The 8 Best gourmet Ketchup (2023 reviews)

The look and feel of this ketchup are consistent with the high quality we're used to from the rest of Whataburger's lineup. It's perfect for a homesick texan who cannot get a whataburger fix. It tastes exactly the same as you can get in the drive though.

Why We Like This:

Delivers what they promise
Good investment for long term

Best For Keto: Primal kitchen gourmet Ketchup

Buy on Amazon

The primal kitchen gourmet ketchup is the best suitable ketchup on the market today. This brand does a great job of making condiments that are tasty and not full of the nasty stuff. This recipe tastes much like eating thick tomato puree or tomato paste with little to no seasoning. The ketchup is unsweetened and in a glass container. It’s healthy and fresh. The ketchup taste great and this is amazing taking into account there is no added sugar. This one is delicious and made with real food.

Why We Like This:

Glass bottle is good for the planet
Fantastic on burgers, meatloaf, chicken, and anything else you'd toss some ketchup onto
Great for turkey burgers or anything else you put ketchup on

Best tasting Product: Sir Kensingtons gourmet Ketchup

Buy on Amazon

The sir kensingtons gourmet ketchup is capable of outshining several other ketchup featured in this list in overall features in its price range. If you are looking for ketchup that actually tastes of tomatoes and not just paste and sugar, you'll need look no further. This one is nice and tangy with an acidic punch of vinegar that works great either on its own as a condiment for burgers, fries, or even eggs, or as an ingredient in a meatloaf or bbq sauce. This ketchup is more flavorful, and has a more concentrated tomato taste. It is a little zesty, and elevates the flavor of a lot of items. There's no watery pool to come out first.

Why We Like This:

High fructose corn syrup, gmo free, soy free and on and on
Tastes fresher and has a more savory flavor
Has a great taste with no lingering back taste

Best Organic Ketchup: Made In Oregon gourmet Ketchup

Buy on Amazon

The made in oregon gourmet ketchup is capable of outshining several other ketchup featured in this list in overall features in its price range. This is great tasting, healthier, and well prepared condiment, made with a nice balance of organic ingredients that can go with a variety of foods. It's almost a blend between catsup and bbq sauce. Aside from burgers it elevates your fries to a couple notches. It's all-natural and maybe even organic. It is made with 7 simple ingredients, it's healthy, but can hold its own with the best ketchups on the market.

This is on the pricy side, but tastes amazing so use sparingly where you really have the ketchup flavor shine. It is much more multidimensional in flavor and rich. It has more of a depth of flavor and is a thicker, more textured sauce.

Why We Like This:

Much stronger and delicious flavor profile than heinz
Great taste, organic, and in a glass bottle
Good investment for long term

Best For every Ketchup application: Portland Ketchup company gourmet Ketchup

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention portland ketchup company gourmet ketchup for daily purpose. There is something that is just so unique about its flavor, it doesn't taste like your standard Heinz in the best way possible. It has beautiful labels. This bottle is conveniently widemouthed to prevent any watery fall out. It is made without high fructose corn syrup. It has a great taste and a smooth texture.

The bottle mouth is wide, so you can get the trusty knife in there if you need. It is a little sweet but also has a wonderful tomato taste.

Why We Like This:

Tasty and an excellent alternative to regular ketchup
You can taste the different depths of flavor
Delivers what they promise

Best Polish Ketchup: Pudliszki gourmet Ketchup

Buy on Amazon

Pudliszki is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist ketchup for people on the go, and its line of pudliszki gourmet ketchup definitely falls in line with that reputation. This Polish ketchup tastes slightly different than American ketchup, but it's also very good. The Pudliszki ketchup is a high quality, American style ketchup with a Polish twist.

Why We Like This:

Good brand reputation
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best PREMIUM: Sabatino Tartufi gourmet Ketchup

Buy on Amazon

Sabatino truffles hand crafted from scratch this one of kind truffle infused hot ketchup with all natural ingredients so that you can elevate your grilling game. The delicately balanced truffle ketchup infusion will make you the ultimate grill master. This ketchup is thick, luxurious and has just enough truffle flavor to add to the experience. It's a great alternative from the classic flavor when you're looking for something more exciting. It's a perfect combination of a home favorite spiced up with heat and truffles.

Why We Like This:

All natural, no fructose, no preservatives, no additives, no artificial ingredients and vegetarian
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best Flavor: Geo Watkins gourmet Ketchup

Buy on Amazon

The geo watkins gourmet ketchup is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily purpose. It's great for 21st century cooking too. It has a mushroom beefy flavor. This is not thick like American tomato ketchup, and is very watery and salty like the equivalent of mushroom soy sauce. It adds a delicious salty umami flavor to all kinds of dishes.

Why We Like This:

Tastes great with meat, especially steak or gamey meat, such as lamb
Delivers what they promise

The 8 Best gourmet Ketchup (2023 reviews)

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Whataburger gourmet Ketchup

Best For Keto: Primal kitchen gourmet Ketchup

Best tasting Product: Sir Kensingtons gourmet Ketchup

Best Organic Ketchup: Made In Oregon gourmet Ketchup

Best For every Ketchup application: Portland Ketchup company gourmet Ketchup

Best Polish Ketchup: Pudliszki gourmet Ketchup

Best PREMIUM: Sabatino Tartufi gourmet Ketchup

Best Flavor: Geo Watkins gourmet Ketchup

10 Best Natural Tomato Ketchup