It is important to have the well suited paint tray insert. In the following post, we will help you to select the best paint tray inserts.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Wooster Paint Tray Insert READ REVIEW

Best For Pros: Buy: Handy Paint Products Paint Tray Insert READ REVIEW

Best For Many Projects: Buy: Ecty Paint Tray Insert READ REVIEW

Best For Disposable Paint Tray: Buy: Bates Choice Paint Tray Insert READ REVIEW

Best For One Time Use: Buy: Cascade Tools Paint Tray Insert READ REVIEW

Best Maneuverability: Buy: Unvert Paint Tray Insert READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Wooster Paint Tray Insert

Buy on Amazon

Here, we review an insert that manages to win our hearts. It's the Wooster Paint Tray Insert and it's widely considered as one of the best inserts you can buy. The wooster paint tray insert is very durable and it works great. You can feel confident knowing wooster is the name behind your tools. And, the insert is very sturdy, is reuseable and it provides great value.

Above all, the wooster paint tray insert is made of rust-resistant steel.

Most customers found that the insert is half the price of corporate building store chains and this held up for a painting job and will probably never fail. Further, they also found that the insert is a metal pan, cheaper than the box stores.

• Use a form-fitting liner (r406, br496, or br407) for instant cleanup.
• This will hold up for a project or two.
• It is easy to load the paint on to the roller.
• 16 1/2 inch l x 11 inch w x 2 1/2 inch d.

Best For Pros: Handy Paint Products Paint Tray Insert

Buy on Amazon

The Handy Paint Products Paint Tray Insert's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The handy paint products paint tray insert is perfect for heavy duty plastic and it is very simple. The handy paint pail was created in 2001 in the classic do-it-yourself style. The handy paint product line has expanded to include the handy paint tray, handy paint cup, handy roller cup, handy pro pail, handy ladder pail and the new and innovative handy paint grid.

Lastly, the handy paint products paint tray insert is solvent resistant to work with any paint or stain on the market.

Almost all customers agree that the insert is great for using this tray. Also, a few also found that the insert is easy to carry and doesn't tip over. In addition, a few strongly agree that the insert cleans up well enough, plus it is an amazing painting. Obviously, this product passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This provides more room to roll the roller.
• This has handles on each side, which makes it easy to move.
• This is great with the 9 inch disposable plastic inserts.
• This definitely solves that problem and can be used on every paint tray.

Best For Many Projects: Ecty Paint Tray Insert

Buy on Amazon

The Ecty Paint Tray Insert's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The ecty paint tray insert fits with linzer of 400 and 403 trays. 1-quart plastic tray liner protects your original paint tray. And, this is great for many projects.

The insert is durable and it is easy to use. Above all, the ecty paint trayinsert comes in a zip - lock bag for multiple uses and easy storage.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the insert made clean-up a whole lot easier. In addition, they say that the insert fits the standard trays at walmart. Also, a few also found that these pan liners are an excellent choice.

• This is usable but slid around in the pan.
• This makes painting very easy.
• This is built for heavy duty and it comes with great liners.
• It comes in a zip - lock bag for multiple uses and easy storage.

Best For Disposable Paint Tray: Bates Choice Paint Tray Insert

Buy on Amazon

The Bates Choice Paint Tray Insert gives the top-tier insert a run for their money by offering flagship specs at a much more affordable price. In addition, the insert is very sturdy and it comes with great liners. It is made of plastic, eye-catching color makes it a stylish addition to your collection. Lastly, the bates choice paint tray insert provides great value, It is easy to clean and has a sturdy design.

Most customers agree that the insert fits the hard plastic tray perfectly and holds up well to the roller pressing down on the bumpy surface. Also, they strongly agree that the insert fits the 9in tray perfectly and also it is used to wash paint trays after painting. And, they strongly agree that the paint tray liner is meant to be disposable for quick clean up. Overall, buyers found this to be one of the best products for daily purposes.

• Bates painttray liners, 9 inch, pack of 10.
• It’s what it’s supposed to be, a disposable paint tray liner.
• New and hot releases.

Best For One Time Use: Cascade Tools Paint Tray Insert

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate insert. The Cascade Tools Paint Tray Insert is exactly that - it's a simple insert that hits all the right notes. The cascade tools paint tray insert allows for easy clean-up and it would be perfect with excellent quality. If any of you have ever tried to carry around a full paint tray in one of those cheap flimsy paint liners, you know how risky it is. And, the insert is designed to fit most 9” paint rollers.

Lastly, the cascade tools paint trayinsert is great for heavy duty plastic, is really inexpensive, It matches the hard shell plastic tray and has a sturdy design.

Almost all customers opine that the insert is easy to remove when done. And, they say that the insert is good for one - time use. In addition, a few also found that the insert is great for painting multiple rooms.

• Simply line your painttray with the included disposable paint liner.
• This is a great way to extend paint tray life.
• One of the newcomers and featured product.

Best Maneuverability: Unvert Paint Tray Insert

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another insert that manages to win our hearts. It's the Unvert Paint Tray Insert and it's widely considered as the insert that has the most suitable features. The unvert paint tray insert is easy to swap out different colors going room-to-room or wall-to-wall to save time. The Manufacturer says: Our plastic tray liner will save you time and money by eliminating the messy paint tray cleanup needs and getting the job done quicker by easily switching between paint colors. This form - fitting plastic paint tray liner makes the cleanup much easier after completing the paint.

The insert can be used with all paints, stains, and finishes. Moreover, it is perfectly fit, is made for good value and it is easy to clean. Most importantly, the unvert paint tray insert is very sturdy and it provides great value.

One customer says - "Handles jobs where you will be switching paint types/colors. ". Most customers quickly discovered that the insert is sturdy and the added liners make cleanup perfect and easy.

• This lets it dry and it is durable.
• This is how these tray liners help to extend the life of the paint tray.
• Just pour off the excess paint and wipe the liner with a paint brush.
• This is excellent for home touch-ups, is white and it is made of white.