The 9 Best Pumpkin spreads (2023 reviews)

The tj's pumpkin spread is capable of outshining several other spread featured in this list in overall features. This Pumpkin Butter is delicious. It is great on bagels, toast, and biscuits, mixed in with greek yogurt, on pancakes, crepes, you name it. The ingredients listed on the jar are pumpkin, sugar, honey, lemon juice concentrate, cinnamon, cloves, ginger, and nutmeg. They love it on pancakes and biscuits too.

The smoothness of the butter blends so well. It is not as sweet as nutella, but it is definitely dessert. It is great for holiday baking.

Why We Like This:

Delicious with puff pastry and brie
Wonderful for cooking fall delights or by itself
Yummy,great on crackers, toast and a spoonful

Best For Gourmet gift: Green Jay Gourmet Pumpkin Spread

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention green jay gourmet pumpkin spread for daily purpose. Green Jay gourmet fruit butters bring to you the familiar, comforting butter experience with a whole lot of fruity, spicy flavors you won’t find elsewhere. Pumpkin butter, with its rich flavor profile, is a perfect addition to your favorite sweet & savory foods, from crumble bars & grilled chicken to cinnamon rolls & croissants. It tastes like pumpkin pie without being overly sweet.

All Green Jay gourmet fruit butter flavors use all-natural, real food ingredients. It does have a strong cinnamon flavor. The Green Jay gourmet fruit butter products contain no corn syrup, preservative or msg. If you like a strong nutmeg flavor this might be for you.

Why We Like This:

Sweet, tart, spice and everything nice
Great on toast and pancakes for any pumpkin lover
Delivers what they promise

Best Pistachio Butter: Nurawbar Pumpkin Spread

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for appropriate and satisfactory spread, nurawbar pumpkin spread should be your first option for buying. These delicious butters are a good source of protein, fiber, potassium and iron. The Pistachio butter naturally has a long shelf life of 12 months not opened. It tastes delicious, it's organic and for someone who doesn't eat sugar this is like a dessert.

This, although grainier, has a good flavor enhanced by vanilla. The vanilla bean gives it a sublime flavor. It is easy to spread but a bit light on flavor. It’s packaged well and the lid is tight. It has a great, hearty taste.

Why We Like This:

A decently made pistachio nut butter
Light flavor and not too sweet like almond butter
Has a great flavor and all natural
Perfect snack/small meal when u add an apple

Best pumkin Butter: Trader Joe'S Pumpkin Spread

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about appropriate and satisfactory spread, trader joe's pumpkin spread should be your first option for buying. Trader Joe’s Pumpkin Butter is delicious on walnut cranberry bread toast for breakfast with coffee. It is cooked slowly, in small batches, with sugar and spices, so the spices have plenty of time to marry with the pumpkin. It is an ingredient in cookies with pumpkin butter, browned butter and chocolate chunks in it. It is smooth and light with opulent flavor and mouth feel. It is good and great for toast. It is an incredible delicious product. It gives peanut butter a run for its money.

Why We Like This:

Great flavor that complements trader joe's brioche pumpkin bread
Great on toast, english muffin or bagels
Fantastic adding to plan greek yogurt
Great ingredient for muffins or cookies

Best with anything: Redhawk Farms Pumpkin Spread

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention redhawk farms pumpkin spread for regular usage. Sugar is actually a form of natural preservative and it does have a bit of sugar. The ingredient list gives a bunch of sweeteners separately, "sugar" and "brown sugar" as well as apple juice concentrate, a slightly deceptive practice. It works great in place of any jelly/jam, and has a very sweet, thick flavor. The jam is intensely sweet, but also intensely apple-flavored, with a rich and concentrated fruitiness.

The apple butter is sweet and delicious with no artificial flavors or preservatives. It is not too thin that this runs and not so thick you can’t spread it. It is made from responsibly sourced, premium ingredients, and cooked with care in small batches in ohio’s amish country. The sugar is actually a form of natural preservative and it does have a bit of sugar.

Why We Like This:

Fantastic flavor, not too spiced or sweet
Flavor is really balanced, not too sweet, no ingredient/spice overpowers
Really good balance of flavor and thickness

Best For glazing on meats: world of chia Pumpkin Spread

Buy on Amazon

Best part: world of chia pumpkin spread costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. Chia seeds are known to be a great source of omega-3 fatty acids, energy, protein, fiber, antioxidants, and calcium. It is crafted with natural and healthy chia seeds without losing the desired jelly or jam texture. It works well as a jam replacement, or as a mix-in for plain yogurt. It is a great way to boost some nutrients in a yummy way. It is great for glazing on meats. It’s a great way to get chia seeds in your diet along with delicious fruit jam.

Why We Like This:

Available in strawberry, raspberry, marion blackberry, or wildberry
Does not include any gluten or animal products
Mixing with plain yogurt, parfaits, smoothies, oatmeal and cereal
Not too sweet and full of omegas

Best premium: Kauffman'S Fruit farm & market Pumpkin Spread

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other spread in this category, the kauffman's fruit farm & market pumpkin spread has a design with broader appeal. The Old-fashioned cooking process uses Kauffman homemade sweet apple cider and creates a rich, delicious flavor. Instead, it’s a fruit delicacy with a spreadable consistency like soft butter that’s delicious on bagels, crackers, toast, and ice cream. It is made with only a few simple ingredients, including pumpkin, freshly-pressed apple cider, and cinnamon.

Why We Like This:

An authentic, healthful fruit spread with no commercial additives or preservatives
Good brand reputation

Best Giftable: Stonewall kitchen Pumpkin Spread

Buy on Amazon

For a low asking price, stonewall kitchen pumpkin spread has managed to overwhelm their customers by packing as many features as they could. This is tasty pumpkin butter. It is made in the usaabout stonewall kitchen. The texture is very sooth and creamy and the taste is surprisingly wonderful. The butter spreads easily and it can be warmed up and poured over vanilla ice cream if you want to. The taste is great on italian bread with a cup of black coffee. It can be used as a recipe ingredient. It DOES NOT TASTE LIKE A JARRED PRODUCT AND IT IS NOT OVERLY SWEET.

Why We Like This:

Nice glass jar and metal twist lid
Really good on bagels or morning toast
Very nice flavor and easy to spread

Best Feature: easy to Spread: 88 Acres Pumpkin Spread

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate spread. The 88 acres pumpkin spread is exactly that - it's a simple spread that hits all the right notes. This pumpkin seed butter is tremendous. It can no longer use peanut butter, and have to go easy on cashews and almonds. It has a wonderful nutty flavor and great texture. It's very tasty, rich, complex, and super easy to spread or stir into things.

It can no longer use peanut butter, and has to go easy on cashews and almonds. It's satisfying so a little goes a long way.

Why We Like This:

Great for athletes, keto, paleo, low-fodmap dieters, vegans, and omnivores alike
Not sweet but great flavor, can be sweetened by addi maple syrup
Great taste and has good source of iron