The 8 Best Eye primers For oily eyelid (2023 reviews)

If you want nothing short of the optimal primer for your regular usage, this milani eye primer for oily eyelid is certainly a wise investment. It's pretty much a dupe for the Urban Decay primer potion. It's an excellent base for your eye shadow though. It has a tiny bit of a nude color that doesn't translate on the lids. It makes the shadows adhere to the lid much better, makes them appear more vibrant and increases the longevity of the shadows.

The Eyeshadow colors show up much more vibrant and really help stay on throughout the day. It goes on creamy and a tiny bit goes a long way. It comes off with makeup removers, just like any high end quality, but still does the job it's meant to do.

Why We Like This:

Great little eyeshadow primer that lasts all day
Comes off easily with makeup remover
Gives shadows a great pop and lots of staying power
Compares favorably to high end eyeshadow primers,produces creaseless and long lasting wear

Best For more natural look: Revlon Eye Primer For oily eyelid

Buy on Amazon

Revlon has been making great primer for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. It is not at all cakey and really does help brighten your eyes. This product truly does brighten up the eye area. It looks natural and fresh. It has a small brush tip applicator and the color is light, but super blendable. It is great to even out the various colors of a red nose, red eyelids, and any other colorful blemish.

It's a good, natural color and is easy to apply as little or as much as you need. It is thin enough to apply a few times throughout the day or night without looking cakey and does temporarily brighten the eye area.

Why We Like This:

Good product and keeps the eye makeup on for hours
Covers dark circles and causes the shadow to stay in place
Good investment for long term

Best For creasing: NYX professional Makeup Eye Primer For oily eyelid

Buy on Amazon

Nyx Professional Makeup line of primer come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. This product puts a matte finish that keeps liner and shadow from smearing. It blends very well with any concealer brushes and gives you a very smooth and even eyelid/base to apply your eyeshadow. It looks good and it's crease free. It’s soft on the tip and glides smoothly over the skin. It takes five minutes to fully dry and set on the eyelids.

Doing a gentle rub test, the nyx is also the clear winner, with no transfer and no disturbing of the pigment. It does not have enough color to hide discoloration. It’s great to be used for any type of eyeshadow such as powdery, matte or glittery ones as it makes the eyeshadow stays all day long without any problem.

Why We Like This:

Cruelty free is a must and nyx always has awesome, affordable products
Drys too fast no time to blend shadows
Very tacky (for better and worse) not the most hygienic applicator
Goes on well as a base for eyeshadow

Best For sensitive skin: E.L.F. Eye Primer For oily eyelid

Buy on Amazon

Best part: e.l.f. Eye primer for oily eyelid costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. This eye primer is designed to create a very fresh, natural, soft, dewy look, it blends beautifully with other products to help create this look. It looks like a concealer, glides on effortlessly, and blends right away. It feels creamy and it does have a color to it but when it tries it looks transparent. It allows for it to go on easily and lasts throughout the entire day/night.

This primer does exactly what it is supposed to and provides a decent foundation for eye makeup. It makes this eyeshadow look cakey and comes out pretty dry already. It looks exceptional all day and can double as an eye-shadow. It looks nice on and gives you a nice base color. This product gives you a great bang for a very little buck.

Why We Like This:

Enough to last through work or a night out
Good investment for long term

Best For crease: Somall Eye Primer For oily eyelid

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate primer. The somall eye primer for oily eyelid is exactly that - it's a simple primer that hits all the right notes. This 24 hours long lasting eyeshadow primer is full coverage for a look and look. It really helps keep your eyes shadow on, and doesn’t crease. It has been developed into a powerful international company in all kind of color makeup industry and makeup tools products, leading high-end makeup palette, lipsticks, concealer, contour, powder makeup. It is waterproof and very easy to blend. It is cruelty free and vegan. It is great for priming eye shadow. It’s not oily, goes on smooth and super pigmented. It would be a perfect alternative to using concealer for cut crease.

Why We Like This:

Amazing for popping out colors but mainly cut crease it’s lovely
Health and safe ingredients and great quality, hypoallergic, skin-friendly
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For someone With normal skin: Maven Gifts Eye Primer For oily eyelid

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about appropriate and satisfactory primer, maven gifts eye primer for oily eyelid is your end point. The eye shadow primer is super. It’s concealer...it works. The primer helps to keep the color on and the mist helps it not get smudged. It will not stop dark circles under eyes. The spray is a little bulky since it's a box shape and has an unpleasant smell but does help makeup stay.

The setting spray really works, it keeps your makeup on very well. This just feels like a regular spray bottle of water. It is great for someone with normal skin. The spray is a little bulky since it's a concealer...it works.

Why We Like This:

Works well and helps make up to stay put for most of the day
Helps keep make up from rubbing off onto mask
Good investment for long term

Best For cut crease: Freeorr Eye Primer For oily eyelid

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate primer. The freeorr eye primer for oily eyelid is exactly that - it's a simple primer that hits all the right notes. Delicate packaging is perfect for gifting to your loved ones. It is easy to blend and provides the highly pigmented eye makeup for you. It is a great prime cover for sun damage/ melisma/ age spots. The Creamy eyeshadow primer is infused with light ingredients to help balance skin tone, easy to blend, giving you a light, non-greasy eye makeup base for a smoother effect that prevents eyeshadow fading or clumping lines.

Fast film forming provides a firm and smooth eye base for cut crease eye shadow makeup, keeping the eye skin dry, firmly grasp the eye shadow powder, and extending the lasting of cut crease eye makeup. It needs extra dry time.

Why We Like This:

Hide your discoloration and balance your skin tone
Enhance the pigment of your eyeshadow
Good brand reputation

Best With SPF: Bellaterra cosmetics Eye Primer For oily eyelid

Buy on Amazon

Bellaterra Cosmetics is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist primer for people on the go, and its line of bellaterra cosmetics eye primer for oily eyelid definitely falls in line with that reputation. Eye primer creates a clean canvas on your eyelids to enhance the pigment and color of each eye shadow. It's tacky consistency makes a great base and the product is build-able. It allows eye shadow to stick on to your eyelids all day without smudging or creasing.

It comes with an even skin tone on your eyelids, your eyes pop to give you a glowy, no-fuss look. The eye primer can be mixed with shimmers prior to application to create a matte appearance, allowing for more versatility. It's worth it. It's made with a hypoallergenic formula, every day is a “good makeup day” with beautiful coverage that conceals and heals problematic skin types like.

Why We Like This:

Great for highlighter under the eyes for anyone with fair-medium skin
Great not only as eye primer but concealer
Has a thick paste consistency and is very highly pigmented