The 9 Best Plastic Caps For 5 Gallon Water Bottle (2023 reviews)

We are personally inclined towards gofriipai plastic cap for 5 gallon water bottle, it is not so pricy, but it overachieves its purpose and outstanding in important aspects. Silicone Stretch Lids are a fantastic eco-friendly alternative to traditional plastic wrap or aluminum foil. These are nice to have, easy to clean, but the inner plug pops open with little force, so if you set the full jug down to hard, it will likely come open. It reduces air leak when the bottle is put upside down.

These lids don't leak at all when placed on either. It can be stored on their sides with no fear of leaks. The inner plug opens easily. These are perfect to fit on 5 gallon refillable water jugs. These lids are great if you’re refilling your own jugs.

Why We Like This:

More plastic caps that are hard to pry off and waste money
Food grade silicone, bpa free, sturdy & durable
Material is similar to those high heat resistant silicone

Best For Plastic Water Bottles: Striludo Plastic Cap For 5 Gallon Water Bottle

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cap. The striludo plastic cap for 5 gallon water bottle is exactly that - it's a simple cap that hits all the right notes. This 3 pack-5 gallon water jug covers are made of good quality silicone and they work great so far. It fits the primo 5 gallon water jugs easily and will hold if the water jug tips over in the car. One of them has the bigger "lip" on the top, designed for press on lids, and the other is threaded for the screw-on type. They keep the water in the jug until you set it on the water cooler.

It's easy to remove and works well. It is designed to have strong sealing performance, so it will not spill, leak or overflow. This is very convenient, especially for top loading water dispensers.

Why We Like This:

Easy to get on and off
Perfect fit for primo 5 gallon 55mm lids
Great reusable caps with penetration plug
Works great for 5 gallon jugs

Best Cap: Neworkg Plastic Cap For 5 Gallon Water Bottle

Buy on Amazon

The neworkg plastic cap for 5 gallon water bottle is capable of outshining several other cap featured in this list in overall features for the price point. It works with original primo 5gal as intended without leaking. It is easy to use, though it does take a bit of pressure to secure the cap to the bottle. The caps fit a 3 or 5 gallon jug perfectly. This also makes it easier to pop the cap into place. It is easy to install, easy to remove by tearing off the indicated corner. If you store the bottles standing up, then these should work just fine for you to reuse again and again.

It is much harder to start the tear after the cap's on a bottle.

Why We Like This:

More wet counter tops when flipping the refilled jugs
Includes 28 pack water bottle replacement caps with plastic film
New and hot release

Best For Water Storage: MYLOLF Plastic Cap For 5 Gallon Water Bottle

Buy on Amazon

The mylolf plastic cap for 5 gallon water bottle should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. These 5 gallon water caps are a great way to reuse your 5 gallon water jugs. They come assembled properly with the retaining loop and cap on the inside so after you wash them put them back together the same way and you’re all set. These are the caps you want, if you don't want to deal with a jug that tipped over and leaked all over. It can work on screw-top water jugs and does not leak, either upside down or on its side.

These are pretty light and will get blasted around the dishwasher by the jets. These are perfect to have on hand if you need a replacement cap for larger water jugs.

Why We Like This:

Excellent choice for reducing plastic waste from individual water bottles
Need to worry about the plug falling into the water jug at all
Works with the primo water jugs

Best For snap Top Bottles: Tobelife Plastic Cap For 5 Gallon Water Bottle

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another cap that manages to win our hearts. It's the tobelife plastic cap for 5 gallon water bottle and it's widely considered as cap that has the most suitable features. This simple but effective item is the heart and soul of keeping your purified water contained. It fits primo bottles and also it is good for one time use. The center plug on these caps has a short tether that keeps it connected to the lid and allows you to replug the cap and use it again. It fits properly and provide a good seal to the mouth of the jug.

It is made from pe plastic with bpa free. It is perfect for snap top bottles, not for use with a screw top bottle. It is easy to install and come off fairly easy.

Why We Like This:

Easy removal with the perforated tabs
5 gallon bottle caps fit well, easy to install and come off fairly easy
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For Bottles: Fiizzot Plastic Cap For 5 Gallon Water Bottle

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cap. The fiizzot plastic cap for 5 gallon water bottle is exactly that - it's a simple cap that hits all the right notes. Water jug 5 gallon cap operation is simple and labor-saving, lids for 5 gallon water bottles for elderly and children can also easily operate. They fit the size of the Primo water bottles. They have a unique anti-leakage design, which can fit perfectly with the 55mm opening water bottle, even if you lay sideways full of water water jug on the water jug holder, no water leakage will occur.

These fit the straight top 5 gallon jugs nicely. The silicone lids are easy to wash/sterilize between uses. The product doesn't leak while the jug is on on it's stand.

Why We Like This:

Comes with handle and easy to carry
Great solution for your 5gal jugs
Works great and is easy to put on and remove

Best For American Maid Bottles: Toymis Plastic Cap For 5 Gallon Water Bottle

Buy on Amazon

The toymis plastic cap for 5 gallon water bottle is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily purpose. These silicone water caps are soft, easy to install and disassemble, first turn the lid upside down, put the lid tightly on the mouth of the barrel, and then adjust the edge to make sure its sealed. It fits the American Maid 5 gallon water bottle. It comes with an inner buckle that can be removed, so it can be used in a water dispenser.

It is perfect for american maid bottles. The caps are easy to place on the jug, and easy to take off. It is easy to clean and reusable, save you time and energy.

Why We Like This:

Great option for hard to find screw on tops
Works with primo pump and american made bottles
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best idea: Zerone Plastic Cap For 5 Gallon Water Bottle

Buy on Amazon

The zerone plastic cap for 5 gallon water bottle is capable of outshining several other cap featured in this list in overall features in its price range. They are pretty tough to get off too. They are made of shitty/weak plastic. It fits more secure into the dispenser to prevent water leakage when replacing the water bottle on the unit. It is fit for a 5.5cm outlet water bottle with screw thread, refill your water jug for recycling use and saving money, no need for disposable water caps. They thread on and stay on without any fuss. It is made of food grade plastic material, this is safe, harmless and reusable.

Why We Like This:

Anti-drop thickened water jug cap plug
53 mm bottles with screw-on caps
Superior quality food grade plastic material

Best Easy To Use: CUNDA Plastic Cap For 5 Gallon Water Bottle

Buy on Amazon

Cunda line of cap come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. Be nature friendly with these reusable bottle caps which will also save you lots of money with time. Thanks to its stronk sealing, this jug cap keeps dust and other dirt out of your water, keeping it clean, fresh and sterile. It is made out of environment friendly silicone, ensuring you that drinking water can stay pure and fresh for a long time.

The Cunda” silicone caps are reusable and easy to remove as well, so your fingers will not get hurt. It comes with its standard 55mm opening and it is a perfect fit for 5 gallon jugs but also for 3 gallon jugs. It works well and does not leak even after multiple uses. It is odorless, soft and elastic.

Why We Like This: