The 9 Best Organic Apple Butter (2023 reviews)

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate butter. The tj's organic apple butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. This Pumpkin Butter is delicious. It is great for holiday baking. It is not as sweet as nutella, but it is definitely dessert. Its jam-like quality makes it easy and quick to spread on whatever you choose, and its pumpkin/cinnamon sweetness makes a wonderful fall flavor. It is perfect for the occasional sweet tooth fix.

This is spicier and much sweeter than pumpkin pie. The recipe came out amazing and the dessert was a huge success at thanksgiving dinner.

Why We Like This:

Delicious with puff pastry and brie
Yummy,great on crackers, toast and a spoonful
Delivers what they promise

Best with bagels: Mccutcheons Organic Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another butter that manages to win our hearts. It's the mccutcheons organic apple butter and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient butter you can buy. If you like sweet & mild yet flavorful apple butter, this is it. This apple butter tastes fresh and you can tell there aren't a bunch of additives. It can be used as a gift for apple lovers, teachers, hostesses, or any time you need a gift for the holiday's, and of course for yourself. This is by far the most scrumptious apple butter out there. It is made from a time-tested family recipe, it's slow cooked in small batches for a rich, mellow flavor that's lightly spiced with a hint of sweetness. This is a perfect replacement to making it with family.

Why We Like This:

Perfect balance of apple and sweetness
Great taste and smooth the way apple butter should be
Not too sweet and just the right amount of spice
Not to thick, not runny, and good taste, and natural

Best For ages: Amish Valley products Organic Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate butter. The amish valley products organic apple butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. If you're an apple butter lover, this one will not disappoint. It’s tasty apple butter. It is made in ohio's amish country 16 oz glass jar. This has that fresh apple taste and it has no added sugar. It is perfectly flavored with spices. It is perfect for the apple butter-lover in the family. This is so good on a biscuit.

Why We Like This:

Great and best apple butter ever
Great basic recipe without sugar added
Sweetened with apple juice, wonder taste and consistency
Very good product for the holiday seasons as well

Best with anything: Redhawk Farms Organic Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The redhawk farms organic apple butter is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. This Redhawk farms apple butter is absolutely delicious, and is perfectly balanced, between spices and sweetness. It comes with its rich flavor profile, which is a perfect compliment to both sweet & savory foods. The ingredient list gives a bunch of sweeteners separately, "sugar" and "brown sugar" as well as apple juice concentrate, a slightly deceptive practice. The spice mix is delicate and wonderful.

The apple butter is sweet and delicious with no artificial flavors or preservatives. It is used to preserve foods. The apple and brown sugar come through well. It's just 35 calories per tablespoon.

Why We Like This:

Really good balance of flavor and thickness
Meets all expectations for taste and texture
Flavor is really balanced, not too sweet, no ingredient/spice overpowers

Best For spreading on breads: Jake & Amos Organic Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Jake & Amos makes beautiful and great butter with classic and smartly choosen materials. Bold apple flavor blends perfectly with warm spices and just the right amount of sweetness, resulting in rich color and fabulous texture and flavor. It is great for spreading on breads, rolls, muffins, toast, pancakes, adding to cottage cheese or as a dessert ingredient.

Why We Like This:

Good investment for long term
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best premium: Eden foods Organic Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a premium butter. The eden foods organic apple butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. This is the best Apple butter ever. It is used to make applebutter and cook it outside all day and boil cider and add apples it is so good. It's such a healthy snack just alone off the spoon or you can put it on toast, waffles, bagels and graham crackers and you can even bake with it. It is good as flavoring in yogurt or on today or a pb&j sandwich.

This is delicious apple butter, with no added sugar or artificial sweeteners. These are organic and taste pretty good. It is very low sugar, low calorie, simple ingredients, and very tasty. It is a great lean option.

Why We Like This:

Best sugar free spice free applebutter
Sugar added and spiced very well
Spices just appple and cider no added sugar

Best value For money: Manischewitz Organic Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Manischewitz is known for creating pragmatic and a right on the money butter for people on the go, and its line of manischewitz organic apple butter definitely falls in line with that reputation. This delicious apple butter has endless options, dip your biscuits in, spread thickly on your toast, top your cakes or even add to your favorite sauces and glaze for a homemade, sweet flavor that will leave you asking for more. It tastes like a luscious, natural, thick applesauce just like it should. It is made with just two simple ingredients, cooked long and slow to produce a delicious, rich, dark brown sauce.

This apple butter does not have added sugar or the heavy cinnamon / clove taste. It is easy to spread, not too thin, not too thick. It is made with two simple ingredients, naturally sweet, no sugar added, and no artificial flavor or colors added, making healthier eating a sweet pleasure.

Why We Like This:

Add to your favorite sauces and glazes for a deliciously sweet flavor
Good investment for long term

Best Feature: easy to Spread: Mrs. Miller'S Organic Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The mrs. miller's organic apple butter is capable of outshining several other butter featured in this list in overall features in its price range.

Why We Like This:

Not too sweet and just the right amount of cinnamon
Good brand reputation