The 7 Best ever Apple Butter (2023 reviews)

We consider a ever apple butter to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Amish Wedding ever Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best Runner up: Buy: Musselmans ever Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best with Stevia: Buy: Musselmans Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best with bagels: Buy: Mccutcheons ever Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best For ages: Buy: Amish Valley products ever Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best Giftable: Buy: Stonewall kitchen ever Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best Flavor: Buy: Kauffman'S Fruit farm & market ever Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Amish Wedding ever Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

There are so many apple butter products out there but this one is the best flavor thickness and goes with so many things and does not overpower it. Old-fashioned, all-natural apple butter for prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in amish wedding foods' apple butter. It is delicious on toast alone or with butter or cream cheese.

Creamy and delicious, this apple butter is the best topping for warm muffins and morning toast. It is good as a cracker barrel’s apple butter. The mix of flavors are the best ever. It is good as a cinnamon apple sauce rather than apple butter.

• Homemade quality and flavor with a little hint of cinnamon
• Very tasty and just the right amount of sugar
• Delivers what they promise

Best Runner up: Musselmans ever Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The musselmans ever apple butter is capable of outshining several other butter featured in this list in overall features.

• Great on biscuits, toast and peanut butter sandwich
• Much healthier than most jellies, jams, preserves
• New and hot release

Best with Stevia: Musselmans Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase butter for their daily usage, but the musselmans apple butter would be an anomoly. It is the apple butter that you usually find at your grocers. It is the perfect complement to apple butter and peanut butter sandwiches. It is creamy, with a heavy apple flavor, and spiced just right. It is just like any jelly or preserves that you would apply on toast. It is perfect for a lot of uses. It comes in 32 oz., and that it comes as a two pack.

The flavor is wonderful and the texture is delightfully thick. It is both sweet & spicy, like that of a good apple cider.

• Low sugar and no high fructose corn syrup
• Spiced apple sauce that's simmered down thick and spreadable
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best with bagels: Mccutcheons ever Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Best part: mccutcheons ever apple butter costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. This is by far the most scrumptious apple butter out there. It is made from just apples, sugar, apple juice and spices. It is great with toast and bagels. It can be used as a gift for apple lovers, teachers, hostesses, or any time you need a gift for the holiday's, and of course for yourself.

This apple butter is almost as good as homemade. It is great for teacher, hostesses, or any time you need a gift for the holiday's, and of course for yourself. It is made from a time-tested family recipe, it's slow cooked in small batches for a rich, mellow flavor that's lightly spiced with a hint of sweetness.

• Not to thick, not runny, and good taste, and natural
• Just the right amount of sweetness
• Perfect balance of apple and sweetness

Best For ages: Amish Valley products ever Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The amish valley products ever apple butter is suitable and reliable and fits well with your regular usage. If you're an apple butter lover, this one will not disappoint. It is good for apple butter for ages. It is made in ohio's amish country 18 oz glass jar. This has that fresh apple taste and it has no added sugar. It is perfectly flavored with spices. It has a great balance between the sugar, spices and apples. This is so good on a biscuit.

• Great and best apple butter ever
• Sweetened with apple juice, wonder taste and consistency
• Great basic recipe without sugar added

Best Giftable: Stonewall kitchen ever Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

They are big fans of ice cream and the woman is particularly fond of caramel. The Caramel Apple Butter is a nice alternative to the regular, thick syrups that are often used as toppers. It is spreadable but it is not as thick as peanut butter. This definitely has the consistency of apple butter and the flavor of apple butter as well with just a hint of caramel.

It's the perfect topping for your favorite ice cream, cake or pastry. It is for a sumptuous breakfast treat, spoon caramel apple butter on pancakes, waffles, or french toast.

• Create an elegant dessert by filling a pastry shell and top with whipped cream
• Great as a gift or for yourself
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best Flavor: Kauffman'S Fruit farm & market ever Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The kauffman's fruit farm & market ever apple butter has killer features for the price point. This brand does not qualify as an appealing, naturally sweet apple taste. It is made with only a few simple ingredients, such as fresh apples, freshly-pressed apple cider, and cinnamon. It is very tasty on toast, english muffins, etc. It is a family staple that is ordered in the 6 jar quantity every few weeks.

The sugar in this delicious apple butter is only the natural sugar found in the apples. It is made with only three ingredients, apples, apple cider and cinnamon, this is as simple and tasty as you can get. The jars are packaged well, and there is no breakage, spillage or mess. This is an excellent product,it's very tasty and great for people who have to watch their sugar intake.

• Use on toast, bagels, butter bread, and ice cream
• Nice cinnamon bite to it and the consistency is just right
• Fresh apples, freshly-pressed apple cider, and cinnamon
• Wonderful for anyone trying to limit sugar intake