There are several advantages of having a foam cartop carrier. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Roofbag Car Carrier READ REVIEW

Best For Safe Travels: Buy: Leader Accessories Foam Cartop Carrier READ REVIEW

Best For Weather Proof: Buy: Rightline Gear Foam Cartop Carrier READ REVIEW

Best For Easy Install: Buy: Amazon Basics Foam Cartop Carrier READ REVIEW

Best For Worth The Price: Buy: Pi Auto Foam Cartop Carrier READ REVIEW

Best For Cold Weather: Buy: Wild Xplorer Foam Cartop Carrier READ REVIEW

Best For Most Vehicles: Buy: Fieryred Foam Cartop Carrier READ REVIEW

Best For Strong Winds: Buy: Roofbag Foam Cartop Carrier READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Roofbag Car Carrier

Buy on Amazon

Here, we review a carrier that manages to win our hearts. It's the Roofbag Car Carrier and it's widely considered as one of the all-around great carriers you can buy. The roofbag car carrier is full of room, it can be bought for good value and has a compact car design. The included protective mat keeps the roof bag waterproof carrier in place and prevents scratching the roof of your car, suv, van or truck. This cargo roof bag does n't flap in the wind because it is built from heavier fabric than any other vehicle soft - shell carriers.

Lastly, the roofbag car carrier is made of nylon for unsurpassed strength, and is not stitched to the roof top car cargo carrier for additional safety.

Almost all buyers found that the carrier is easy to install and take off each night. Further, they also found that the carrier is easy to install on the roof for taller individuals. In addition, a few say that this part is a much bigger pain than a standard hard top case.

• This is stationary for several hours in pouring rain.
• This provides tons of room to add to that will also leak in the rain.
• Protect the bottom of the carrier to avoid fabric abrasion damage.
• This is great with three duffle bags on a 5 day.

Best For Safe Travels: Leader Accessories Foam Cartop Carrier

Buy on Amazon

The Leader Accessories Foam Cartop Carrier's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The leader accessories foam cartop carrier allows for a great fit and has a good design. The Manufacturer says: From RV covers to RV awnings, from powersports covers to powersports bags, from boat covers to boat seats, we provide direct access to the largest selection of products, just to make your outdoor life much more enjoyable and memorable. Further, the carrier is good for universal fit, It is great for fishing lovers and has a nice design.

The career has been dedicated to outdoor leisure enthusiasts. Above all, the leader accessories foam cartop carrier works great, can be trusted for good quality, it can be bought for good value and has a safe design.

Almost all buyers agree that the carrier is a clamp plate attachment. Further, they say that the carrier will probably ship you another one or give you your money back. Further, a few strongly agree that the carrier is easy to follow, but once it is installed it works great and it is very sturdy.

• This is easy to assemble as long as instructions are read.
• This looks like it belongs in a kids ' toy vehicle.
• Extra 4 pcs tie down straps including.
• This works fine, is very good, it is straight - forward and has a new design.

Best For Weather Proof: Rightline Gear Foam Cartop Carrier

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another carrier that manages to win our hearts. It's the Rightline Gear Foam Cartop Carrier and it's widely considered as one of the most convenient carriers you can buy. The front gear foam cartop carrier matches the range of car top carriers, thanks to their heavy-duty, xtra tough pvc semi-coated mesh construction. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Further, it works great, it holds up well and has a storage design.

The carrier is perfect for lots of room, is good for huge space, It is very easy and has a universal design. Most importantly, the front gear foam cartop carrier has a closed door, It is other than a zipper and has a watertight design.

Most customers opine that the carrier is easy to setup and clings into place well using the weather stripping hooks and a non - slip mat. And, they strongly agree that the carrier is perfect for a 2-dr coupe. In addition, a few also found that the bag is completely full, there is less of a chance of items shifting during travel. To sum up, buyers found this to be one of the best carriers for daily purposes.

• This allows for a great fit, It comes with quality straps and has a sturdy design.
• This can ’t really be beat.
• This can fit the Sylvan sport.
• It is easy to install the straps, and easy to secure.

Best For Easy Install: Amazon Basics Foam Cartop Carrier

Buy on Amazon

The amazon basic foam cartop carrier's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The amazon basic foam cartop carrier is good for light weight, It is made for worth the money and has a non-slip design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Further, it worked fine, it has features for very good quality and has a storage design.

The carrier works great, fits perfectly, it is comfortable and has a waterproof design. Lastly, the Amazon Basics Foam Cartop Carrier is very big, It is perfect for snow storms and has a safe design.

Most customers find that the carrier can be folded back into its bag and stored in the closet when not in use. Further, they strongly agree that the carrier fits in a 10"x12"x16" storage bag with some room for compression. Moreover, they also found that this cargo bag is wonderful, but beware.

