The 6 Best Hickory Wood Hammer Handles (2023 reviews)

This handle is for a large framing hammer, with a square eye. It's a great hammer and will help you get the job done without much effort. It has a tear drop shaped eye, with the wide end of the teardrop in the direction the handle curves towards, and the skinny part on the back side of the handle, that it curves away from. Love the hammer, but the design of the handle makes it really narrow at the point where it enters the head of the hammer and you can shear it right off with a good pull.

The size is approx 1 3/4" x 5/8" And it is a triangular shaped oval with the smaller part to the back. It's great the best handle ever worked perfectly. This handle can not be used with an axe or a hatchet.

Why We Like This:

Excellent ergonomics, will reduce carpenters elbow symptoms greatly
Comes with wooden and metal wedges and installation instructions
Great handle to a great hammer

Best For sledgehammer: Seymour Hickory Wood Hammer Handle

Buy on Amazon

It is a really well made, straight grained, hard wood handle. It includes the wood wedge and metal wedge to help secure the handle, making a really tight fit. The handle is fairly easy to shape, at the oval eye insertion end, with an 80 grit belt on a belt sander. It works well as a hammer handle.

The handle is a narrower ellipse than the head. It is meaty, and sturdy. It comes with a bit of sanding, and this handle repaired a 4 lb hammer.

Why We Like This:

Tight fit for 3 lb blacksmith hammer
Perfect replacement for 4 lb sledge
Perfect replacement for a blacksmith hammer
Nice handle and they give you two different wedges

Best Replacement Handle: Link Handles Hickory Wood Hammer Handle

Buy on Amazon

It is made with heavyweight hickory. It comes with all the necessary wedges very strong hickory sapwood. With grain running the right way front to back with the face and claws of the hammer head. The handle wood is very good quality. It is perfect replacement handle for a very, very old hammer. The Great quality hickory handle with little fitting required comes with all the necessary wedges very strong hickory sapwood.

Why We Like This:

Clears small trees or brush with a quick swipe
One of the new comers and featured product

Best Quality Handle: Link Handles natural wax finish

Buy on Amazon

The link handles natural wax finish's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. It is made of hickory, not the highest quality. The shape and lines are very similar to the old vintage style of handles. It is a spare ball peen hammer handle.

Why We Like This:

Has good grip and a smooth finish
Great replacement handle a little rasping and sanding and it fits well
One of the new comers and featured product

Best finish: Martin Sprocket & gear Hickory Wood Hammer Handle

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase handle for their daily usage, but the martin sprocket & gear hickory wood hammer handle would be an anomoly. This hammer handle is for a small hammer head of an approximate 8 ounce. It fits the hammer head great and fits older tool body hammers.

Why We Like This:

Good handle for a small mallet
Fit well on a 3/8" x 5/8" (top)opening on hammer head
New and hot release

Best For Sturdiness: Vaughan Hickory Wood Hammer Handle

Buy on Amazon

Best part: vaughan hickory wood hammer handle costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. It fits brand blacksmith hammers, includes wedges, material hickory, handle type straight, overall length 16 inches.

Why We Like This: