There are plenty of options available while buying old penny loafers in the market right now, and if you're confused regarding which one to go for, This page is just for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Sperry Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best For Wedding: Buy: Clarks Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best For Wide Width: Buy: Dockers Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best For Good Quality Shoe: Buy: Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best For Medium Width: Buy: Nunn Bush Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best For Leather Soles: Buy: Cole Haan Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best For Size Chart: Buy: Florsheim Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best For Stylish Shoe: Buy: Deer Stags Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best For Soft Leather: Buy: Ecco Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best With A Suit: Buy: Mephisto Old Penny Loafer READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Sperry Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other loafers in this category, the sincerely old penny loafer has a design with broader appeal. In addition, the sincerely old penny loafer provides added stability and comfort along with a molded cup heel. Genuine hand-sewn burnished leather uppers with true moccasin construction and rawhide laces. Moreover, the loafer comes out with great shoe, it has slip on shoes and has a traditional style. Lastly, the sincerely old penny loafer looks amazing in cream color and is available in 35 other colors: glove navy, blue, navy red 000, blue, navy red 000 etc.,.

Most buyers opine that the loafer is fortunate to find this enhanced version of the classic boat shoe. In addition, they say that the loafer is made from a different sort of leather that does not handle water well. Overall, many buyers have used the sincerely old penny loafer for more than a few months without letup, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• It feels great, is highly recommend, it is very soft and has a classic design.
• This is how a lot of people refer to the very basic topsider boat shoe.
• Luxury lambskin lining surrounds the foot for softness.
• These are upon first slipping them on.

Best For Wedding: Clarks Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other loafers in this category, the Clarks Old Penny Loafer has a convenient design. And, the clarks old penny loafer has been in business for over 100 years, making very fine men's dress shoes in a variety of styles. The cotrell free by Clarks collection is a durable men's loafer that will quickly become a go-to. And, the loafer is very good. It fits well. It is best for comfort shoes and is good for style. Lastly, the clarks old penny loafer is available in black smooth leather, brown tobacco leather, tobacco leather etc., so, we bet you will like one of these.

One customer says - "They are dressed enough to wear to work and comfortable enough for long periods of walking. ". Almost all customers opine that the loafer fits exactly true to size and is very comfortable.

• This has heel height and has a rubber sole style.
• Shaft measures approximately not_applicable from arch.
• This can be bought for good value, It has slip on shoes and has a comfortable style.
• This is great with brown leather and has style.

Best For Wide Width: Dockers Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

The dockers ' old penny loafer's superior materials make sure that it ages well with use. In addition, the dockers ' old penny loafer is outer and it is with a soft sole. Easy slip on and off the foot loafer construction. Also, it is uncomfortable and it is really nice. Most importantly, the dockers ' old penny loafer is available in 2 colors: tan and black.

Most buyers agree that the loafer has withstood moisture well and the sole remains intact, and showing normal wear.

• This is really comfortable, would be perfect with exceptional comfort and it has a rubber outsole.
• This leather is good and it can pass for nice shoes.
• Cushioned latex feet for exceptional comfort.

Best For Good Quality Shoe: Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other loafers in this category, the Old Penny Loafer has a convenient design. Moreover, the old penny loafer is secure, is good for nice shoe, it is great for good shoes and has a versatile style. You will love the leather upper with penny loafer strap detail. Moreover, the loafer is a little large, it is very snug and has a casual style. Lastly, the old penny loafer is available in black brush off, tan, black/new brown etc.,.

Almost all buyers opine that the loafer is a smokin'-good price, and Rockport is a well known and trusted brand. Furthermore, a few also found that the loafer is great with or without socks. In addition, they strongly agree that this loafer fits very comfortably and is perfect for a casual or even more formal ( suit, blazer ) look. In conclusion, at the price, they believe that they got a steal of a deal with it.

• These fit pretty well, and fit perfectly out of the box.
• This is the perfect fit and shoe for those long business casual days on your feet.
• This looks great but not very comfortable. order 1/2 bigger.
• This looks good with khakis or more formal business wear.

Best For Medium Width: Nunn Bush Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

Nunn Bush line of loafers comes in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. The Nunn bush old penny loafer works with premium leather, is good for fast delivery, It is perfect for dress pants and has a comfortable style. . Also, it feels great, It is available in medium width and has great style.

The loafer you can get for a reasonable price, is made with synthetic sole, It is perfect for wide widths and has shoe style. Further, it is highly regarded as a premier footwear brand, providing the best value and style in fine men's footwear since 1912. Lastly, the Nunn bush old pennyloafer is available in medium, It comes out with great shoes and has good style.

Most customers quickly discovered that the loafer fit great from day 1. Moreover, a few say that the loafer is what you want, go for the leather sole. To sum up, for almost all customers, Nunn Bush product was just what they wanted.

