The 12 Best non Menthol Throat Lozenges (2023 reviews)

If you are looking for collection of best non menthol throat lozenges, This page is just for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Halls non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best For adult: Buy: Ricola non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best For whole family: Buy: Ludens non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best For post Nasal drip: Buy: Honees non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best For kid: Buy: Grers non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best For severe Cough: Buy: Vicks non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best For clearing nose: Buy: Modhui non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best For strep: Buy: Manuka South non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best With Benzocaine: Buy: Smith Brothers non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best With elderberry: Buy: Zarbees non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best For irritated Throat: Buy: vocal Eze non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best With Echinacea: Buy: Laki Naturals non Menthol Throat Lozenge READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Halls non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about good lozenge, halls non menthol throat lozenge should be your first option for buying. There aren't too many brands of pectin drops but these are the strongest, and the best tasting. If you have an issue with your stomach accepting menthol (aka mint), these pectin drops are for you. They taste great and work well for dry throat. They help with the sore throat at the beginning of a cold, and the cough tickle at the end.

This brand is good for dry throats. It comes with a variety of flavors, pack types and sub-brands, and helps you get back to the things that matter most in your life. These drops are perfect and very good flavor. These are perfect for a dry mouth or throat.

• Taste great and help sore throat pain
• Awesome relief for sore throat without the terrible taste of menthol throat drops
• Works great for a scratchy throat
• Great if not looking for the menthol/ medicinal taste

Best For adult: Ricola non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate lozenge. The ricola non menthol throat lozenge is exactly that - it's a simple lozenge that hits all the right notes. It is perfect for a pesky cough. It saves a lot of money rather than purchase small individual bags. It has a lot of lemon flavor counterbalanced with a hint of mint. The drops are larger than some and last a long time in your mouth. It stops a cough quickly.

The coughs from dry rooms won't stop either. The size matters and it is great with no sugar.

• Great product for people who has itchy throat
• Works well without the guilt of a child's candy
• Tastes great but has carbs and calories even though sugar free

Best For whole family: Ludens non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention ludens non menthol throat lozenge for regular usage. These honey lemon drops are an excellent cough drop to keep moisture in the mouth without the menthol that is in so many others. They are good as cough drops. Flavor is wonderful and they work for dry mouth quickly. It is great for the whole family, including kids 3 and up. These are hard candies and taste very good. They are good as a cough drops.

This is a GREAT little candy especially if you have heartburn or acidosis as it removes it.

• Soothing if you have a cough and very pleasant taste
• Great cough drop/throat soother without the sugar
• Delicious & soothing,excellent for a dry throat

Best For post Nasal drip: Honees non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

The features department is where honees non menthol throat lozenge truly manages to shine. It is a great throat lozenge to ward off a nagging cough. These are amazing cough drops, a great deal and works amazingly to open up airways for upper respiratory flu, or sickness. It helps alots, stopping cough, soothing throat and aid in helping to breath better. The natural flavors allow you to enjoy the taste while experiencing relief at any time. They also come packaged in bags of 20 pieces or bars of 9 pieces so you can always have one available within reach.

It comes with 7.5 mg of menthol and they provide immediate relief for a sore/dry throat. It's just very soft and melts gently in your mouth. The drops are delicious and the eucalyptus soothing on the throat.

• Great relief for sinuses, sore throat and coughing
• Sore throat, cough and nasal congestion
• Absolutely the best cough/throat drop ever

Best For kid: Grers non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

The grers non menthol throat lozenge is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. This almost one pound tin contains a tiny tin to fill and put in your purse or pocket. It's the same exact design as the regular tin except big as a brick. They last a long time in one's mouth and are soothing. They are extremely soothing and aid with dry throat, allergies, etc. They are the best product for a raspy throat.

It's great sweet to have on hand to relieve strained voices or vocal cords due to dry mouth and hoarseness and offers relief for a sore throat from cough. Plus, it comes with a mini travel tin inside so you can keep a few in your bag and refill it as they run out. Exactly the right degree of soft gumminess, they have a unique taste that is totally addictive.

• Great product for throat tickles and coughs
• Good brand reputation

Best For severe Cough: Vicks non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another lozenge that manages to win our hearts. It's the vicks non menthol throat lozenge and it's widely considered as lozenge that has the most suitable features. The Vicks Vapors are strong and fast relief. They are great for sore throats and nasal congestion. They are very strong cough drops and provide an excellent menthol soothing to your throat and sinuses. The menthol in them help to soothe a sore throat right away.

