The 9 Best natural eyelid primers (2023 reviews)

The milani natural eyelid primer is specially designed for your daily usage and has plenty of most useful features. The Milani eye primer has amazing staying power. It is very light colored but it rubs in basically clear. It spreads very easily with light tapping and dried quickly. This primer prevents powder shadows from sinking into the creases and improves the overall appearance. It really makes your eyeshadow last much longer.

The Milani shadow primer works well, keeps your lids dry, and shadow stays on and does not crease hours after wear. It comes off with makeup removers, just like any high end quality, but still does the job it's meant to do.

Why We Like This:

Can apply with finger or brush
Takes a tiny amount to cover entire eye area
Great little eyeshadow primer that lasts all day
Amazing inexpensive dupe for urban decay primer potion

Best For oilier eyelids: NYX professional Makeup natural eyelid Primer

Buy on Amazon

The nyx professional makeup natural eyelid primer's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The NYX ultimate shadow and liner primer helps anyone achieve beautiful eye makeup no matter how level your makeup skills might be. It offers a soft blurring effect to create the perfect canvas for infinite eye looks. It’s great to be used for any type of eyeshadow such as powdery, matte or glittery ones as it makes the eyeshadow stays all day long without any problem.

This product puts a matte finish that keeps liner and shadow from smearing. It has a good consistency and spreads nicely with a fingertip. It’s soft on the tip and glides smoothly over the skin. Doing a gentle rub test, the nyx is also the clear winner, with no transfer and no disturbing of the pigment. The primer is a sheer beige color. It takes five minutes to fully dry and set on the eyelids.

Why We Like This:

Drys too fast no time to blend shadows
Very tacky (for better and worse) not the most hygienic applicator
Goes on well as a base for eyeshadow
Great small product to store in makeup bag for everyday use

Best For sensitive skin: E.L.F. natural eyelid Primer

Buy on Amazon

Best part: e.l.f. Natural eyelid primer costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. This eye primer does exactly what it is supposed to and provides a decent foundation for eye makeup. It glides on easily with no super greasy mess leading to shadow clumps. It works as a great basecoat for your eyeshadow. It goes on light with almost no color, does not emphasize wrinkles, and stays on all day. It does leave a white dusty tone behind.

It dries with only a slight color, but does help to hide eyelid flaws.

Why We Like This:

Eye makeup stays on all day
Prevents creasing, but definitely fades out by end of day
Enough to last through work or a night out
Comparable to urban decays eyeshadow primer

Best For Shadow Base: MAEPEOR natural eyelid Primer

Buy on Amazon

Maepeor offers a variety of primer for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. This glitter eye primer goes on evenly and blended easily with your eyeshadow or glitter, you don't need to worry about the eyeshadow crease and the eyeshadow color changed. It is the hue and inspiration of the catwalk, and gorgeous high-saturated eye makeup changes the color. It's somewhat shiny. It is the best companion for eyeshadow, making eyeshadow more colored and more saturated.

It is natural and environmentally friendly and safe to use. You can maximize glitter & keep sparkling with this glitter primer and without all the mess in your tent. It lasts 8+ hours. It is great for shadow base.

Why We Like This:

Comes off with warm water last all day
Make eyeshadow lasting, keep makeup for 24 hours, waterproof and sweat proof
Lightweight and portable, uniform application, beautiful in use, without any accumulation or spots

Best For crease: Jolie impeccable me natural eyelid Primer

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about appropriate and satisfactory primer, jolie impeccable me natural eyelid primer is your end point. This eye shadow base is terrific. It magnetizes eye shadow color to your eyelids and holds it in place for extra ultra-long wear. It is thick but creamy, so a little goes a long way. The density of the light color is fantastic for an eyeshadow base. It will only crease if you put too much on—you only need to tap your eyelids and your shadow will be perfect.

This is a great base for eyeshadow. It is a great sheet covering base for eyelids, but it hugs shadows and shows their true qualities. The shadow magnet is a must have.

Why We Like This:

Light, blends well and holds the shadow
Stays on without any creasing and eye shadow color goes on smooth and true
Great for minimizing lines and creases

Best For older women: Ilia natural eyelid Primer

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase primer for their regular usage, but the ilia natural eyelid primer would be an anomoly. This brilliant eye primer creates the ideal canvas, sure to keep shadows + liner looking on point all day, illuminating eyes while locking pigments into place. It instantly illuminates your eyes with a radiant sheen. It’s kind of sticky and dries clear. It is an anti-inflammatory that helps to de-puff. It’s great for older women.

This product is sheer with a slight shimmer, very slight shimmer, and very slight shimmer. It does need an extra bit of time to dry before applying eyeshadow, but it’s worth it. This works well for being a clean alternative.

Why We Like This:

Dries fast, eyeshadow looks great after
Feels nice on, not thick, mostly transparent, while providing enough coverage
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best With SPF: Bellaterra cosmetics natural eyelid Primer

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention bellaterra cosmetics natural eyelid primer for regular usage. Eye primer creates a clean canvas on your eyelids to enhance the pigment and color of each eye shadow. It allows eye shadow to stick on to your eyelids all day without smudging or creasing. It comes with an even skin tone on your eyelids, your eyes pop to give you a glowy, no-fuss look. It's tacky consistency makes a great base and the product is build-able.

It's a great base for eye shadow, giving you a very smooth look. Eye primer can be mixed with shimmers prior to application to create a matte appearance, allowing for more versatility. It's worth it. It is made with a hypoallergenic formula, every day is a “good makeup day” with beautiful coverage that conceals and heals problematic skin types like.

Why We Like This:

Great not only as eye primer but concealer
Has a thick paste consistency and is very highly pigmented
Great for highlighter under the eyes for anyone with fair-medium skin

Best For shiny eyes: PYT beauty natural eyelid Primer

Buy on Amazon

The pyt beauty natural eyelid primer's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. Pyt Beauty eye primer is a nude, sheer matte eye primer perfect before applying any shadows. It is sheer for a light-skinned person. It is made with antioxidants such as green tea extract, pomegrante extract, ginseng extract, and vitamin e to help moisturize and protect skin. It provides coverage for minor imperfections on the eyelid and a good base for eye shadow color.

The product page says it is vegan, cruelty free (leaping bunny certified), silicone free, sulfate free, paraben free, and phthalates free. It is very light and blended in smoothly. It has the ingredients on a sticker that is also used as a seal going over where the cap comes off. This primer is very liquidy, so it goes on with zero drag. It is great with no creasing.

Why We Like This:

Sheer nude color, no color at all
New and hot release

Best PREMIUM: Luneaster natural eyelid Primer

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about a luxury primer, luneaster natural eyelid primer is your solution. This creamy, lightweight vegan eyelid primer neutralizes darkness, discoloration and other imperfections to create a fresh, bright. Formulated with vitamin E, licorice extract and apple seed extract, it helps to hydrate and brighten, while providing a soft-focus, illuminating base to keep eyeshadow in place throughout the day. The Licorice extract helps to support skin's elasticity, soothe irritation and reduce redness.

Why We Like This:

Neutralizes darkness, discoloration and other imperfections to create a fresh, bright
Vitamin e and apple seed extract help hydrate, repair and protect skin
Helps to hydrate and brighten to illuminate the eye area