The 10 Best Dark Cherries In A Jar (2023 reviews)

We consider a dark cherry in a jar to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: Tillen Farms Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best For topping on cheesecake: Buy: Amarena Fabbri Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best For Old Fashion: Buy: Oregon Chai Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best With liquor: Buy: Filthy food Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best For baking: Buy: happy Belly Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best For Whiskey Sour: Buy: Toschi Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best With stem: Buy: Member'S Mark Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best For those: Buy: Collins Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best For Bourbon: Buy: Barrel Roll bar essentials Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best For Black Forest cake: Buy: Specially selected Dark Cherry In A Jar READ REVIEW

Best overall: Tillen Farms Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

The Luxardo Cherries are almost creamy texture because it's more a candy cherry, but the Bada Bings haven't been processed till you can't recognize them anymore. They taste (and look) like real cherries and are naturally sweet, not saccharine sweet. They are the dark ones and are great for adding to a wonderful old fashioned or just putting on top of some ice cream. It would be perfect with the woodbridge cherry bitters.

The syrup is sweet and therefore, if the cherries are sour to begin with, they are no longer sour. It is not up to luxor cherry quality, but toss a couple in a shot of whiskey with a bit of orange sparkling water and enjoy. It is best cherry for drinks, taste like a cherry and not over sweet ice cream cherries.

• Firm texture, more natural color and flavor
• Perfect for manhattans and other cocktails
• Great tasting cherries for cocktails or desserts
• Delicious pitted (pits removed) black cherries for cocktails

Best For topping on cheesecake: Amarena Fabbri Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable cherry, amarena fabbri dark cherry in a jar is your end point. This is nothing like those bright red, nasty sweet cocktail cherries, but rather a delicious balance of sweet and tart. It is perfect to compliment a manhattan cocktail. The cherries themselves are identical, and they come with more syrup. It can be used in many ways.

These are the best cherries ever for Manhattans and topping for cheese cakes. The cherries are on the more tart side and the syrup is sweet but not sickeningly so. It is good for manhattans or ice cream. It can be used by international bartenders, baristas, and pastry chefs.

• Perfect in manhattans or fruit cake too
• Tasty syrup adds a sweet (but not too sweet) kick to any drink
• Great flavor, beautiful container that can be reused for various things if you want
• Just a bit deeper flavor than maraschino cherries

Best For Old Fashion: Oregon Chai Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

Oregon Chai offers a variety of cherry for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. These are the best canned cherries. It's much better than the ones for pie cherries. It calls for draining the juice to combine it with corn starch and sugar and cook till boiling. Add your own favorite pie crust, sugar and other filling ingredients and these cherries will take you back to the best cherry pie you ever had.

These make a great cherry pie, crisp, or cobbler. It's easy to make a delicious pie from scratch. These are fine for cooking or for making jam or syrup. It's great for cooking or eating.

• Nice tart flavor makes a great tasting pie
• Perfect for making cherry pie filling
• Simple way to make a pie
• Perfect for making black forest cherry cake or just straight from the can

Best With liquor: Filthy food Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

Filthy Food makes beautiful and great cherry with classic and smartly choosen materials. These are the absolute premium cherries to compliment a beverage (Manhattan) or dessert. It is great for any cocktail especially for an old fashioned. These little cocktail cherries are full of flavor. It's very sweet with a tart finish. It is great for kir royal or eat straight up or to top a dessert.

This glass jar contains 45 exquisite black cherries that are surely hard to forget. The cherry juice is a real plus it would be easy just to put the cherries and some light juice and call it quits but they took it to the max. It is perfect fit for your bar at home.

• Great addition to the liquor cabinet
• Good brand reputation

Best For baking: happy Belly Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention happy belly dark cherry in a jar for regular usage. These are full of flavor and very delicious. It is a jar of regular maraschino cherries in a sweet light cherry-flavor watery syrup.

• Can pineapple rings, drained, reserve juice
• Evenly pour the pineapple juice, cherry syrup, and butter over the cake mix
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For Whiskey Sour: Toschi Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

If you are searching for a satisfactory cherry for your daily usage, you cannot go wrong with the toschi dark cherry in a jar. Upgrade your cherry game with these amarena black cherries for your next old fashioned, manhattan, or chocolate martini and you won’t regret it. It is the most widely used cocktail garnish. These candied cherries are delicious and add just the right amount of sweetness to the cocktail. It is great potential for homemade black cherry ice cream from these cherries and syrup. The syrup these cherries are just as tasty.

These are excellent and can fill in for all occasions. It is perfect for desserts or bar drinks.

• Perfect for manhattan's or just with straight bourbon
• Beautiful, rich perfect blend of sweet and tang
• A great ice cream topper or drink accompaniment

Best With stem: Member'S Mark Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

The member's mark dark cherry in a jar's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. These are regular size maraschino cherries with stems. They taste great and make a wonderful Manhattan. They have a strong maraschino cherry flavor, not just red sugar syrup and they add flavor and character to a good Manhattan cocktail. The cherries are great and have the needed stems. The cherry stems are great for dipping the cherries into melted chocolate or for mixed drinks. Use this in a lot of christmas baking and candies, if you have need for a lot, this is the way to buy them.

• Each and everyone is delicious, beautiful and mouthwatering
• Stores great,keeps nice in the fridge
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For those: Collins Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

Best part: collins dark cherry in a jar costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. These stemless cocktail cherries are the ideal gift for parties, housewarming, weddings, birthdays, or just as a surprise gift for cocktail connoisseurs. Red and juicy, these cherries are perfect for those looking to make authentic cocktails. Formulated with professional bartenders, Collins mixers and garnishes are made with real ingredients for real cocktails. It is made from sweet, delicious fruit and preserved in syrups made with real sugar for cherries that add extra punch to manhattans, old fashioneds, and other classic cocktails.

It is perfect for cocktails, these cherries are delicious on their own, especially for those who have a sweet tooth.

• Lot of satisfied buyers
• New and hot release

Best For Bourbon: Barrel Roll bar essentials Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cherry in this category, the barrel roll bar essentials dark cherry in a jar has a convenient design. No decent kitchen or bar is complete without these premium cherries. These dark reserve cherries are made with dark cherry juice, elderberry juice, and vanilla on top of its infusion with barrel-aged bourbon for that distinct taste you’ll love. It is ideal for various drinks like whiskey-made cocktails or the barrel roll old fashioned and manhattan mixes. These are carefully and slowly cooked by hand in small batches to extract the most out of the fruit’s natural taste without ruining its texture.

These delicious fruits are a wonderful garnish or ingredient for charcuterie boards, cheese plates, desserts, and cocktails. This large size means you have more than enough for those cherry cravings as well as your favorite recipes. It can also be used for a range of desserts.

• Delivers what they promise
• New and hot release

Best For Black Forest cake: Specially selected Dark Cherry In A Jar

Buy on Amazon

The specially selected dark cherry in a jar is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features in its price range. It makes the best cherry pie ever. These cherries are perfect for making cherry pies. The syrup in the jar has a watery flow. The texture is good and the flavor is great. They are the perfect cherries for the dish. They are well packaged to ensure no breakage. They are very close to the fresh fruit.

• Good brand reputation
• One of the new comers and featured product