The 7 Best Natural Marshmallows (2023 reviews)

We consider a natural marshmallow to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: Jetpuffed Natural Marshmallow READ REVIEW

Best For Krispy Treats: Buy: Happy Belly Natural Marshmallow READ REVIEW

Best For Christmas: Buy: Dandies Natural Marshmallow READ REVIEW

Best For making smores: Buy: campfire Natural Marshmallow READ REVIEW

Best For anyone: Buy: know Brainer Natural Marshmallow READ REVIEW

Best Vegan Marshmallow: Buy: Dandies traditional Marshmallow READ REVIEW

Best For They: Buy: Hammonds candies Natural Marshmallow READ REVIEW

Best overall: Jetpuffed Natural Marshmallow

Buy on Amazon

Jet-puffed marshmallows deliver a sweet taste and fluffy texture when roasting up s'mores. If you want to stick only one marshmallow on and get three toasty marshmallow outsides out of it, these are for you. These are soft and fresh. They take longer to "melt" and never get soft.

These marshmallows are Huge and Delicious. They are the perfect size to play marshmallow dodgeball. It comes with zero trans fat and zero total fat per serving, jet puffed jumbo marshmallows make a fun summer snack for kids or a mouthwatering addition to your favorite camping dessert recipes. These are fresh and you can smell them even before they are opened.

• Perfect for s’mores, hot chocolate, and rice krispy treats
• Delivers what they promise

Best For Krispy Treats: Happy Belly Natural Marshmallow

Buy on Amazon

These marshmallows taste just as good as the name brand marshmallows. It is animal based or the ingredients would call it vegetable gelatin. The marshmallows have a really rich taste, they are soft and they melt in your mouth. The marshmallows are very fresh and fluffy like marshmallows should be.

These marshmallows are great in hot cocoa. It is great for krispy treats, s'mores, and plain snacking. It is packaged in a thin plastic bag which makes them vulnerable to penetration.

• Tasty and all around great for smores
• Marshmallows for making homemade rockyroad candy
• Good investment for long term

Best For Christmas: Dandies Natural Marshmallow

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase marshmallow for their daily usage, but the dandies natural marshmallow would be an anomoly. These are delightful and full of flavor. It is perfect for s'mores, crispy treats or hot chocolate. These are packed in a soft plastic envelop, and the marshmallows are squeezed into a large single block. The texture is also pretty good, a bit softer than the regular marshmallows but not bad at all. The marshmallows are fresh and have just a hint of vanilla flavor to them.

This product is delicious and is used for a recipe because it is just as good as regular malows. They take a little slower to melt, but that’s no problem. They also work great in hot chocolate as a topping if not mashed.

• Simple pure ingredients and much better then your “normal” marshmallow
• Vegan marshmallows are excellent and taste very good
• Perfect if you're vegan or a true vegetarian
• Great vegan replacement for marshmallows that contain gelatin

Best For making smores: campfire Natural Marshmallow

Buy on Amazon

Campfire makes beautiful and great marshmallow with classic and smartly choosen materials. These campfire premium quality giant roaster (extra large) marshmallows are naturally fat-free and gluten-free. They're so big that when you roast them, the middle doesn't get gooey or anything. These are perfect to pair with graham crackers and chocolate for memorable smores. They are made with tapioca starch instead of gelatin and that is what makes them so good. They are great for making smores & roasting by the campfire.

These babies are big and tasty. They are at least twice as heavy as other marshmallows. The middle stays exactly as is prior to roasting, even if you set it on fire. They also keep well for future usage.

• Huge & impressive in presentation with great flavor
• Gluten-free marshmallows the whole family (and dogs) love to have around the campfire
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For anyone: know Brainer Natural Marshmallow

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase marshmallow for their daily purpose, but the know brainer natural marshmallow would be an anomoly. These are nice and fluffy, very satisfying to chew. They melt in hot chocolate (low carb, of course), and are creamy and delicious. They are a suitable substitute for higher calorie marshmallows but the texture is just a bit off. The ones with standard gelatin in them contain a very reasonable 2grams of dietary fiber per serving. The flavor is as if the marshmallow is already toasted and has a good texture, very delicious.

These do have a nice flavor and melts well. They are nice and fluffy, very satisfying to chew.

• Texture is good and each piece is substantial
• Flavor is great, no intestinal issues after eating, texture is great
• Wonderful flavor and texture,and no sugar
• Absolutely delicious, perfect little pillows of pleasure

Best Vegan Marshmallow: Dandies traditional Marshmallow

Buy on Amazon

Dandies has been making great marshmallow for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. To find marshmallows that are safe at all is a blessing but these also taste very good. This is a great vegan marshmallow. It is made with simply, all natural. The flavor is clean tasting vanilla, they melt well for recipes, and they roast into a crispy pillow of goodness. They taste delish and are allergen free. They taste much better than regular marshmallows.

They taste just as good as regular marshmallows, but they don't melt quite as fast. This makes for amazing smores plus it is great for children with allergies.

• Fantastic for vegan rice krispie treats
• The best vegan marshmallow ever made
• New and hot release

Best For They: Hammonds candies Natural Marshmallow

Buy on Amazon

Best part: hammonds candies natural marshmallow costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. These rich, creamy vanilla bean marshmallows are handmade to perfection in small batches. It is proud to handcraft some of the world’s most nostalgic candies with the same careful craftsmanship that mr. Carl t. hammonds, sr. originally created in. They are small, but they're just like a regular marshmallow. It has light and fluffy, great pure vanilla bean flavor, and they melt nicely into hot cocoa.

The marshmallows are incredibly sweet, not surprising, but the bottom of the bag contains a thick layer of congealed ooze. You can tell these are made hand-batched and is a family owned business. It will take as long to roast and will be nice and creamy and melty.

• Perfect snack if you love marshmallows that aren't made with garbage ingredients
• All natural ingredients, down to vanilla bean specks you can see in each marshmallow
• Excellent for hot chocolate but also good on their own