The 7 Best Hydrogenated shortenings (2023 reviews)

We consider a hydrogenated shortening to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: SCP South Chicago packing Hydrogenated Shortening READ REVIEW

Best coconut Oil: Buy: Spectrum Hydrogenated Shortening READ REVIEW

Best For Organic Palm Oil Shortening: Buy: grain Brain Hydrogenated Shortening READ REVIEW

Best For cooking: Buy: Nutiva Hydrogenated Shortening READ REVIEW

Best For greasing pans: Buy: Crisco Hydrogenated Shortening READ REVIEW

Best For buttercream: Buy: Spectrum better alternative READ REVIEW

Best Shortening: Buy: Stratas foods Hydrogenated Shortening READ REVIEW

Best overall: SCP South Chicago packing Hydrogenated Shortening

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing short of the optimal shortening for your regular usage, this scp south chicago packing hydrogenated shortening is certainly a wise investment. The South Chicago natural old-fashioned lard contains zero artificial trans fats or partially hydrogenated oils and is natural, sustainable, with minimal processing. It replaces butter in a lot of recipes as well, so it's very versatile and has a good high smoke point and adds a taste you can't get from canola, coconut, olive or peanut oils. It will definitely have pork flavor and smell, but it is created by melting down pork fat that is not cured or seasoned with salt or smoke.

This container of lard at first appears to be in a metal can but actually it is a plastic tub. It will be solid at room temperature. It can be used as shortening for tortillas, yum.

• Adds great taste to your favorite foods
• Flaky, light, and a richer flavor
• Perfect for vintage & historical recipes
• Velvet smooth texture lard makes perfect pastry

Best coconut Oil: Spectrum Hydrogenated Shortening

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase shortening for their daily usage, but the spectrum hydrogenated shortening would be an anomoly. This makes the best tortillas. It is made with organic palm oil, and the spectrum of organic shortening is non-hydrogenated making it an excellent alternative to traditional shortening for flaky crusts and crispy fries. It's antibacterial/antifungal attributes are invaluable. It really moisturizes them well.

This shortening has great flavor and is a really great organic product. It is amazing on chemically processed hair. It is in so much of the food on the grocery shelves. It is the only thing that can replace cris o or other trransfsy oils that are solid.

• Awesome shortening for your everyday baking or cooking
• Palm oil is medicinal and works perfectly
• Excellent all vegetable shortening as opposed to crisco
• Does an excellent job in gluten free baking

Best For Organic Palm Oil Shortening: grain Brain Hydrogenated Shortening

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other shortening in this category, the grain brain hydrogenated shortening has a convenient design. It helps make the best grain free cookies and cakes. It is a good source for organic palm oil shortening. This shortening is a good value and since it is tasteless-it's perfect for high-heat frying, making biscuits or pan searing. The consistency is softer and more chocolaty. It is recommended for delicate cakes.

The shortening is not red, it actually looks a lot like butter or margarine. It is solid at room temperature and has a neutral smell and taste. It is inexpensive but works well. These are also certified by the roundtable on sustainable palm oil.

• Great product for persons allergic to other more conventional shortening or oils
• Great palm shortening and a good value
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best For cooking: Nutiva Hydrogenated Shortening

Buy on Amazon

The nutiva hydrogenated shortening is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. The golden color reveals the presence of antioxidant vitamins A & E naturally found in red palm oil. It is great substitute for butter or shortening in baked goods. This stuff is high in nutrients such as Vitamins A & E as well as other health-promoting agents so it's good for you. It is great for baking, frying, and sautéing and is an excellent alternative to butter.

The palm oil is for creating flaky baked goods, the coconut oil provides the added health benefits of lauric acid. The fat makes all the difference when it comes to frying. This shortening is vegan and contains no dairy, soy or canola. It is perfect substitute for butter or shortening in baked goods. It is organic, non-GMO and Fair Trade certified.

• Delivers what they promise
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For greasing pans: Crisco Hydrogenated Shortening

Buy on Amazon

The crisco hydrogenated shortening should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. The shortening product made of plant based oils and oil seeds to create the cooking oil that was promoted for its light taste, crisco has been making life in the kitchen more delicious for years. It is recognized, comfortable, and trusted across generations, yet it is simple and unadorned. It gives a lightness to whatever you're baking and it doesn't affect the taste in any way. It is also a versatile ingredient that adapts to your cooking style.

It is great for greasing pans, or use with fondant or gumpaste. It's fairly shelf stable and easier to ship around than oil.

• Great favor for any cookie dough
• Helps make delicious fried food and helps to leave baked food light and fluffy
• Include canola, corn, and natural blend oils
• Works great on squeaky doors too

Best For buttercream: Spectrum better alternative

Buy on Amazon

The spectrum better alternative is capable of outshining several other shortening featured in this list in overall features for the price point. Spectrum palm fruit oil is certified by the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil and is also sourced solely from Columbia where there are no orangutans. It's fair trade certified, non-gmo, and non-hydrogenated palm oil that's genuinely good for you. It is made with organic palm oil, spectrum organic shortening is a healthy, trans-fat free alternative to traditional shortening for flaky crusts and crispy fries.

This is great for baking, making vegan frosting's. The shortening is absolutely the best quality, taste and texture for all your baking needs. It is great as a butter sub in baking too. It works well in all kinds of baking.

• Great stuff for gluten free meals and desserts
• Lightweight, no scent or taste, it's a perfectly neutral shortening
• Works great as a typical shortening substitute
• Works well with baking and making icing

Best Shortening: Stratas foods Hydrogenated Shortening

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention stratas foods hydrogenated shortening for daily purpose. This emulsified vegetable shortening is specially formulated for use in icings. It makes a very smooth buttercream that holds up to the heat. It comes in a huge block, so it's best to have large food safe containers ready to divide it into. It is perfect high ratio shortening for icing. It is a hi-ratio shortening. It stays good for a long time as long as it's kept in a dry cool place and you are maticulate about not contaminating it.

• Diglycerides, polysorbate 60, tbhq and citric acid added to help preserve freshness
• Include pictures of kitchen crafts and alpines ingredients
• Good investment for long term