The 9 Best plastic Horseshoe sets (2023 reviews)

Are you looking for collection of best plastic horseshoe sets ? You have come to the right page.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Gosports plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For Horseshoe pit: Buy: St. Pierre plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For cook out party: Buy: Franklin Sports plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For indoors: Buy: Champion Sports plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For Backyard: Buy: Crown sporting goods plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For tailgating: Buy: Hey Play plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For both indoor And Outdoor Fun: Buy: Trademark Innovations plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For money: Buy: Armstrong home Solutions plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best For birthday parties: Buy: GSE games Sports expert plastic Horseshoe Set READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Gosports plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase set for their regular usage, but the gosports plastic horseshoe set would be an anomoly. This is a good, sturdy set of horseshoes with a handy carrying bag. It includes two metal rods, two red horseshoes, two blue horseshoes and a canvas zippered carrying bag. It is made of cast steel, which makes them durable and are rust and corrosion resistant. It comes with the case, you can bring it on picnics and camping outings for some quick, traditional outdoor fun and expect the set to outlast the users.

This is a very nice horseshoe set, and the carrying case makes it easy to take to park, beach, or parties. It comes in a really nice carry bag (with plenty of room to store additional items in, if needed), and the stakes and horseshoes are super solid and sturdy.

• Well constructed and a heavy duty carrying/storage bag too
• Great for the beach and for the back yard
• Pretty solid build and sturdy material
• Very solid and sturdy poles and shoes

Best For Horseshoe pit: St. Pierre plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase set for their daily purpose, but the st. pierre plastic horseshoe set would be an anomoly. Throwing on a straight, smooth stake, this shoe performs awesome, and will last year after year. It has longer tips, a tapered leading edge allowing the shoes to slide into the stakes and a ringer breaker to rotate the shoe. The case is light duty, but works well to keep everything together and clean for the next event. They get some light to moderate use and they still look new.

If you're looking for a decent set of horseshoes for the backyard without dropping a lot of clams, this is the set for you. These are good quality with precise instructions. The horseshoes are weighted properly and the stakes are easy to hammer into the ground at the park and then easier to remove the shoe. This set is sturdy, and works as expected.

• Heavy duty kit that helps you to play harder without worries of damaging
• Awesome set, great powder coated steel shoes
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For cook out party: Franklin Sports plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

This is a really nice starter set, it has everything you need to get a game going, and it comes with a nice instruction manual that outlines the rules & has a diagram with measurements for setting up the Horseshoe court. It is made of a thin canvas like material with full color printing of brand information and people using the product. It has a good durable coating to prevent rust. There is room to carry a mallet or hammer for the 2 poles in the bag.

The metal is the perfect standard shape on the stakes and horseshoes. It is great for temporary setups in the yard or park, not for long term. It is easy to set up and comes with a case for easy portability. It is good for temporary setups in the yard or park, not for long term.

• Hours of family fun and great for bbqs, picnics, or other outdoor events
• Perfect for the beach, backyard, an outing or your next party
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For indoors: Champion Sports plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

Champion Sports makes beautiful and great set with classic and smartly choosen materials. Young and old love these Horseshoe Sets, they can be used indoor or outdoor. It is great for horseshoes on artificial grass. It comes with 4 horseshoes, 2 rubber mats with center pegs, and 2 red plastic dowels, this horseshoe set comes with everything needed to start a game in your backyard, on the playground, or in the gym. It is eaiser to twist them into the ground, instead of trying to hammer or push from the top, as they will split.

The base is very lightweight and falls over easily but its good enough to have some fun with. The odor that emitted from the box is very, very strong. You can play it indoors or use outside without worrying about putting holes in your yard. They are great for outside play in the summertime and great for inside play and some well needed exercise in the winter time when it snows.