These drops really help with the allergy issues of stuffy sinuses and sore throat. It comes with 2x more menthol per drop and a powerful rush of vicks vapors, vapocool provides fast sore throat relief you can feel. These drops work fast to soothe your nasal passages.

• Vapors are strong enough to breathe through your nose
• Cools soothes stop cough opens up nasal passages
• Product relieves cough and stuffy nose

Best For clearing nose: Modhui non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

Modhui makes beautiful and great lozenge with classic and smartly choosen materials. These lozenges are great for sore throats or dryness in the mouth. Not only does it relieve cough instantaneously, it actually tastes great sugar free. They are sugar free. It is great for dry throat issues.

• Sugar and no acids listed among the active and inactive ingredients
• Works the same as big name brand drops of menthol for cough and congestion
• Great taste and very effective at soothing throat and controlling coughs
• Very effective in soothing throats with various ailments

Best For strep: Manuka South non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

The manuka south non menthol throat lozenge should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. The healing powers of manuka honey is magical. It’s a perfect blend of manuka honey, lemon, and echinacea that taste both soothing and zesty. They dissolve in a smooth fashion and they have a pleasant, mild honey taste. It comes with added natural lemon flavor, echinacea, eucalyptus oil & menthol crystals. The sealed plastic is air tight and therefore, the lozenges will stay fresh longer.

They are tasty enough to enjoy, even when you don't have a cough or sore throat, and given the small supplement boost, they are worth eating whether you're ill or not. These are individually wrapped, which makes them convenient to take along.

• Each re-sealable pouch contains approximately 25 lozenges
• Perfect to smooth a dry throat
• Eased discomfort, quieted cough, and possibly helped speed up recovery
• Excellent product to tame a bad sore throat

Best With Benzocaine: Smith Brothers non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

The smith brothers non menthol throat lozenge is capable of outshining several other lozenge featured in this list in overall features for the price point. These lozenges taste like a warm apple pie and help smooth a dry or sore throat. They’re warming and they taste amazing. The warming feature feels nice when your throat is raw. For those who do not want the wrapper to make noise in a quiet setting, this cough drop wrap is soft wrapped.

These are super powerful to help your throat. It is good for soothing a dry, mildly sore throat. These are so good and effective with no aritficial color. The warm apple pie flavor is very different and it’s delicious.

• Best flavor (not too sweet) and throat coating of all lozenges
• Great natural and tasty lozenge to help with the worst croupy throats and coughs
• Excellent flavor and very effective cough drop
• Not too strong a flavor, just a hint of apple and cinnamon

Best With elderberry: Zarbees non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other lozenge in this category, the zarbees non menthol throat lozenge has a convenient design. Zarbee's Naturals Cough Syrup* + Mucus, Natural Honey Lemon Flavor is a good product. It is made with honey for a simple, natural way to soothe throats and calm coughs. It includes vitamin c, zinc and elderberry all of which help fight a cough and discomfort that comes with constant coughing. It has a pleasant mild herbal flavor that goes down well. It is a great natural replacement for roitussin or mucinex type syrups.

It is a bit costly, natural health vs cost.

• Wonderful cough drops, love having them and prefer to other choices
• Really helps sore throat and coughing
• Good brand reputation

Best For irritated Throat: vocal Eze non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

The vocal eze non menthol throat lozenge's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. It is great for tired voice after singing and talking. Unlike the average lozenge, these just taste good and are not overpowering. It is made with manuka honey which has unparalleled quality and healing properties. It is recognized for having flavonoids, which may help the body. The lemon flavor has the most robust menthol sensation, followed by the strawberry. It can be used as a substitute for a varied diet and healthy lifestyle.

The vocal eze spray is much more effective as an aid to vocal performance. They do help a scratchy throat.

• Coats the throat nicely without being too viscous
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best With Echinacea: Laki Naturals non Menthol Throat Lozenge

Buy on Amazon

These dry throat lozenges can help you concentrate on a self-soothing act that reduces stress, increases alertness and boosts your focus. It helps ease the stress of having a throat tickle and soothe your mind and mood with laki’s cough calming lozenges. They are maybe a little more than an Inch across with a unique salty-sweet flavor. The texture is almost a bit creamy, although they are definitely a lozenge.

These are nice large rectangular candieslozenges so each one lasts a while. The flavor is very weak, sort of like a tease. It is great for dry mouth. It is made without menthol and these sweet and salty throat lozenges provide long lasting, instant calming for everyday throat irritation.

• Filled with herbs and botanicals and sugar free
• Each one has its own delicious, soothing flavor
• A lozenge that works and tastes great