• The bag is flexible ( not rigid ) so it should work well.
• This is excellent, convenient to load and secure on the trailer.
• The bag itself is weather resistant and sheds light rain well.
• It is easy to secure and adjust the straps when it is dry.

Best For Worth The Price: Pi Auto Foam Cartop Carrier

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate carrier. The Pi Auto Foam Cartop Carrier is exactly that - it's a simple carrier that hits all the right notes. The pi auto foamcartop carrier is built with quality materials, it is comfortable and has a fixed design. Place the roof rack, cargo carrier and mat on top of your vehicle. The cargo carrier bag to the top, close the zipper, and secure the straps with fasteners for extra car roof storage.

The carrier reduces wind noise, it is great for high quality and has a non-slip design. Moreover, it is perfect for high winds, is good for storage capacity, it is definitely waterproof and has a reinforced design. Lastly, the pi auto foam cartopcarrier buy again, It can ask for good quality and has a nice design.

Most buyers find that the carrier does hold a heck of a lot of stuff (see third photo) and has withstood some pretty intense storms, heat and wind but kept everything inside bone dry and as it is when packed. And, a few say that the carrier can be secured, but without the cross beams, the wind has a tendency to push the carrier backward a bit. Moreover, a few say that the bag is no longer water resistant if driving through the rain. Obviously, this carrier passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This comes with straps, contents show it is supposed to come with straps.
• This will make things soooo much easier and prevent damage to the carrier.
• This is designed to go over the top instead of being sewn onto the sides.
• This is soft sided so it should conform to the roof.

Best For Cold Weather: Wild Xplorer Foam Cartop Carrier

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase a carrier for their daily usage, but the Wild Xplorer Foam Cartop Carrier would be an anomoly. The wild xplorer foam cartop carrier needs multiple people to lift and fit, lots of space to store, and securing and removing require extra accessories, tools and considerable time. This is the only and last cargo roof bag you’ll ever need to buy. The only xxl waterproof car roof bag to offer a complete guarantee.

The carrier bought it again and it looks great. Most importantly, the wild xplorer foam cartop carrier is perfect for great quality material and it gets the job done.

Most buyers found that the carrier is designed to protect the top of your roof from getting scratched. Moreover, they also found that the carrier offers to resolve issues. Additionally, it is fairly smooth sailing. Moreover, they say that the car rooftop cargo carrier has been designed to be mounted in minutes. In short, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the career suits the purpose.

• This has reinforced straps and it would be perfect with great customer service.
• This is perfect even through rain.
• This can be tied to the crossbars on top of your highlander.
• This does not attach to your roof bars.

Best For Most Vehicles: Fieryred Foam Cartop Carrier

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Fieryred Foam Cartop Carrier for daily usage. The fieryred foamcartop carrier is designed for ultra durable construction, is more durable, it resets in place and has a sturdy design. The foamed webbing construction is engineered to keep your luggage and cargo carrier from sliding or shifting, thus making your load more secure during driving. And, it is built for ultimate protection, It is multifunctional and has a good design.

Lastly, the fieryred foam cartopcarrier can be used for universal fit, It would be perfect with durable construction and has a great design.

Most customers agree that the carrier is easy to remove after the trip. Also, they say that the carrier is a great size, plenty thick, and it stayed in place for a thousand miles driving pretty fast. And, a few say that the carrier is a perfect inexpensive way to line the bed. In conclusion, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the career suits the purpose.

• This is suitable for most vehicles, including suv, sedan,ss corssover, truck, etc.
• This is designed with a non-slip mat, It is anti-slip and has a reliable design.
• This can be used in a wide variety of vehicles.
• This is super sturdy, it is great for a great price and has a universal fit design.

Best For Strong Winds: Roofbag Foam Cartop Carrier

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate carrier. The Roofbag Foam Cartop Carrier is exactly that - it's a simple carrier that hits all the right notes. The roofbag foam cartop carrier serves its purpose, has bought a car protector and it is good for high winds. Prevents slipping or sliding of the carrier during travel. Further, the carrier is made of a special thick, rubbery, non-slip webbing material.

The carrier protects the roof's paint from scratching during travel. Lastly, the roofbag foam cartop carrier is made for a great topper and it is designed for loading with gear.

Most buyers opine that the carrier is perfect for long distance travel. Further, a few strongly agree that the carrier will last for years and is totally waterproof. In addition, they say that the carrier is perfect for car top carrier.

• This provides extra padding, helping cushion the load to protect the roof.
• This was a gift and the recipients were very happy with it.
• This protects the roof and keeps the roofbag in place.
• This is perfectly protected the roof.