• Great for the kids birthday party
• Fun game for everyone and the hard rubber horseshoes are perfect
• Simple to assemble and has stakes for playing on hard surfaces

Best For Backyard: Crown sporting goods plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

The crown sporting goods plastic horseshoe set's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The whole family likes this item and it's so much fun without having to dig holes in the ground. It's easy to set up and take down and does not ruin the lawn. The horseshoe is a very strong sturdy plastic. It is rubber so it can be used indoors or outdoors.

The poles are weighted enough to keep from falling over. They are heavy enough that they don't bounce when they hit the ground but stay in place. It can be played inside or outside.

• Heavy duty plastic horseshoes and parts
• Easy assemble for indoor play or grass
• Great for playing horseshoes with kids

Best For tailgating: Hey Play plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

The hey play plastic horseshoe set is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily usage. With components that allow you to play both inside and outside, this lawn game is ideal for adults and kids of all ages, and can be played anywhere. This horseshoe set comes with ground stakes and pegs with suction cups, so you can set up and play both outdoors and indoors. It works perfectly indoors, the mat lays flat and the pole stands straight up (have not tried it outdoors yet) and the horseshoes have a great weight to them, so they don't feel like a toy.

This makes it a great game for the beach, parties, picnic, camp, tailgate, backyard, and even on a rainy day. The rubber and soft plastic components also mean indoor use will not damage floors, walls and furniture.

• Easy to transport & set up
• Delivers what they promise

Best For both indoor And Outdoor Fun: Trademark Innovations plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate set. The trademark innovations plastic horseshoe set is exactly that - it's a simple set that hits all the right notes. The Tailgate 360 Complete Outdoor Horseshoe Set is perfect for the kids and Grandkids to play, it would be perfect with metal rods. It includes 2 red and 2 blue horseshoes, 2 long sticks for outdoor play, 2 short sticks for indoor play and 2 plastic boards for inserting the stakes. It is made of a fairly heavy solid rubber, about as heavy as you can get for kids before moving on to the real thing.

This is a toy for your kids to use on the lawn or easily portable to take to the beach or park. It is great for the kids and easy to set up. It's weighted enough to work well and is kid friendly as well. They are pretty flimsy. This is a fun and safe game, kids can play horseshoes without hurting themselves or being too heavy, colors are good too, so they know what horseshoes are theirs.

• Fun game for back yard or take it anywhere
• Easy and fun to play on the beach
• Much easier to handle than the heavy metal ones

Best For money: Armstrong home Solutions plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

Armstrong Home Solutions line of set come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. It is great for ages two to five. Kids love it great quality materials and wish it had come with a carrying case to store and make it more portable. It comes with an actual metal spike pole set as opposed to those flimsy plastic stumps. The stakes are great heavy duty metal.

The colors are nice and vibrant but the horseshoes are plastic and very light weight. It will still be rust-free after years of playing. The stakes are metal, the set is light and easy for children to carry themselves.

• Bright red and blue color horse shoes allow for easy scoring from far away
• Great horseshoes for kids at the beach
• Good brand reputation

Best For birthday parties: GSE games Sports expert plastic Horseshoe Set

Buy on Amazon

Best part: gse games sports expert plastic horseshoe set costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. The complete indoor and outdoor rubber horseshoe game set includes 4 horseshoes ( 2 red/2 blue ), 2 rubber mats with posts, and 2 plastic stakes. It comes with stakes to go in the ground or a set that does not need to be driven into the ground. It is a sturdy game that both children and adults will enjoy.

The complete indoor and outdoor rubber horseshoe game set is suitable for indoor or outdoor use as it will not damage floors or walls during games and will not dig up your yard, since they are so lightweight. It is made with quality rubber, these lightweight horseshoes are easier to throw, and aim compared to traditional metal horseshoes, and their soft design also makes them safe. The pegs could be longer to get further into the ground so they don’t tip over when they are hit.

• Easy to put together, sturdy and fun
• Leading the games and sports with quality product that make a hedonistic lifestyle
• Easy and quick set-up and tear-down for anyone
• Fun for everyone of all ages