible concoction. The Versatile inglehoffer seafood tartar sauce for shrimp also makes a flavorful sandwich spread, salmon marinade and seafood dip. It's thicker than the cocktail sauce. The lemon and capers are an incredibly wonderful addition to this fabulous sauce.

The Gluten free tartar sauce is vegetarian to suit a variety of dietary needs. It comes in a squeeze bottle for easy use and storage. The inglehoffer tartar sauce is wonderful, but does not affect the taste of other dishes.

Why We Like This:

Gourmet seafood dip crafted with tangy lemon and capers for a delicious flavor
, a very rich and tasty version of the sauce
Seafood sauce comes in a squeeze bottle for easy use and storage
Suitable for a variety of diets

Best for DIPPING any kind of finger Foods: Mccormick creamy Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

The mccormick creamy tartar sauce should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. This is absolutely delicious tarter sauce and works well with most fish. It tastes good on a bun in a dish with a side of fish. No matter what you choose, the aroma and taste will always be purely delicious. The flavor is great and it's the perfect pairing for fish of all sorts.

This sauce is creamy, has a very balanced flavor between sweet and tangy. The bottle is soft and easy to squeeze. It comes in a flip top squeezable bottle. The flavor is tangy and not too sweet.

Why We Like This:

Nice flavor not overwhelming to the fish
A delicious addition to your fish dinner
Good investment for long term

Best for pouring on The go: Kraft Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

The Kraft natural lemon flavor and herb tartar sauce is america's favorite pick for adding delicious flavor to any fish meal. The flavor of this tartar sauce is quite good. It is great for pouring on the go.

The Kraft tartar sauce delivers the unsurpassed quality and consistency you demand to satisfy customer tastes. It comes in a squeezable bottle for easy serving and portion control. The flavor is amazing without being overwhelmed by the lemon and herbs. This cocktail sauce is very good. The Kraft tartar sauce is a perfect flavor to add your choice of fish.

Why We Like This:

Ready-to-use sauce is thick and creamy for easy dipping and spreading
Kraft natural lemon & herb tartar sauce
Made with herbs, natural lemon flavor and other natural flavors

Best premium: Stonewall kitchen creamy Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase sauce for their regular usage, but the stonewall kitchen creamy tartar sauce would be an anomoly. Stonewall's offering has the same top-quality approach and consistency as Legal Sea Foods' tartar sauce. It has that 'premium, yet homemade' taste you'd expect at a fancy oceanfront seafood restaurant. It's tangy and sweet, with a classic taste.

It has a zesty taste that's similar to legal's sauce, but it's a little more one-note and less sophisticated. It can be used as an aioli of sorts, say as a dipping sauce, or as a sandwich spread.

Legal's has relish front and center as the first ingredient, caramelized onions, and ground celery seeds, while Stonewall's has a stronger dill flavor and lemon. The flavor is complex and hits the bullseye of vinegary tang balanced by pleasing sweetness.

Why We Like This:

New and hot release
Good investment for long term