The 7 Best eyeliner sharpeners (2023 reviews)

We consider a eyeliner sharpener to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Loreal Paris eyeliner Sharpener READ REVIEW

Best For gel eyeliner: Buy: Revlon eyeliner Sharpener READ REVIEW

Best For gel eyeliner Pencil: Buy: elf eyeliner Sharpener READ REVIEW

Best With multiple Pencil sizes: Buy: Palladio eyeliner Sharpener READ REVIEW

Best With big eye shawdow crayons: Buy: eyeliner Sharpener READ REVIEW

Best For both regular and jumble Makeup Pencils: Buy: SHANY eyeliner Sharpener READ REVIEW

Best Easy to Use: Buy: Michael Marcus eyeliner Sharpener READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Loreal Paris eyeliner Sharpener

Buy on Amazon

This sharpener shaves the plastic pencil eyeliner casing. It has a lid to catch the shavings and a tool to help clean out sharpener if needed. It comes with a tiny pick to help clean out the makeup from the sharpener. It has the design that doesn't let you twist past a certain point.

This sharpener is designed with premium-quality steel and a lid for less mess, and includes a plastic pick for cleaning shavings from blades. The sharpener has 2 sizes so it fits a variety of pencils. There is also a little hidden pick hidden to help you get out the excess stuck crayon pieces.

• Keeps shavings off the counter & floor
• Good quality and works perfectly with those chubby pencils
• Great sharpener for thick and thin pencils

Best For gel eyeliner: Revlon eyeliner Sharpener

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate sharpener. The revlon eyeliner sharpener is exactly that - it's a simple sharpener that hits all the right notes. This is a super inexpensive sharpener that does work & it does have a german blade. It is designed to create a long, very sharp point, which is not ideal for a cosmetic pencil. It is perfect for nars lip pencils and more. The bottom and the top are removable, one side captures shavings, and the other side houses a wee small pick that lets you detail and clean the blade. Unlike most make-up pencil sharpeners, this has a nice little removable cover.

The main appeal of this sharpener is that it is the right size to sharpen nars lipstick pencils. It sharpens lipliners or small eyeliners, and it sharpens large pencils as well. It is nice to have two sizes in case you have a chubby eye or lip crayon.

• Works on the plastic casing around eyeliner‘s and lip liners really easy
• A must-have tool for your makeup bag
• Designed pencil sharpener for eyebrow pencils
• Includes a stick/pick cleaner tool, and it empties from top and bottom

Best For gel eyeliner Pencil: elf eyeliner Sharpener

Buy on Amazon

The elf eyeliner sharpener is capable of outshining several other sharpener featured in this list in overall features for the price point. It doesn't eat up or chew up your makeup pencils and works like a charm. It fits most eyeliners and lipliners and the larger one fits most jumbo eyeshadow pencils. It is great for softer makeup pencils that break easily. It keeps everything neat until you are ready to dispose of the shavings. It is easy to clean and doesn’t chew up your pencil while sharpening.

The covers are meant to keep the shavings in the sharpener chamber, and they can then be removed for easy cleaning. It catches the shavings for you in the back, and has a hidden cleaning stick in it as well. It works well, especially with gel eye liner and regular eyeliners.

• Nice and sharp eye pencil sharpener and great for the money
• Great for lip liner, easy to clean
• Can also be used to sharpen pencils
• Made of sturdy material and feels like it will last a long time

Best With multiple Pencil sizes: Palladio eyeliner Sharpener

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate sharpener. The palladio eyeliner sharpener is exactly that - it's a simple sharpener that hits all the right notes. It works on the GEL Eyeliner Pen. It has two openings for multiple size pencils. It gets pencils to a nice point without “chewing” them up. It comes with lip liner pencils, eyeliner pencils, and brow pencils. It gives them an extra fine point perfect for lining.

The small side of the sharpener fits regular sized pencils. It actually sharpens without leaving a piece of wood on the end of the pencil that can poke you while you're trying to put on your eyeliner. It doesn't chew up your liners.

• Works perfect, sharp and only shaves off a little at a time
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best With big eye shawdow crayons: eyeliner Sharpener

Buy on Amazon

The features department is where eyeliner sharpener truly manages to shine. It's like a jumbo pencil sharpener. It works with large eye liner pencils. It can make eye pencils pointed or flat when sharpening. It is great for those huge eye products that won’t fit in a standard sharpener.

The jumbo sharpener has a 1/2" diameter ( width of the circle) opening. It is perfect for the bigger sized eye and lip pencils. It is the right size for a large eyeliner pencil.

• Perfect for the large anastasia large eyelid
• Has a cleaner tool built in-very handy
• Cuts smoothly with no jagged edges formed

Best For both regular and jumble Makeup Pencils: SHANY eyeliner Sharpener

Buy on Amazon

Shany makes beautiful and great sharpener with classic and smartly choosen materials. This SHANY Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener is a no mess makeup pencil sharpener. It’s made of a plastic material and has the shany logo on the front. It fits it, so it does allow for larger liners and lip pencils. It works well on the plastic type pencils but also the wood ones.

This sharpener, though, is fresh, new, and TIDY. It’s sharp (of course because it’s new) but it has the side for regular sized pencils and the jumble pencils too, so it’s a great 2 in. It has a removable end to empty out shavings after each use, as well as allow for an easy clean up with a tool hidden inside to help.

• Sharpens thinly and doesn't break the pencil used
• Sharpens two sizes of makeup pencils
• Good investment for long term

Best Easy to Use: Michael Marcus eyeliner Sharpener

Buy on Amazon

Michael Marcus offers a variety of sharpener for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. Constructed with premium-quality long lasting carbon steel blades, whether you sharpen your gel pencil, lip pencil, or eye pencil, you will get a perfect sharp finish without the mess every time. It doesn’t catch on the edge, but is very smooth.

This is a well designed makeup pencil sharpener that does the job and catches loose shavings. It’s small enough to carry in your purse as a sharpener for your lip pencil and it contains the shavings until its convenient to empty. It is committed to providing a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

• Very convenient to carry in your purse
• Cosmetic makeup pencil sharpener easy to use
• A great staple for your makeup bag