The 10 Best Grill Tray Liners (2023 reviews)

We consider a grill tray liner to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Traeger Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best For Griddle: Buy: Profire Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best For But They: Buy: Salbree Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best Replacement Tray: Buy: Bull outdoor products Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best For smoker: Buy: NUPICK Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best With Drip Tray: Buy: fire magic Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best For pellet: Buy: BBQ future Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best For BBQ: Buy: TYH supplies Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best For pellet Grill: Buy: Green Mountain Grills Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best With Grease trap: Buy: Jin Better Grill Parts Grill Tray Liner READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Traeger Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

Traeger line of liner come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. This product saves a lot of time, when it comes to cleaning the barbecue. They cover the smokers drip pan well and make clean-up much easier. They still fit under the drip shoot and do the job nicely. The aluminum is heavy gage and they can be used several times.

The cooking grate has to be removed for either method but with the trays you don't have to take out the drip tray to wrap the foil. They dont leak and are easy to throw away. This will be slightly sier to swap out than peeling off the layers of foil.

• Makes the grill so much easier to clean, without using aluminum foil
• Easy clean up, easy to install
• Easy cleanup, a bit small for the provided bucket
• Saves a lot of cleanup time

Best For Griddle: Profire Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

The profire grill tray liner gives the top-tier liner a run for their money by offering flagship specs at a much more affordable price. These are a perfect size when cooking other items like the meat along with them. It can be used to store your delicious food when bbq, holiday family gatherings, picnics, road trips, and large event preparations. It can be rinsed/washed between uses to extend the life of each rigid foil drip pan. It can also be used to bake a smaller portion of food or cakes, bread, and cookies.

These items are easy to clean if you choose to do so. They are a bit small and a bit soft. It is enough to use and you do get several containers. It is great for holding small credit cards, and will last through many grilling sessions.

• Perfect weber grill replacement drip pan
• Good to make food for someone elderly
• Great drip pans, they are the perfect size and are nice and sturdy

Best For But They: Salbree Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

Salbree line of liner come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. It makes cleaning out your traeger grease bucket a snap. This bucket liner is very sturdy & can provide multiple uses before having to discard. It fits well, they are a bit thinner than expected. It fits great for the pitboss grease drain bucket.

This has made cleaning up so easy, it's worth every penny. These fit well and are sturdy and hold the grease with no leakage. It is perfectly sized for the bucket on the traeger pro.

• Fit nicely and makes clean up super simple
• Makes grill bucket clean up simple
• Makes cleanup a breeze when removing grease from pellet smoker

Best Replacement Tray: Bull outdoor products Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

Bull Outdoor Products makes beautiful and great liner with classic and smartly choosen materials. It keeps your grill clean and prevents grease fires by making it easy to replace the grease tray liners regularly. It fits the grill great to add to that fits well for bull grills.

• Disposable trays that make cleaning the grease tray easy, just remove and replace
• Works ok, fits well for bull grills
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best For smoker: NUPICK Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

The nupick grill tray liner is capable of outshining several other liner featured in this list in overall features for the price point. The NUPICK aluminum foil series provide quality cooking experiences without the need to clean up. They catch the grease as designed.

• Sturdy aluminum will not melt under the hottest of smoker grease
• Delivers what they promise

Best With Drip Tray: fire magic Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

Best part: fire magic grill tray liner costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. Custom-designed for Fire Magic grills and sold in packs of 4, these convenient disposable drip tray liners reduce the risk of grease fires. These are a perfect replacement trays. It is designed for fire magic grills.

• Perfect fit for aurora fire magic
• Make cleaning of drip tray mush easer
• Reduces the risk of grease fires

Best For pellet: BBQ future Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate liner. The bbq future grill tray liner is exactly that - it's a simple liner that hits all the right notes. This is the sub-branding of bbq future, which focused on developing blackstone griddle accessories, grill cart, fire pit and more. It fits the members mark 4 burner grill perfectly. It is compatible with traeger bac404 pellet grill, timberline 1300 and timberline 850 pellet grills only for traeger grills. It is made of 100% recyclable aluminum, eco-friendly rear grease cup liner.

The Pans are sturdy and easy to clean. It is a professional outdoor grilling experience manufacturer.

• Excellent fit for the members mark 36 inch griddle grease pan
• More dirty grease cup to clean up
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best For BBQ: TYH supplies Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other liner in this category, the tyh supplies grill tray liner has a convenient design. This universal grease tray is up to the task on nearly all of the popular BBQ grills on the market. It comes with up to a staggering 1100 degrees heat resistance, this backyard grill drip tray handles the heat in any outdoor kitchen, car camping, outdoor picnic or garden bbq party setting. It is made for all rectangular pellet grill and smoker brands such as rectec, oklahoma joe's, cuisinart, and replaceable for traeger bac458 drip trays.

This drip pan grill has clever lipped edges to ensure the grease stays put, does not overflow, and is easily disposed of with ergonomic carrying handles when it’s time to chow down. The best part is the flap (a thin piece that folds up from the back side) which molds nicely to the drip tray “off ramp” to guide drippings into the bucket. These drip tray liners fit the Traeger Ranger better than the Traeger brand version.

• Good brand reputation
• Good investment for long term

Best For pellet Grill: Green Mountain Grills Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

The green mountain grills grill tray liner is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your regular usage. 4103 Green Mountain Grills offers an expert solution to make cooking life easier, and outcomes tastier. It features 3 disposable liners designed for the gmg daniel boone model, and measures 23.5 x 15.5 x 0.3 inches. It comes with grease pan grill liner sheets, so you'll never need to worry again about stubborn charred grease that can spoil your dinner.

• Need to worry again about stubborn charred grease
• Good investment for long term

Best With Grease trap: Jin Better Grill Parts Grill Tray Liner

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate liner. The jin better grill parts grill tray liner is exactly that - it's a simple liner that hits all the right notes.

• New and hot release
• Good brand reputation