The 10 Best Replacing Old Shower Handles (2023 reviews)

We consider a replacing old shower handle to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Danco Faucet Handle Kit READ REVIEW

Best For broken Faucet knob: Buy: Delta Faucet Replacing Old Shower Handle READ REVIEW

Best For kitchen sink: Buy: LDR Industries Replacing Old Shower Handle READ REVIEW

Best For Old Handle: Buy: Plumb USA Replacing Old Shower Handle READ REVIEW

Best For soapy hands: Buy: Primeline Replacing Old Shower Handle READ REVIEW

Best For generic Replacement Handle: Buy: Tearel Great Replacement Handle READ REVIEW

Best spacer: Buy: Danco Replacing Old Shower Handle READ REVIEW

Best For bathtub Faucet: Buy: BRASSCRAFT mfg Replacing Old Shower Handle READ REVIEW

Best For repairing without The need: Buy: Tearel Replacing Old Shower Handle READ REVIEW

Best Feature: Easy To Install: Buy: BRASSCRAFT mfg existing Handle READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Danco Faucet Handle Kit

Buy on Amazon

Here, we review handle that manages to win our hearts. It's the danco faucet handle kit and it's widely considered as one of all-around great handle you can buy. These knobs are a perfect replacement for the worn out hot and cold handles. They are quick and easy to install with just a slotted and a philips screwdriver. They are made of metal. The center of each knob comes with the "H" and "C" are little plastic covers. It is easy to install with little tools required. It is the perfect upgrade or replacement for any bathroom decor with clear plastic hot and cold index buttons for a classic look.

• Very nice shape, and work well
• Great replacement for old tub handles
• Delivers what they promise

Best For broken Faucet knob: Delta Faucet Replacing Old Shower Handle

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase handle for their daily usage, but the delta faucet replacing old shower handle would be an anomoly. The New Delta Knob RP17451 has a diamond shaped opening and requires removing the plastic hexagonal sleeve before installation of the new knob. This knob is roughly 3" in diameter and 2 1/2" tall. It fits all crystal handles. It's just a decorative handle. This pulls out then turns to select temperature. The back looks like a rounded eye. It also has a stainless steel screw. The fact it has the diamond shaped centered hole in the knob.

• Easy to screw on & off
• Easy upgrade to a delta bathroom sink faucet
• Great replacement for a broken knob
• Excellent replacement knob handle kit for tub/shower

Best For kitchen sink: LDR Industries Replacing Old Shower Handle

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase handle for their daily usage, but the ldr industries replacing old shower handle would be an anomoly. These knobs fit the Glacier Bay fixture just fine. It is made using premium grade acrylic construction which provides a smooth turning action. It is used for delta sink faucets with the open side facing down. The back where it mounts has a half cut round bore.

The dimension of each knob is 1.8 inch high with a diameter of 1.8 inch high. It is easy to install and they fit perfectly. It only takes a Phillips head screw driver and about 5-10 minutes of your time. This set of handles fit perfectly. They are about 2 inches across at the top and about 2 inches tall.

• Good replacement for glacier bay faucet
• Installed and finished in less than 5 minutes
• Perfect fit for handles that had to be replaced

Best For Old Handle: Plumb USA Replacing Old Shower Handle

Buy on Amazon

Plumb Usa makes beautiful and great handle with classic and smartly choosen materials. These babies shine like they are straight out of the dark crystal. The Clear acrylic faucet handle will complement any tub and shower faucet. It measures 2.7" length x 2.7" width x 2" height. It feels loose even though it’s as tight as you can make it. The knob itself has two keyholes top and bottom and there is very slight play once on. It fits a pfister 974 to add to that it is easy to install 2mins at most. This knob will fit sink faucets too.

• Attractive enough that it doesn't draw attention to itself
• Easy to install 2mins at most
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best For soapy hands: Primeline Replacing Old Shower Handle

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate handle. The primeline replacing old shower handle is exactly that - it's a simple handle that hits all the right notes. This is universal pretty much everywhere you go even when traveling internationally. It fits inside the handle to allow different sized stems to fit. It includes you need to remove the center caps (hit and cold) and there is a scre that. It fits perfectly, and is easy to install. They grip good for soapy hands or if you are trying to adjust that water pressure is real good at that & easy to clean. It is great for older fixtures.

• Universal knobs for the kitchen sink
• Budget friendly and super easy to install
• Good investment for long term

Best For generic Replacement Handle: Tearel Great Replacement Handle

Buy on Amazon

Blending elegance and sophistication, this large metal valve handle will be the perfect addition to your bathroom. The new handle is comparable, but has a set screw that requires a metric allen wrench which is a hair smaller than the original, which uses a 1/8" blade. The handle fits on the Delta valve stem exactly like Delta's H79 handle. It is a great replacement for the original delta bathroom faucet.

This is a large lever handle for high quality parts to last and will prove to be the perfect replacement for your broken fixture. The quality of this handle is great. It's quick and easy to install, it looks nice and it works perfectly.

• Easy fit nice heavy tight handle
• Solid handle with good finishing and material
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best spacer: Danco Replacing Old Shower Handle

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate handle. The danco replacing old shower handle is exactly that - it's a simple handle that hits all the right notes. This universal style diverter handle will fit any tub or shower faucet. It is constructed of durable metal that will endure the rigors of everyday use. It includes allen wrench, vice grip style adapter and spacers to fit most faucets. All you need is a Philips screwdriver and your set.

This one works perfectly for showers, has a great finish, and installs in minutes. The spacer is there in case you need to have the knob stick out a little farther than just the knob itself would. These even come with new screws plus extras. It is easy to install as well.

• Canopy style handles with a chrome finish for an elegant loo
• Good brand reputation

Best For bathtub Faucet: BRASSCRAFT mfg Replacing Old Shower Handle

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase handle for their daily usage, but the brasscraft mfg replacing old shower handle would be an anomoly. Clear acrylic faucet handles will easily complement any kitchen and bathroom decor. It is one of the designers, manufacturers and distributors of plumbing products for the new construction and repair and remodel markets. Even though this doesn't necessarily update anything, it definitely adds sparkle and feels so much cleaner than the old one. It fits a diamond shaped stem. The transformation of the new look is so delightful. It includes easy-to-follow instructions. It measures 1-3/4" width x 2-1/4 height.

• Definitely adds sparkle and feels so much cleaner than the old one
• Perfect fit for the 30+ year old delta bathtub faucet, looks like new again
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best For repairing without The need: Tearel Replacing Old Shower Handle

Buy on Amazon

Tearel line of handle come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. This shower handle is designed for use with Posi-Temp or Moentrol shower systems and is not compatible with a sink faucet. It includes adapters for use on both posi-temp and moentrol valves. It is ideal replacement handle for repairing without the need to replace the entier plumbing fixtures. It comes with a 2 adapter for the handle to attach to. It is also easy to install.

• Works fine, simple install, just the knob and plastic piece, both slide on
• Look is definitely much better and easy to use & clean
• New and hot release

Best Feature: Easy To Install: BRASSCRAFT mfg existing Handle

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another handle that manages to win our hearts. It's the brasscraft mfg existing handle and it's widely considered as handle that has the most suitable features. The Clear acrylic faucet handle will complement any tub and shower faucet. It measures 2" length x 2.13" width x 2" height. The Handle has exact slots to match, new screw, and cover plate. It is perfectly on old shower tub handle. It is match for pf avante series valve control with tab on valve stem.

• Requires you pull out and then turn for hot or cold
• Lot of satisfied buyers