The 7 Best Pumpkin pie Butter (2023 reviews)

We consider a pumpkin pie butter to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Tj'S Pumpkin pie Butter READ REVIEW

Best For Gourmet gift: Buy: Green Jay Gourmet Pumpkin pie Butter READ REVIEW

Best pumkin Butter: Buy: Trader Joe'S Pumpkin pie Butter READ REVIEW

Best tasting Butter: Buy: Dickinsons Pumpkin pie Butter READ REVIEW

Best Sweet potato Butter: Buy: Braswell Pumpkin pie Butter READ REVIEW

Best Flavor: Buy: Amish Buggy Pumpkin pie Butter READ REVIEW

Best value For money: Buy: Mccutcheons Pumpkin pie Butter READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Tj'S Pumpkin pie Butter

Buy on Amazon

The tj's pumpkin pie butter is specially designed for your daily purpose and has plenty of most useful features. This might not be the healthiest choice of Pumpkin Butter, but it is very tasty. It is not as sweet as nutella, but it is definitely dessert. It makes a phenomenally tasty treat. Its jam-like quality makes it easy and quick to spread on whatever you choose, and its pumpkin/cinnamon sweetness makes a wonderful fall flavor.

The ingredients listed on the jar are pumpkin, sugar, honey, lemon juice concentrate, cinnamon, cloves, ginger, and nutmeg. It is perfect for the occasional sweet tooth fix. It comes with 9grams of sugar per serving. It is on the high side for those counting sugars and you can definitely taste it.

• Would be a great gift basket addition
• Wonderful for cooking fall delights or by itself
• New and hot release

Best For Gourmet gift: Green Jay Gourmet Pumpkin pie Butter

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other butter in this category, the green jay gourmet pumpkin pie butter has a convenient design. Green Jay gourmet fruit butters bring to you the familiar, comforting butter experience with a whole lot of fruity, spicy flavors you won’t find elsewhere. Pumpkin butter, with its rich flavor profile, is a perfect addition to your favorite sweet & savory foods, from crumble bars & grilled chicken to cinnamon rolls & croissants. It has a great flavor. The flavors make you think of that thanksgiving treat, pumpkin pie.

This pumpkin butter is delicious. It does have a strong cinnamon flavor. If you like a strong nutmeg flavor this might be for you. It is perfect for a gourmet gift, too.

• Great on toast and pancakes for any pumpkin lover
• Sweet, tart, spice and everything nice
• New and hot release

Best pumkin Butter: Trader Joe'S Pumpkin pie Butter

Buy on Amazon

Trader Joe’s Pumpkin Butter is delicious on walnut cranberry bread toast for breakfast with coffee. It is to be an ingredient in cookies with pumpkin butter, browned butter and chocolate chunks in it. This spread does not actually contain butter, but it does have a distinctively rich, butter. It is smooth and light with opulent flavor and mouth feel. It's full of spices and not too sweet.

This pumpkin butter is very flavorful and good with peanut butter. It is wrapped so well that it took ten minutes to unwrap it. This spread makes them so yummy. It is good and great for toast.

• Great flavor that complements trader joe's brioche pumpkin bread
• Fantastic adding to plan greek yogurt
• Great ingredient for muffins or cookies
• Great on toast, english muffin or bagels

Best tasting Butter: Dickinsons Pumpkin pie Butter

Buy on Amazon

The dickinsons pumpkin pie butter should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. This pumpkin butter is very tasty and worth every penny. It is comfort food at its best simple, hearty, and nourishing. It is a velvety smooth, golden fruit butter with the autumn flavor of spiced pumpkin pie. It pairs perfectly with pumpkin bread. It has a deep and rich flavor. The taste is definitely there and truly wonderful. It is delicious as well as versatile.

• Delicious and very good value as the 6 pack
• Mild pumpkin taste, not too sweet
• Perfect on toast & in oatmeal
• Very well packed with no issues with glass jars

Best Sweet potato Butter: Braswell Pumpkin pie Butter

Buy on Amazon

The braswell pumpkin pie butter's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. This is a delicious sweet potato butter. It has a sweet ( but not overly) rich & smoky flavor. It is great as a topping on breakfast breads, muffins, toast or scones. It is heavyweight and has a cut glass appearance. There are more ingredients than sweet potatoes and those 4 spices, which can be seen in the product's photos. The peach butter is excellent as well. This butter is super delicious.

• Ingredients all spice, cinnamon, ground glove and ground ginger
• Good tasting and a little goes a long way
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best Flavor: Amish Buggy Pumpkin pie Butter

Buy on Amazon

The amish buggy pumpkin pie butter should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. This is the best pumpkin butter and it does not have added sugars. They have no weird taste, and are perfect for those who are diabetic or are just looking for a more healthy alternative to spreads full of sugar. This pumpkin butter is not only organic but no sugar added, it is delicious. They come packaged wonderfully and quickly. It is so tasty, not too sweet, and a good level of spice.

• Not too sweet, nicely spiced and a good sized jar
• Great flavor and the only sweetener is cider
• Great on bread and stirred into yogurt

Best value For money: Mccutcheons Pumpkin pie Butter

Buy on Amazon

These have been known for their old fashioned preserves, fruit butters, jellies, and sauces since. It is used to make the most delicious homemade pumpkin butter. This McCutcheons pumpkin butter comes in a pint jar and it has a rich pumpkin taste with a sweet and mild spicy taste. It's so good that when family members taste this product they want to take some home to enjoy.

The pumpkin butter itself is smooth and mildly spicy.

• Serve hot with cream or with ice
• Ingredients pumpkin, sugar, fruit acids, spices
• Good investment for long term