The 7 Best Peanut Butter Cookie mixes (2023 reviews)

We consider a peanut butter cookie mix to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Milkbliss Peanut Butter Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best With pumpkin: Buy: Kalifornia keto Peanut Butter Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best For anytime celebrations: Buy: Duncan Hines Peanut Butter Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best For Family: Buy: Betty Crocker Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best For fresh baked Cookie Mix: Buy: Betty Crocker Peanut Butter Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best For snack Time: Buy: Krusteaz Peanut Butter Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best With ingredient: Buy: PB2 Peanut Butter Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Milkbliss Peanut Butter Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The milkbliss peanut butter cookie mix is specially designed for your daily purpose and has plenty of most useful features. These cookies are delicious and soft. It can create a rubbery texture. It is not only will they help boost your milk supply but you will love the soft bake texture and taste. It can be heavy and works best if beaten well before adding to other ingredients. It does work for milk production. It is one stick of butter, one egg yolk and one whole egg. It is actually pretty easy to bake.

• Yummy cookies with an added benefit for nursing moms
• Naturally boost your breastmilk supply up to
• Good investment for long term

Best With pumpkin: Kalifornia keto Peanut Butter Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The kalifornia keto peanut butter cookie mix is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. Kalifornia keto kookie mixes are made with simple and wholesome ingredients that your entire family, toddler to teen, will enoy. They’re super easy to make because you only need a couple of ingredients and the flavor is awesome. Since you still have to add your own egg and butter, it will be far more cost effective and almost as easy to just make from scratch using a keto recipe off the web.

The cookies are always soft and fell apart easily so take care when grabbing them. It's got a nice cookie base so you can really make any flavor you want as it has no peanut butter in it at all. The texture of the baked cookies may be different than if you used jarred peanut butter due to the lower fat/oil content of the powdered peanut butter. These cookies are good considering that they are not traditional cookies and mostly to stay on track with the keto diet.

• You can feel good serving them healthy sweets and treats
• Delicious homemade cookies for the whole family
• Low carb, keto-friendly, and tastes amazing

Best For anytime celebrations: Duncan Hines Peanut Butter Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

Duncan Hines has been making great mix for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. It is a fun way to spend time. The double chocolate cookie mix features delicious bits of melted chocolate in a chocolate cookie base for a dessert the whole family will love. It is perfectly baked, crunchy on the outside, chewy inside. It is good for a quick snack for the kids.

They taste amazing and have the perfect texture baked in the little pans. They aren't perfect because they are microwaved, but they are definitely better than a lot of the mug cakes and things. It can be a fun activity for adults and children to customize a cookie. It comes with your own cooking container or use your own.

• Great for an after school treat
• Can whip one up without having to store a batch of cookies
• Good investment for long term

Best For Family: Betty Crocker Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The betty crocker cookie mix's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The Betty Crocker peanut butter snack size cookie mix helps you make delicious fresh out of the oven cookies that everyone will love. It is easy to whip up delicious cookies, brownies and brownie bars. It’s like a mini package so cute and makes sure you dont have too many cookies for one person to just eat them all while watching TV lol. It goes from bowl to oven in minutes for that home baked cookie experience.

It’s a delicious cookie mix that makes a warm, sweet treat packed with flavor that both kids and adults will love. It comes out clean and edges are set with fork. It’s super easy to make, just add 1 TBS of oil and 2 TBS of water mix and roll them squash with fork.

• Very tasty and easy, but just a snack pack
• Make sugar cookie dough as directed on pouch for drop cookies
• Contains wheat, peanut, milk and egg
• Very quick and easy to make and they are delicious

Best For fresh baked Cookie Mix: Betty Crocker Peanut Butter Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The betty crocker peanut butter cookie mix should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. This cookie mix is super simple to mix up and pop in the oven. It looks and feels like other betty crocker pouch cookies, with a nice soft fluffy texture and great rich cookie flavor. The flavor is Cinnamon toast crunch with cinnadust. The addition of the miniature cereal pieces gives the cookies a nice crunch and adds an extra layer of cinnamon flavor.

The mix is a standard ready-to-make Betty Crocker pouch, requiring few ingredients and containing simple instructions. This produces the perfect soft cookie. When you want cookies out of the oven that take less time, these are a great option.

• Moist in the middle with a delicious cinnamon roll taste
• Good way to introduce kids to baking
• Easy to make and good flavor/texture
• Great flavor, a little dry and grainy

Best For snack Time: Krusteaz Peanut Butter Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another mix that manages to win our hearts. It's the krusteaz peanut butter cookie mix and it's widely considered as mix that has the most suitable features. This krusteaz mix makes the perfect kind of soft, chewy, and delicious cookies every time, for anytime. Each box makes plenty of different-sized cookies (and even cookie bars) that are perfect for desserts, snack time, and more. It can also be customized with nuts, fruits, chocolate chips and more to create new treats.

This 12 box pack is great for buying to always keep a krusteaz mix on hand for when you crave it. Stir together egg, butter, and this cookie mix until the dough forms (hand kneading, if necessary), and scoop or press the dough into your desired cookie or cookie bar size. This recipe is also easy to make.

• Delivers what they promise
• Good investment for long term

Best With ingredient: PB2 Peanut Butter Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

Best part: pb2 peanut butter cookie mix costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. When you don’t eat gluten and you’re also wanting a treat with some protein, this is a worthwhile purchase. It has instructions for making 10 which is half of the jar.

• 4 grams of plant-based protein and is only 100 calories per cookie
• Made with 6 simple and recognizable ingredients
• New and hot release