The 10 Best Eye primers For sensitive skin (2023 reviews)

We consider a eye primer for sensitive skin to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For oily Eye: Buy: Milani Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For more natural look: Buy: Revlon Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For creasing: Buy: NYX professional Makeup Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For sensitive skin: Buy: E.L.F. Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For Shadow Base: Buy: MAEPEOR Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For older women: Buy: Ilia Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For cut crease: Buy: Freeorr Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For tones: Buy: touch In Sol Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best For shiny eyes: Buy: PYT beauty Eye Primer For sensitive skin READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

The eye primer for sensitive skin's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The Anastasia Beverly Hills Mini Eye Primer is a travel-size water-resistant eye primer in a light-colored base that creates the perfect canvas for matte and shimmer shadows and pressed pigment eyeshadows. It truly holds the bold colors of the eye shadows. It’s quite light colored. It never moves and lasts for hours.

The base looks really very white but once your makeup is on your eyes, you’d never know it’s so white. It does have a slight white cast to it, which helps keep colors vibrant, but someone with darker skin may find that to be less than ideal. It is a very thin formula, so a little goes a long way. This makes your eye make up easier to apply, and last longer.

• Looks great and hides dark circles
• Love the sheer & bright look
• Makes a perfect eye shadow base

Best For oily Eye: Milani Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another primer that manages to win our hearts. It's the milani eye primer for sensitive skin and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient primer you can buy. The Milani shadow primer works well, keeps your lids dry, and shadow stays on and does not crease hours after wear. It goes on smooth and it just takes a very little bit. It has a slight beige tint which totally disappears when you apply eyeshadow, and it doesn't interfere with the eyeshadow color. It works great as long as you make sure your eyelids are clean, dry, and free of oil.

This primer prevents powder shadows from sinking into the creases and improves the overall appearance. The intended use of the primer is purely for the eye lids. It works so well that you do have to blend a bit more than normal but the shadow lasts all day with this product.

• Comes off easily with makeup remover
• Listed as water proof, smudge proof, and long lasting
• Excellent for sensitive eyes and contacts
• Great little eyeshadow primer that lasts all day

Best For more natural look: Revlon Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate primer. The revlon eye primer for sensitive skin is exactly that - it's a simple primer that hits all the right notes. The Revlon photoready perfecting prime is a revolutionary, lightweight primer that helps soften skin and diffuses light to help minimize flaws and even out skin texture. It covers darkness and makes your eyeshadow stay put. It works fairly well, doesn't need any touch ups for normal wear. It has some shimmer to brighten, but its not overly done or crazy. It can be worn alone or under the foundation. It is good for a more natural look (alone) but plan on using a brush or applicator. It is not at all cakey and really does help brighten your eyes.

• Good product and keeps the eye makeup on for hours
• Covers dark circles and causes the shadow to stay in place
• Delivers what they promise

Best For creasing: NYX professional Makeup Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

Best part: nyx professional makeup eye primer for sensitive skin costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. The NYX ultimate shadow and liner primer helps anyone achieve beautiful eye makeup no matter how level your makeup skills might be. It features a unique doe foot applicator for easy, smooth application. It looks good and it's crease free. It's super creamy with a soft blurring effect. It is easy to apply and works. It's much stickier and really grabs onto the eyeshadow pigment, and it works well for liquid liners too.

Doing a gentle rub test, the Nyx is also the clear winner, with no transfer and no disturbing of the pigment. The primer helps keep liner and shadow in place all day and helps reduce need for reapplication. It works well as a primer for eyeshadow to stay all day.

• Easily comes off with regular eye makeup remover
• Very tacky (for better and worse) not the most hygienic applicator
• Goes on well as a base for eyeshadow
• Helps to smudge a bit with your finger in case wand leaves excess

Best For sensitive skin: E.L.F. Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

Best part: e.l.f. Eye primer for sensitive skin costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. It looks exceptional all day and can double as an eye-shadow. It gives a wonderful even flesh toned canvas across the eyelid that makes eyeshadow pop and stay in place all day. It goes on light with almost no color, does not emphasize wrinkles, and stays on all day. It doesn’t greasy or watery so it is comfortable to wear.

