The 8 Best Plastic Flappers (2022 reviews)

The Fluidmaster Plastic Flapper's high-end materials make sure that it ages well with use. The fluidmaster plastic flapper is adjustable for optimum performance and water savings, is corrosion-resistant, and has a solid frame for ultimate reliability. Replace or fix your toilet flapper with a fluidmaster toilet flapper. And, this seals well, go ahead, it stopped the leak and has worked as design.

Above all, the fluidmaster plastic flapper is very nice, It is very simple and has a universal design.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the flapper was perfect after adjusting the chain length. Also, a few say that the flapper is easy to install and seemed to fit right. And, they also found that the flapper fits any toilet size.

Customers also found that its wise to buy a plastic toilet chain, along with this flapper.

Top Customer Quotes:

This allows for flush adjustment.
This installed easily, is adjustable for maximum performance and it stops wasting water.
The flapper, a dial to adjust the amount of water in the flush.
The rigid frame aligns the flapper properly on every flush.

Best For Exact Replacement: Kohler Plastic Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase flappers for their daily usage, but the Kohler Plastic Flapper would be an anomoly. The kohler plastic flapper works as advertised and it works well. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, the flapper is compatible with the following kohler models.

The flapper is designed by kohler engineers to maintain original product performance and promote product longevity. In addition, it is made for easy installation and it fits perfectly. Lastly, the kohler plastic flapper would be perfect with the product description and it fits properly.

Most buyers found that the flapper allows new performance again. Also, a few also found that the flapper is more pliable to allow easy reset of the 3 flush tower tangs with a 1/4 clockwise turn. Further, they strongly agree that the flapper fits perfectly and works 100. Therefore, buyers were very happy to recommend it to friends and would-be buyers.

Top Customer Quotes:

This is a little too expensive.
For one-piece toilets with 3 1/4" flappers.
This works very well and it stopped the leak.
This includes the installing is easy, and the chain for the interior handle bar.

Best For Hard Water: Essential Values Plastic Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Essential Values offers a variety of flapper for personal choice and yet maintains quality in all the variants. The Essential Values Plastic Flapper is as simple as it could get. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, it is great for high quality and it stopped the leaks.

Above all, the essential values of plastic flapper are not compatible with the following two power - gravity toilet models.

Most customers agree that the flapper is easy to install, fixed the intermittent tank leak caused by the old and warped flapper. And, they strongly agree that the flapper is nice because the connection is all the way around and stretches to fit. And, they say that the flapper is a pretty standard toto flapper. Overall, buyers found this to be one of the best flappers for daily purposes.

Top Customer Quotes:

This is crafted with fine workmanship and has a universal design.
Replacing your flapper will not take you more than a few minutes.
This is easy to install in less than 10 minutes.
High-quality red rubbery-toto universal flapper is also resisting chlorine and gems issues.

Best For Few Months: American Standard Plastic Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The American standard plastic flapper is suitable and reliable and fits well with your regular use. The American standard plastic flapper is white and it is designed for an exact fit. Parts, hardware, and components are engineered to enhance the usage of your American standard products. And, the flapper is made in the United States and is also durable and reliable.

The flapper does the job and it has prime shipping. Above all, the American standard plasticflapper is a style that works better every.

Almost all customers agree that the flapper is an American standard part but should fit any ticket that uses a 3" flapper and has the little "ears" on the flush valve. And, they strongly agree that the flapper looks like an engineering modification. Also, a few strongly agree that the constant running and disengaging of the flapper upon flushing the toilet led to the daily removal of the toilet tank cover and the repeated adjustment of the dysfunctional original flapper. In short, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the flapper suits the purpose.

Top Customer Quotes:

This is very happy, is effective, it has paid attention and has worked as a design.
This was great for a few months, but now I getting phantom flushes.
This fits well in the tank drain.
This is a perfect fit, works like a charm.

Best For Stainless Steel: Aquasource Plastic Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Aquasource Plastic Flapper is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily use. The aquasource plastic flapper is exactly like the original and it installed easily. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, it comes in standard clamshell packaging.

The flapper is compatible with current models including henshaw, colby, Lyndsay, and rutherford. Finally, the aquasource plastic flapper is available in a plastic clamshell or a plastic bag.

Most buyers agree that the flapper takes a good amount of force to get them off or on. Also, a few also found that the flapper fits Glacier Bay toilets. Additionally, it is a great replacement for the old blue flapper. And, they say that the flapper looks exactly like the replacement, so it may have already been replaced.

Why We Like This:

This is made of a durable hard plastic body and a silicone seal.
Replaces leaking, warped, or worn flappers.
Meets all applicable US and Canadian plumbing codes (upc and csa).
This comes with a stainless steel chain and hooks attached.

Best For Better Price: Plumb Craft Plastic Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Plumb Craft offers a variety of flapper for personal choice and yet maintains quality in all the variants. The Plumb Craft Plastic Flapper can be bought for a better price and it is worth the money. The water saver forever toilet flapper is the perfect flapper to fix your running, leaky toilet, forever. And, this comes with a limited lifetime warranty.

Above all, the plumb craft plasticflapper is effective, fits most toilets including and it works well for good quality.

Almost all buyers found that the flapper provides a sure seal and also comes with a limited lifetime warranty. In addition, a few say that the flapper is made for a perfect fit and no more leaks. Moreover, they strongly agree that this review is for the plumb craft water saving forever adjustable toilet flapper 2 inch. With no doubts, this flapper passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

Few customers got plastic toilet chain, along with the flapper.

Why We Like This:

Fits most toilets, including: American standard, kohler, glacier bay, Mansfield and many more.
This is very happy, stopped the leak and there are many more.
Lot of satisfied buyers.

Best For Quick Delivery: Duravit Plastic Flapper

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about convenient and suitable flapper, Duravit Plastic Flapper is your end point. Flapper 3" plastic one piece / two piece 1.6 gpf / 1.28 gpf single flush. Also, the flapper is made for quick delivery and it fixed the problem. In conclusion, with a 4.4 rating and more than 224 buyers, the duravit plastic flapper stands as the best choice.

In conclusion, buyers found this to be one of the best flappers for daily purposes.

Why We Like This:

Good investment for the long term.
Lot of satisfied buyers.

Best With Fast Shipping: Lasco Plastic Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Lasco is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist flappers for people on the go, and its line of Lasco Plastic Flappers definitely falls in line with that reputation. The lasco plastic flapper is user-friendly and it worked perfectly. Please revert to retail place of purchase for resolution of any possible plumbing questions, warranty or defective part replacement. And, it is good for exact replacement and it has caused ghost flushes.

Most importantly, the Lasco plastic flapper is a third - generation family - owned and operated company with over 80 years of experience. has the largest retail plumbing line in the industry today with over 7000 packaged and 16, 000 bulk sku's.

"If your tank leaks into the bowl and you own a kohler, this is a perfect fit. " - says, one customer. Without any doubt, this product passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

Customers say that buying a plastic toilet chain, with this flapper made their life much easier.

Why We Like This:

Manufacturer says: We pride ourselves on service, selection and support.
This is best for good fit and it would be perfect with fast shipping.
Good brand reputation.