The 5 Best Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies (2023 reviews)

Best Runner up:

Best Premium:

Best FLAVOR:

Best for freshness:

Best overall: Nutterbutter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cooky

Nutter Butter makes beautiful and feature-packed cooky with classic and higher-grade materials. Nutter butter peanut butter sandwich cookies satisfy the peanut butter lovers in your family with a snack that's ready to enjoy. It is made with real peanut butter, these cookie snacks have a crunchy texture and a smooth, creamy filling between two crispy cookies for a sweet and savory snack. They are great to give as treats for Halloween.

These cookies are good and fresh. They are ideal for portion control. They come in 1.9 ounce snack packs that contain four nutter butter cookies each, making them ideal for lunches, road trips or on-the-go snacking. The crackers are fresh and flakey and the peanut butter is just right. It is great if you only eat a couple of cookies every few weeks.

Why We Like This:

A great addition to get your subscribe and save up to 5 items
Highly recommended to those who love peanut butter
Keeps the package from going stale
Each package is large enough to split between two people

Best Runner up: Nutterbutter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cooky

The look and feel of this cookies are consistent with the high quality we're used to from the rest of Nutter Butter's lineup. Add these Nutter Butter cookies to lunches or take these peanut butter snacks on road trips or take these peanut butter snacks on road trips. It is great for on the go snacks. It is made with real peanut butter, these cookies have a crunchy texture and a smooth, creamy filling between two crispy cookies for savory and sweet snacks. They travel well and are just right for a quick sugar taste.

Sealed packaging keeps each pack in these bulk cookies fresh until you're ready to enjoy. They taste a little different than the full size (assuming the filling to cookie ratio is a little off) but definitely a sweet investment.

Why We Like This:

Good brand reputation
Delivers what they promise

Best Premium: Nutterbutter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cooky

If you often find yourself scrambling for an exceptional cooky, this product should be your first option for buying. Make dessert time even sweeter with these round fudge covered peanut butter cookies. Whether it’s dressed in fudge or going au naturel, Nutter Butter is the peanut butter–lovers’ cookie. Prepare for movie nights, small parties, study sessions, and work breaks with these cookies. It also stashes neatly in your kitchen pantry, office desk, or snack food shelf.

The conveniently sized box makes sharing this treat simple. It will be shipped in an insulated bag with cool packs during the summer months.

Why We Like This:

Sweet yet savory kosher nutter butter cookies are always made with real peanut butter
Good brand reputation

Best FLAVOR: Nutterbutter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cooky

If you are searching to buy a popular cooky for your daily usage, this product is the natural option.

Why We Like This:

Peanut-shaped sandwich cookies are fun to eat
Crunchy cookies with smooth, creamy filling for a mix of textures
Add to lunches, enjoy as snacks or take on road trips

Best for freshness: Nutterbutter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cooky