It looks like a concealer, glides on effortlessly, and blends right away. It dries with only a slight color, but does help to hide eyelid flaws. It does do a good job of priming the lid so that eyeshadow application is smooth and free of creasing.

• Enough to last through work or a night out
• Prevents creasing, but definitely fades out by end of day
• More smudgy, dirty eyelids in the afternoon at work

Best For Shadow Base: MAEPEOR Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

The maepeor eye primer for sensitive skin is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your regular usage. This glitter eye primer goes on evenly and blended easily with your eyeshadow or glitter, you don't need to worry about the eyeshadow crease and the eyeshadow color changed. It's somewhat shiny. It is the hue and inspiration of the catwalk, and gorgeous high-saturated eye makeup changes the color. It lasts 8+ hours.

This glitter eye primer goes on evenly and blended easily with your eyeshadow or glitter, so you don't need to worry about the eyeshadow crease and the eyeshadow color changes the color. It is natural and environmentally friendly and safe to use.

• Comes off with warm water last all day
• Silky material, easy to push, strong concealing power
• Waterproof glue is natural and environmentally friendly and safe to use

Best For older women: Ilia Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate primer. The ilia eye primer for sensitive skin is exactly that - it's a simple primer that hits all the right notes. It’s a decent product for your eye shadow primer. This brilliant eye primer creates the ideal canvas, sure to keep shadows + liner looking on point all day, illuminating eyes while locking pigments into place. It’s kind of sticky and dries clear. It is an anti-inflammatory that helps to de-puff.

This product is sheer with a slight shimmer, very slight. It does need an extra bit of time to dry before applying eyeshadow, but it’s worth it. It is great for older women.

• Helps to rejuvinate and improve moisture level
• Dries fast, eyeshadow looks great after
• Feels nice on, not thick, mostly transparent, while providing enough coverage

Best For cut crease: Freeorr Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase primer for their daily purpose, but the freeorr eye primer for sensitive skin would be an anomoly. It is easy to blend and provide the highly pigmented eye makeup for you. It is a great prime cover for sun damage/ melisma/ age spots. The Creamy eyeshadow primer is infused with light ingredients to help balance skin tone, easy to blend, giving you a light, non-greasy eye makeup base for a smoother effect that prevents eyeshadow fading or clumping lines. Fast film forming provides a firm and smooth eye base for cut crease eye shadow makeup, keeping the eye skin dry, firmly grasp the eye shadow powder, and extending the lasting of cut crease eye makeup. It comes with a blending eye brush, which is affordable. It needs extra dry time. Delicate packaging is perfect for gifting to your loved ones.

• Hide your discoloration and balance your skin tone
• Enhance the pigment of your eyeshadow
• Good brand reputation

Best For tones: touch In Sol Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

The touch in sol eye primer for sensitive skin's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. This stuff fixes your eyeshadow and eyeliner. It goes on very sheer and matte with a bit of a fine parafin feel to it. The sheer tinted primer with smooth texture glides effortlessly over the skin, smoothing over imperfections and giving your makeup a flawless finish. It is hydrating but dries down to a matte finish. It is suitable for all skin types and tones.

This goes on easily and also doesn’t paint your eyelid a different color. It doesn't dry out the skin but helps manage oily lids. It is easy to use and isn’t overly complicated or difficult.

• Tocopheryl acetate, camellia sinensis leaf extract
• You can just swipe each eyelid and blend it out with a finger
• Long-lasting eyeshadow base without smudging and creasing, 0.14 fl.oz

Best For shiny eyes: PYT beauty Eye Primer For sensitive skin

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other primer in this category, the pyt beauty eye primer for sensitive skin has a convenient design. It is great as a transparent eyeshadow primer. It is made with antioxidants such as green tea extract, pomegrante extract, ginseng extract, and vitamin e to help moisturize and protect skin. It is made with 25% recycled plastic and 38% sugarcane based plastic. The ingredients are printed on that tape, and the tape has to be removed in order to open the cap.

This one works well if you go in with it unset, but it works well once it has time to fully dry down and set or if you set it lightly with powder. It’s pretty liquidy. The product page says it is vegan, cruelty free (leaping bunny certified), silicone free, sulfate free, paraben free, and phthalates free. It is great with no creasing.

• Sheer nude color, no color at all
• New and hot release