• Outsole: non-leather, long wearing man-made outsole.
• This can also be worn sockless.
• This provides outstanding comfort right of the box.
• Perfect fit: available in medium width and wide width for the perfect fit.

Best For Leather Soles: Cole Haan Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about the appropriate and satisfactory loafer, Cole Haan oldpenny loafer is your end point. The Cole haan old penny loafer is great for stylish shoes, is highly recommend, it fits great and has a versatile design. Moccasin-toe penny loafer with stacked heel. And, the loafer comes with fit right, it looks good, it looks stylish and has a nice style. look look look look.

The loafer can resize for a nice fit, it goes out and has a durable design. Most importantly, the Cole Haan old penny loafer works for very nice shoes, It makes excellent shoes and has fit style.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the loafer was a perfect fit for the word "go. In addition, they say that the loafer can never go wrong with a great pair of black shoes. Also, a few strongly agree that the loafer is like a reenactment of Cinderella. In short, at the price, they believe that they got a steal of a deal with it.

• This would be perfect with stocking and a tad large without.
• This is used for casual events, it no matter and has a classic design.
• This is another good quality shoe.
• They fit great, Cole haan shoes are great looking and comfortable.

Best For Size Chart: Florsheim Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

The Florsheim old penny loafer is the most reliable loafer on the market today. The Florsheim old penny loafer is exceptionally comfortable, It is available in medium widths and has a new style. . This slip - on is a fashion warrior that always looks great and is never out of place.

The loafer has a great finish, a leather outsole lends refinement, and a rubber-enforced heel adds durability and tames heel strikes for greater comfort. Most importantly, the Florsheim old pennyloafer can be gotten for a reasonable price, It looks good and has a perfect design.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the loafer is great to get an old friend back with the comfort and timeless design. In addition, a few also found that the loafer looks like the option to choose for a medium width shoe. To sum up, for almost all customers, the loafer was what they were looking for.

• Classic style: beef-roll penny loafer, crafted with genuine handsewn moccasin construction.
• This is available in medium, It is great for narrow width and has a classic style.
• Care: easy to clean, just wipe down with a soft, damp cloth.
• Comfort: the shoe is unlined, and the insole is fully cushioned and non-removable.

Best For Stylish Shoe: Deer Stags Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

The Deer Stags Old Penny Loafer's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The deer stags oldpenny loafer is comfy, It is quite comfortable and has a sole design. Technology and slip-lasted construction, deer stags have become a leader in comfort footwear for men, women, and children. Also, this measures approximately 1.06 and also has been making shoes comfortable since 1929.

The loafer is great for business meetings, or an evening on the town. Also, the loafer is really comfortable, is suitable for new shoes, it is too loose and has a versatile style. Most importantly, the deer stags old penny loafer can be adjusted for a comfortable fit, is good for the price, It looks very nice and has a nice style. look look look look.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the loafer is easy to add in inserts for support. Also, they say that the loafer does not pinch or bunch up your toes. Further, they say that the loafer fits extremely well, plus it will last nearly that long. With no doubts, this loafer passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This is superior to many shoes at double the price.
• Breathable woven uppers help keep your feet cool and dry.
• They look okay and they fit nicely for the price.

Best For Soft Leather: Ecco Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

If you are searching for a popular loafer for your regular use, you cannot go wrong with the old old penny loafer. The old old penny loafer is enhanced by the soft smooth detailing. Manufacturer says: Crafted from soft leather, made in our own tanneries. This slip on penny loafer styled sneaker is smart and stylish.

Above all, the old old penny loafer allows for nice looking shoes and has great style.

Most buyers opine that the loafer looks very nice, and they appear to take hard wearing it well.

• The textile lining offers softness and breathability.
• The lightweight sole provides cushioning and flexibility, using innovative ecco fluidform direct comfort technology.
• Penny loafer details mixed with sneaker style.
• The removable, textile-covered insole offers added comfort and customizable fit.

Best With A Suit: Mephisto Old Penny Loafer

Buy on Amazon

The Mephisto Old Penny Loafer is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily use. In addition, the mephisto old penny loafer is best for quality construction, It is for protection for your feet and has a comfort design. The soft-air midsole is flexible and soft, reduces the shock from walking, protecting your feet, joints and vertebrae. Further, it is tough, it makes for a great casual shoe and has a rubber sole design. Lastly, the mephisto old penny loafer is available in 2 vibrant colors: rust and black.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the loafer was perfect or required a very minor adjustment through the use of heel lifts to prevent ankle rub. Moreover, they also found that the loafer takes the germans to germanize the penny loafer.

• This looks great, it comes with great customer service and has a traditional style.
• Delivers what they promise.