The 6 Best local Apple Butter (2023 reviews)

The musselmans apple butter's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. It has the best flavor. It simply has the best taste and lowest added sugar of any apple butter out there. It has apples, sugar, high fruitose, apple cider, cinnamon, cloves, and corn syrup. It can be used in a new recipe with glazed pork loin chops. It comes in 32 oz., and it comes as a two pack.

This is very good, especially on waffles, pork chops, and with cream cheese on toast. The flavor is wonderful and the texture is delightfully thick. It is perfect for a lot of uses. It is both sweet & spicy, like that of a good apple cider.

Why We Like This:

Tasty stuff, great on toast or in a pastry
Sweetness is perfect hand taste is great definitely will buy again
Smooth and sweet but not too sweet
A dessert pairing good with peanut butter

Best with most recipes: Green Jay Gourmet local Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Green jay gourmet fruit butters bring to you the familiar, comforting butter experience with a whole lot of fruity, spicy flavors you won’t find elsewhere. Apple pecan butter, with its rich flavor profile, is a perfect addition to your favorite foods, from sandwiches & grilled chicken to parfaits & croissants. It’s crafted meticulously to maintain consistency that works with most recipes & foods.

All green jay gourmet fruit butter flavors use all-natural, real food ingredients. It is made with juicy apples, nutty pecans & laced with cinnamon, green jay gourmet apple pecan butter is just about as delicious as fruit spreads or fruit butters can get. The rich, fruity, spicy flavor profile is made even more luxurious with its creamy, crunchy texture. Green jay gourmet fruit butter products contain no corn syrup, preservative or msg.

Why We Like This:

Gluten-free & trans-fat free apple butter for guilt-free gourmet indulgences
Fruit spreads that can deliciously replace the same-old, boring butter
Tasty and available all year round
Real food ingredients, bold flavors, no junk & the sheer joy of gourmet

Best with bagels: Mccutcheons local Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The mccutcheons local apple butter might be a relatively new release, but it's still nothing short of impressive this year. This is by far the most scrumptious apple butter out there. It makes a good fruit butter spread. It can be used as a gift for apple lovers, teachers, hostesses, or any time you need a gift for the holiday's, and of course for yourself. THIS TASTES LIKE HOMEMADE APPLE BUTTER. It is made from a time-tested family recipe, it's slow cooked in small batches for a rich, mellow flavor that's lightly spiced with a hint of sweetness. This apple butter tastes fresh and you can tell there aren't a bunch of additives.

Why We Like This:

Not to thick, not runny, and good taste, and natural
Wonderful on hot homemade buttered biscuits
Not too sweet and just the right amount of spice

Best Food: Backyard Food company local Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The backyard food company local apple butter is capable of outshining several other butter featured in this list in overall features for the price point. Big Apple butter is the perfect accompaniment to every meal whether paired with a breakfast sausage, as a spread on your favorite sandwich, baked onto pork chops or even with ice cream for a sweet dessert. It makes good food great or simply stands alone. It's unbelievable on fresh baked bread, it's even better on pork or chicken. It is made in small batches with simple, all-natural ingredients you would use at home.

Why We Like This:

Delicious and evocative of sweet autumn treats
Made in a facility that handles nuts
Just the right amount of apple and sweetness

Best Giftable: Stonewall kitchen local Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

They are big fans of ice cream and the woman is particularly fond of caramel. The Caramel Apple Butter is a nice alternative to the regular, thick syrups that are often used as toppers. It is spreadable but it is not as thick as peanut butter. This definitely has the consistency of apple butter and the flavor of apple butter as well with just a hint of caramel.

It's the perfect topping for your favorite ice cream, cake or pastry. It is for a sumptuous breakfast treat, spoon caramel apple butter on pancakes, waffles, or french toast.

Why We Like This:

Create an elegant dessert by filling a pastry shell and top with whipped cream
Great as a gift or for yourself
Delivers what they promise