The 7 Best Milk replacers (2023 reviews)

We consider a milk replacer to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Manna Pro Milk Replacer READ REVIEW

Best For wildlife rehabilitation: Buy: Petag Milk Replacer READ REVIEW

Best For Puppies: Buy: Sav A Caf Milk Replacer READ REVIEW

Best For rescue squirrels: Buy: exotic nutrition Milk Replacer READ REVIEW

Best with dog food: Buy: Tailspring Milk Replacer READ REVIEW

Best with colostrum: Buy: Premier 1 Supplies Milk Replacer READ REVIEW

Best For Lamb: Buy: Homestead Harvest Milk Replacer READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Manna Pro Milk Replacer

Buy on Amazon

We are personally inclined towards manna pro milk replacer, it is not so pricy, but it overachieves its purpose and outstanding in important aspects. This is an excellent product to bottle raise baby goats. It is good as a regular creamer. The replacer powder is quickly and easily mixed with water and thankfully does not clump. It is easy to mix and the kids like it well. There’s no unmixable residue left in the 1 quart jar when the liquid is poured into the feeding bottle.

This is an excellent milk replacer for goat kids. It is used for baby kittens and it's perfect. It is easy to use palatable to many kinds of animals.

• Great replacement milk for feeding wildlife
• Contains a source of live (viable), naturally-occurring microorganisms
• Good brand reputation

Best For wildlife rehabilitation: Petag Milk Replacer

Buy on Amazon

The petag milk replacer is capable of outshining several other replacer featured in this list in overall features for the price point. It is a wonderful replacement for their mother's milk. It is perfect formula for baby critters. It is specially formulated with a balance of protein, fat, carbohydrates, and essential vitamins and minerals to ensure proper development and growth in puppies. It is formulated to provide a caloric pattern similar to mother's milk in protein, fat, and carbohydrates. The puppies like the flavor and this has worked well out of the bowl. It mixes well at room temperature. They also have techs on hand to answer your questions about rescuing wildlife. It provides a complete diet for puppies that have been orphaned or rejected.

• Great for puppies and females who are nursing their puppies
• Great product for raising thriving puppies
• Gives them nutrients their body needs

Best For Puppies: Sav A Caf Milk Replacer

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing but a replacer that is satisfactory, this sav a caf milk replacer is certainly a worthy investment. Dogs look and feel great when this is part of their daily vitamin regiment. It is great for puppies to gain that weight. It has help in feeding, gaining weight, vitiemins, and hope this helps. It's good and you won't go through it too fast depending on the size of your animal.

This product is made for babies with supplements for young animals. It is easy to mix in small or bigger batches. Dogs love it either way, but the water ensures hydration during hunting season.

• Convenient for humans, maybe lacking nutrition for puppies and kittens
• Good for ill cats and chubby dogs
• Inexpensive when compared to pre packaged kitten milk
• Great for puppy and newborn pitt bulls best product

Best For rescue squirrels: exotic nutrition Milk Replacer

Buy on Amazon

Exotic Nutrition offers a variety of replacer for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. This milk is great for rescue squirrels. It smells sweet like a protein workout powder instead of that awful smell that the puppy milk has. It is formulated to closely match mother's milk in protein, fat, and carbohydrates. It is a quick & easy powdered milk replacement formula and a complete food source for orphaned or rejected baby animals, as well as pregnant females. It is 24% protein and 24% fat. It can be stored up to 6 months unrefrigerated or in the freezer up to a year.

You can serve the milk replacer right after mixing, or you can store the mixture refrigerated for 10 days, or frozen for 6 months. It provides foundation of nutrients for strong development.

• Brings all the squirrels to the yard
• Contains 250 grams or 8.8 ounces
• Enriched with high-quality protein sources, vitamins, minerals, and essential amino acids
• All natural, no preservatives, made in the usa

Best with dog food: Tailspring Milk Replacer

Buy on Amazon

The tailspring milk replacer is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. It is ideal for puppy's sensitive stomach. It is made with whole goat milk and 100% human grade ingredients. It’s easy to use and mix. It can be used as a nutritious meal topper or treat for adult dogs. It is made without the use of preservatives, artificial colors or flavors. It mixes easily with no clumping.

• Tasty, healthy and nutritious for your pet
• Powdered milk replacer for puppies made with whole goat milk
• Good investment for long term

Best with colostrum: Premier 1 Supplies Milk Replacer

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another replacer that manages to win our hearts. It's the premier 1 supplies milk replacer and it's widely considered as replacer that has the most suitable features. The first ingredient of The Shepherd’s Choice Lamb and Kid Milk Replacer is skim milk. It is a milk replacer that has had organic acids added to the mixture. It is naturally high in casein–the same protein found in skim milk powder. It comes with citristim for baby lambs and goat kids. It is a “fast protein” which is quickly assimilated, but can result in intestinal hemorrhage syndrome and abomasal bloat if fed too quickly.

The lambs’ consumption per day will surprise you—as will the daily cost of the milk replacer. This “slow protein” aids in digestion.

• Offer dry creep feed in a feeder
• Formulated by experienced shepherds and veterinarians for their own sheep and goat flocks
• Improved digestion and higher daily gains
• Instant milk replacer with citristim for baby lambs and goat kids

Best For Lamb: Homestead Harvest Milk Replacer

Buy on Amazon

The homestead harvest milk replacer should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease.

• Good brand reputation
• Good investment for long term