The 6 Best Naturally fresh Tartar sauces (2023 reviews)

If you like a good tartar sauce, you'll be blown away by this incredible concoction. This tartar sauce is extremely similar to McDonald’s tartar sauce. It is crafted with tangy lemon and capers for a delicious flavor. The lemon and capers are an incredibly wonderful addition to this fabulous sauce. It's thicker than the cocktail sauce.

The Gluten free tartar sauce is vegetarian to suit a variety of dietary needs. It comes in a squeeze bottle for easy use and storage.

Why We Like This:

Gourmet seafood dip crafted with tangy lemon and capers for a delicious flavor
Tastes more like dill dip than tartar sauce
, a very rich and tasty version of the sauce
Seafood sauce comes in a squeeze bottle for easy use and storage

Mccormick Naturally fresh Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

The mccormick naturally fresh tartar sauce is capable of outshining several other sauce featured in this list in overall features for the price point. This sauce is creamy, has a very balanced flavor between sweet and tangy. The flavor is great and it's the perfect pairing for fish of all sorts. It comes in a flip top squeezable bottle. The bottle is soft and easy to squeeze. The flavor is tangy and not too sweet. This is absolutely delicious tarter sauce. No matter what you choose, the aroma and taste will always be purely delicious.

Why We Like This:

Adds a nice and creamy tang to fried seafood, making it less greasy
Tastes way better than kraft, which is more like plain mayo tasting
Good investment for long term

Stonewall kitchen Naturally fresh Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

The stonewall kitchen naturally fresh tartar sauce's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. Legal's has relish front and center as the first ingredient, caramelized onions, and ground celery seeds, while Stonewall's has a stronger dill flavor and lemon. It's tangy and sweet, with a classic taste. It has a pleasant acidity and is fine as a lemony glorified mayo, but isn't nearly distinctive enough to qualify as tartar sauce, let alone a good one.

It also doesn't have nearly enough "chunks" of good stuff inside, kind of like chocolate chip ice cream with barely any chips in it. The flavor is complex and hits the bullseye of vinegary tang balanced by pleasing sweetness. It can be used as an aioli of sorts, say as a dipping sauce, or as a sandwich spread.

The sauce is too gentle and overly sweet.

Why We Like This:

Good investment for long term
New and hot release

Captain Toady'S tasty sauces Naturally fresh Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another sauce that manages to win our hearts. It's the captain toady's tasty sauces naturally fresh tartar sauce and it's widely considered as sauce that has the most suitable features. CAPTAIN TOADY'S TASTY Tartar Sauce is made with over 30 Ingredients that will delight your taste buds. It is going into pint size jars. It is made with canola oil, less saturated fat than mayonnaise.

Why We Like This:

Pure gourmet goodness fresh from the great northwest
Love the flavor of the tartar sauce on fish
Blending natural gourmet goodness with refined ingredients to promote longevity & stability

Captd Naturally fresh Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable sauce, captd naturally fresh tartar sauce is your end point. CAPTAIN TOADY'S TASTY PRODUCTS are the freshest and best tasting sauces available. It comes with dill 8 oz (227 g) tasty. Captain toady's tasty tartar sauce is made with over 30 ingredients that will delight your taste buds.

Why We Like This:

Makes the most boring fish sticks a joy to eat
Express yourself, pure gourmet goodness fresh from the great northwest
Blending natural gourmet goodness with refined ingredients to promote longevity & stability
Excellent with burgers and fries, and on your favorite sandwich

market Naturals Naturally fresh Tartar Sauce

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable sauce, market naturals naturally fresh tartar sauce should be your first option for buying. Pike Pier Market natural tartar sauce is made with over 30 ingredients that will delight your taste buds. It is made with canola oil, less saturated fat than mayonnaise. It is great with all types of seafood...mix with tuna for quick tuna salad.

Why We Like This:

Keeps fish moist while baking, and gives it great flavor
Mix with "pike pier cocktail sauce" for a shrimp and crab dip
Pure gourmet goodness fresh from the great northwest
Blending natural gourmet goodness with refined ingredients to promote longevity & stability