The 7 Best Fresh Apple Butter (2023 reviews)

We consider a fresh apple butter to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Musselmans Fresh Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best with bagels: Buy: Mccutcheons Fresh Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best with most recipes: Buy: Green Jay Gourmet Fresh Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best For ages: Buy: Amish Valley products Fresh Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best Quality Product: Buy: Dillman farm family owned since 1970 Fresh Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best Food: Buy: Backyard Food company Fresh Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best premium: Buy: Kauffman'S Fruit farm Fresh Apple Butter READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Musselmans Fresh Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The musselmans fresh apple butter's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. It has the best flavor. It simply has the best taste and lowest added sugar of any apple butter out there. It has apples, sugar, high fruitose, apple cider, cinnamon, cloves, and corn syrup. It can be used in a new recipe with glazed pork loin chops. It comes in 32 oz., and it comes as a two pack.

The flavor is wonderful and the texture is delightfully thick. It is both sweet & spicy, like that of a good apple cider. It is perfect for a lot of uses. This is very good, especially on waffles, pork chops, and with cream cheese on toast.

• Tasty stuff, great on toast or in a pastry
• Sweetness is perfect hand taste is great definitely will buy again
• Smooth and sweet but not too sweet
• A dessert pairing good with peanut butter

Best with bagels: Mccutcheons Fresh Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Apple butter is a highly concentrated form of apple sauce produced by long, slow cooking of apples with cider or water to a point where the sugar in the apples caramelizes, turning the apple butter a deep brown. This is by far the most scrumptious apple butter out there. If you like sweet & mild yet flavorful apple butter, this is it. It makes a good fruit butter spread.

THIS TASTES LIKE HOMEMADE APPLE BUTTER. It is perfect for toast, or as filling for cakes, donut or sandwiches. It's good stuff, but is similar to cinnamon applesauce in consistency and flavor.

• Wonderful on hot homemade buttered biscuits
• Not too sweet and just the right amount of spice
• Delicious on english muffins, pancakes, etc

Best with most recipes: Green Jay Gourmet Fresh Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Green jay gourmet fruit butters bring to you the familiar, comforting butter experience with a whole lot of fruity, spicy flavors you won’t find elsewhere. Apple pecan butter, with its rich flavor profile, is a perfect addition to your favorite foods, from sandwiches & grilled chicken to parfaits & croissants. It’s crafted meticulously to maintain consistency that works with most recipes & foods.

All green jay gourmet fruit butter flavors use all-natural, real food ingredients. It is made with juicy apples, nutty pecans & laced with cinnamon, green jay gourmet apple pecan butter is just about as delicious as fruit spreads or fruit butters can get. All green jay gourmet fruit butter products contain no corn syrup, preservative or msg.

• Gluten-free & trans-fat free apple butter for guilt-free gourmet indulgences
• Fruit spreads that can deliciously replace the same-old, boring butter
• Real food ingredients, bold flavors, no junk & the sheer joy of gourmet
• Tasty and available all year round

Best For ages: Amish Valley products Fresh Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The amish valley products fresh apple butter is capable of outshining several other butter featured in this list in overall features for the price point. It’s good apple butter for ages. If you're an apple butter lover, this one will not disappoint. It is perfect for the apple butter-lover in the family. It is made in ohio's amish country 16 oz glass jar. It has a great balance between the sugar, spices and apples. This has that fresh apple taste and it has no added sugar. It is perfectly flavored with spices. This is so good on a biscuit.

• Sweetened with apple juice, wonder taste and consistency
• Great basic recipe without sugar added
• Very good product for the holiday seasons as well

Best Quality Product: Dillman farm family owned since 1970 Fresh Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Dillman Farm Family Owned Since 1970 is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist butter for people on the go, and its line of dillman farm family owned since 1970 fresh apple butter definitely falls in line with that reputation. If you are eating a low carb or sugar-free diet, this apple butter is probably the right level of sweetness for you. It is made with sweeter apples that have more natural sugars and taste too sweet. It also fits into a low carb lifestyle at just 2 grams of carbohydrate per tablespoon serving. It is made with apple pie seasoning, use with peanut butter on a low carb cinnamon muffin or a rolled tortilla, and eat on pork chops.

This apple butter is absolutely delicious plus it's guilt free with no sugar, no artificial sweeteners and no additives. It tastes sweet enough even though there is no added sugar. The Tasty product has the right amount of organic cinnamon and the best part is that it is made from organic apples on a family owned farm.

• Won’t break the bank in terms of calories
• Organic cinnamon and organic michigan apples
• Organic and no added sugar and the flavor is phenomenal

Best Food: Backyard Food company Fresh Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other butter in this category, the backyard food company fresh apple butter has a convenient design. Big Apple butter is the perfect accompaniment to every meal whether paired with a breakfast sausage, as a spread on your favorite sandwich, baked onto pork chops or even with ice cream for a sweet dessert. It makes good food great or simply stands alone. It's unbelievable on fresh baked bread, it's even better on pork or chicken. It is made in small batches with simple, all-natural ingredients you would use at home.

• Made in a facility that handles nuts
• Delicious and evocative of sweet autumn treats
• Just the right amount of apple and sweetness

Best premium: Kauffman'S Fruit farm Fresh Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The kauffman's fruit farm fresh apple butter is long-lasting, rigid and fits well with your regular usage like a dream. It is not a treat that you tire of, It is in the ranks of a good jelly or butter for your toast and is a great condiment for pork and ham. It’s an authentic, homemade, small batch fruit product without any added preservatives. Instead, it’s a fruit delicacy with a spreadable consistency like soft butter that’s delicious on bagels, crackers, toast, and ice cream. It is made with only a few simple ingredients, such as fresh apples, freshly-pressed apple cider, and cinnamon.

• Great flavor, low carbs relative to brand names, thick-not runny
• Thick, well mixed and sooooo many excellent recipes
• Real apple butter without processed sugar