We consider a paper baking tray to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you pick the best one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Nordic Ware Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Even Heat Distribution: Buy: Checkered Chef Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Fruit Cobblers: Buy: Bastwe Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Large Size: Buy: Nutrichef Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Customer Support: Buy: Kitchenatics Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Making Petit: Buy: Wildone Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Deep Rim: Buy: Pp Chef Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Rounded Corners: Buy: Teamfar Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Heavy Duty Carbon Steel: Buy: Joho Baking Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best For Heat Distribution: Buy: Silpat Paper Baking Tray READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Nordic Ware Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

The look and feel of these trays are consistent with the high quality we're used to from the rest of Nordic Ware's lineup. The Nordic Ware Paper Baking Tray is reactive to acidic ingredients such as vinegar and tomato products. From cookies to sheet pan dinners, this is the pan you’ll reach for. These foods may darken, pit or corrode the pan after prolonged use.

The tray is made of a special hardened aluminum alloy that provides superbly uniform heat conductivity and maximizes scratch resistance. Finally, the nordic ware paper baking tray is compatible with parchment paper or silicone baking mats if desired.

Most customers found that the tray is easy to hold when wearing an oven mitt. Moreover, they say that the tray is not your cheap, dime store pan. Further, a few strongly agree that the high - sided sheet cake pan will hold 32 cups. To sum up, for almost all customers, it was the most suitable.

• This provides natural nonstick performance.
• It is heavy enough to keep flat, but not real heavy.
• This cleans well, nice high lip for spring cake roll.
• This has a pit metal and it is used for chicken nuggets.

Best For Even Heat Distribution: Checkered Chef Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another tray that manages to win our hearts. It's the Checkered Chef Paper Baking Tray and it's widely considered as one of the most convenient trays you can buy. The checkered chef paper baking tray is great for baking cookies, it cooks evenly and has an excellent design. Use this cookie sheet and pan rack for healthier, drip-free meals. This stainless steel sheet pan rack is designed for every situation.

The tray is great for baking, it is easy to like and has a baking mat design. Most importantly, the checkered chef paper baking tray comes with two 45.7 x 33 cm (18 x 13 in) pans and two 43.2 x 30.5 cm (17 x 12 in) racks, This oven rack set will fit in most standard ovens and cookware sheets.

Almost all customers found that the tray allows things to cook and crisp on all sides. Moreover, they strongly agree that the tray is perfect for "air fried" wings. In addition, a few also found that the tray is indeed aluminum instead of something cheaper like "aluminized steel.

• This is more convenient, it is good for country of origin and has a durable design.
• Use it to bake, cook, cool, roast, or grill all of your favorite items.
• This is made of stainless steel, but it's not.
• This is used to pan and cooling rack to back turkey meatballs.

Best For Fruit Cobblers: Bastwe Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

The Bastwe Paper Baking Tray has killer features for the price point. The bastwe paper baking tray can be found for good value, Go ahead, it makes cookies and has a product design. Please clean and dry the baking pan after using it for its durability. The preferred choice by professional family bakeware around the world for its durability quality, extra strength and high - performance capabilities.

The tray is good for country of origin, it has good lip height and has a stackable design. Most importantly, the bastwe paper baking tray works great, It is best for preparing food and has a small design.

Most buyers agree that the tray works well for baking needs. Moreover, they also found that the tray is made of stainless steel and very easy to clean. In addition, a few strongly agree that the simplest advice would be to try lining any pan you use with parchment paper ( bottom and sides ) and coat with olive oil before pressing the dough in the pan. Obviously, this tray passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This has no problems at all stepping over the lip of these marvelous little pans.
• size cookie pans are easy for you to clean by hand or dishwasher.
• This is stainless steel in good quality.
• This is suitable for showing off & enjoying this.

Best For Large Size: Nutrichef Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing but a tray that is reliable, this Nutrichef Paper Baking Tray is certainly a worthy investment. In addition, the nutrichef paper baking tray is impressive, makes for a great buy, It makes for great cookie sheets and has a rimmed border design. The set includes 1 large baking sheet (lxwxh) 15.7" x 11.0" x 1.3" and 1 baking sheet medium size (lxwxh) 13.4" x 9.6" x 1.3" so you can make bulk batches of oven-baked cookies. The bakeware ’s durable nonstick coating helps ensure quick, effortless food release — no need for excess butter, oil, or cooking spray. Above all, the nutrichef paper baking tray looks amazing in black color and is available in 3 other colors: blue diamond, gold and rose gold.

Almost all customers opine that the tray is used for cookies mostly... so great for that. Further, they strongly agree that the tray is easy to clean, soft cloth will clean any mess. To sum up, buyers found this to be one of the best tray for daily purposes.

• This comes with a great rack.
• This can be used in a convection microwave.
• This looks much nicer and is also good as air frying.
• This provides durability & fast, even heat distribution for uniform browning, oven-safe up to 445°f.

Best For Customer Support: Kitchenatics Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate tray. The Kitchenatics Paper Baking Tray is exactly that - it's a simple tray that hits all the right notes. The kitchenatics paper baking tray is good for lifetime warranty and has a product design. The manufacturer says: Re-invent dinnertime with your family by cooking them a meal using our aluminum oven pan and stainless steel cooling rack. In addition, the tray throw away, is great for crispy chicken and has a safe design.

The tray is great for customer support, it has fried chicken and has a durable design. In addition, the tray is highly recommend, Pay attention, it is made for large capacity and has a unique design. Most importantly, the kitchenatics paper baking tray is great for bacon, It looks great and has a great design.

Almost all buyers agree that the tray cleans up well every time. And, they strongly agree that the tray is an example of an oven baked bakon. Further, they strongly agree that the measurements are the inside bottom of the pan. The rack fits perfectly and is almost exactly 12 x 17, as the pan sides are beveled out.

• This is spend less, buy again, it is extra large and has a small design.
• Pans should be washed by hand & not in the dishwasher to avoid discoloration.
• The aluminum baking oven pan is hand washed only.
• Or, bake items directly in the pan.

Best For Making Petit: Wildone Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about the appropriate and satisfactory tray, one paperbaking tray is your solution. The Wildone Paper Baking Tray comes with great pans and it is very thin. Dishwasher safe to free your hands and save you time. And, this is made with good value and it is perfect for meat.

The tray is highly recommend, it looks nice and it is quite sturdy. In addition, it is ideal for use in baking shop, buffet,ss birthday parties, food festival,sss family gatherings or other occasions. Finally, the wildone paper bakingtray is great for a great price and it is really attractive.

Almost all customers opine that the tray is great for making petit fours too. Further, they strongly agree that the tray is easy to use, cook with and clean up afterwards. In short, many buyers have used the tray for more than a few months without letup, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This is perfect even for the best cookies and treats.
• No more aluminum in your food, great replacement for aluminum pans.
• This is best for great baking sheets and it is made with high sides.
• These fit well with the rest of the pans.

Best For Deep Rim: Pp Chef Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase a tray for their regular usage, but the Pp Chef Paper Baking Tray would be an anomoly. The pp chef paper baking tray is very durable, looks great and it makes cookies. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. These baking sheets are suitable for baking meat, fish, vegetables, cookies and etc.

Most importantly, the pp chef paper baking tray feels good and it is great for deep rim.

Almost all buyers agree that the tray has a very shiny (so hopefully, wo stick) finish and, so far, has been easy to clean. And, they also found that the tray is a bit hard to clean after baking. In addition, a few strongly agree that this baking sheet is stainless steel and not aluminum. Overall, many have used the pp chef paper baking tray for more than a few months without any issues, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This allows for easy clean-up and it allows for smooth surfaces.
• This is constructed with 18/0 high quality stainless steel without toxic substances or chemical coatings.
• Keep shiny and dishwasher proof but aluminum not 3.
• This is suitable for cooking for multiple people for a big family.

Best For Rounded Corners: Teamfar Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other trays in this category, the Teamfar Paper Baking Tray has a convenient design. The teamfar paperbaking tray is constructed with perfect weight, is shiny stainless and it is perfect for home use. Set of 3, all measured 16 x 12 x 1 inches. Further, the tray is made for side by side, is worth the money and it is great for Thanksgiving day.

The tray is highly recommend, is great for different sizes and it is perfect for your home. Further, it is perfect for half size and it is great with high sides. Finally, the teamfar paper baking tray has a superb mirror finish to reduce the risk of food sticking, smooth roll edges without rough spots comfortable to hold and transfer.

Most customers opine that the tray measures 15 15/16" x 12. In addition, they say that the tray is 15 x 11.25 inches interior dimension. And, a few say that this is a highly polished and reflective baking sheet and it is intended to replace an aluminum baking sheet, that while the aluminum is stiffer and much thicker, this is a pretty good compromise on cost. In conclusion, most customers found the tray suits best, and no one questions it.

• It is easy to clean and they couldn't be better.
• This is made of aluminium and has become bent or warped over the years.
• This is great for everything else thus far.
• This cleans easily enough without.

Best For Heavy Duty Carbon Steel: Joho Baking Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Joho Baking Paper Baking Tray for daily usage. The joho baking paper bakingtray is perfect for savory baking, cookies, biscuits, other desserts, sheet pan dinners, even used as a serving tray. Baking sheets for the oven can be stackable, so you can store them easily in limited space. Also, it is made of heavy duty carbon steel, resists rust, scratch, bend, even in high heat.

The tray comes with great pans, is made for side by side, It is easy to store and has a small design. In addition, it cleans up easily, It is rose gold and has a fine design. Above all, the joho baking paper baking tray works for smooth surface, It is perfect for puff pastry and has a basic design.

Most customers agree that the tray is made for huge items. And, a few say that the tray is best to wash by hand. And, a few say that the sheet does warp but then it flexes back somehow to the original shape.

• It is easy to clean, hand wash is recommended.
• Joho baking focuses on developing and manufacturing bakeware pans, durability in a lifetime.
• Manufacturer says: lifetime guaranteed for our kitchen baking pans once ordered.
• Please check the size first what you want.

Best For Heat Distribution: Silpat Paper Baking Tray

Buy on Amazon

The Silpat Paper Baking Tray's superior materials make sure that it ages well with use. The silpat paper baking tray is steady, is for half size, it is pretty heavy and has a superior design. The manufacturer says: Using silpat products saves time, money and reduces waste in our environment. Also, it works wonderfully, It is great for parchment and has a nice design.

The tray is easy to grasp, it remains flat and has a perfect design. And, it definitely heats evenly, is traditional, it is perfect for fish sticks and has a product design. Lastly, the silpat paper baking tray allows the tray to be inverted for use as a cooling rack.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the tray was perfect for cooking cookies and other baked goods. And, a few strongly agree that the tray makes baking easy to add to that it is really night and day. In addition, they say that the tray measures 13 1/2 by 16 1/2 inches and the cooking/cooling surface is perforated so air efficiently circulates, which helps whatever is baking to cook evenly.

• This is cold or hot, it is great for easy release and has a fine design.
• This tool is made out of a high quality grade of aluminum.
• The inverted baking tray can also be used to cook the cookies.
• The perforated nonstick baking tray also doubles as a cooling rack.