There are several advantages of having a replacing tub overflow gasket. We are here to help you pick the best one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Ezflo Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best With Nice Finish: Buy: Qualihome Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Solid Metal: Buy: Wholesale Plumbing Supply Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Oil Rubbed Bronze: Buy: Kingston Brass Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Good Seal: Buy: Westbrass Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Tip Toe: Buy: Dorence Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Worth The Investment: Buy: Bluevue Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Heavy Duty: Buy: Bluevue Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For High Quality Material: Buy: Artiwell Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Ezflo Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Ezflo Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket is the best long-standing gasket on the market nowadays. The ezflo replacing tub overflow gasket fits perfectly and it does the job. Fits all standard size tubs. You can install this product in minutes. Also, it looks good and it makes for solid construction.

The gasket is built for heavy duty and it fits very well. Most importantly, the ezflo replacing tub overflow gasket worked perfectly, provides great value and it has an overflow face plate.

Most buyers opine that the gasket is made of zinc pot metal, but "good enough. Also, they strongly agree that the gasket will fit a kohler villager cast iron bathtub. In addition, they also found that this part is so much higher in big stores, but it 's doing the job nicely, looks great, and it holds up well. In short, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the gasket suits the purpose.

• ✅Easy installation- fits all standard size tubs. You can install this product in minutes.
• This is solid brass with chrome plate.
• This is an overflow plate allowing tub water to drain.
• This allows the water to flow out.

Best With Nice Finish: Qualihome Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Qualihome Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket might be a relatively new release, but it's still nothing short of impressive this year, thanks to multiple price cuts and added new features over the past few months. The qualihome replacing tub overflow gasket is good for looks of good quality, It is perfect for simple installation and has a great design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, the gasket is easy to install quickly. It works great and has a simple design.

Above all, the quality replaced tub overflow gasket fits in most standard bath tubs overflows with two holes.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the gasket fits perfect over old cast iron tub overflow holes. Moreover, a few also found that the gasket is meant for a 2 hole application. With no doubts, this gasket passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This is perfect and restored some dignity to the original tub.
• Easy to install Quick and simple installation.
• This is made for this tub drain and fits it perfectly.
• This is inexpensive, does the job, it fits perfectly and has a nice style.

Best For Solid Metal: Wholesale Plumbing Supply Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Wholesale Plumbing Supply offers a variety of gaskets for personal choice and yet maintains quality in all the variants. The Wholesale Plumbing Supply Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket fits 1 3/8 inch or 1 1/2 inch waste elbows. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, it is great for brand name, makes for nice quality and it makes for solid construction.

Above all, the wholesale plumbing supply replacing tub overflow gasket worked perfectly and it works great.

Most customers agree that the gasket is designed to follow similar sizing patterns. And, they strongly agree that the gasket looks good, and is way better than the gaping drain pipe. And, they strongly agree that the gasket is great for a 3 year old that loves bath time. Overall, buyers found this to be one of the best gaskets for daily purposes.

• This comes with a brass adapter for a wider drain thread setup.
• This fits perfectly and it has a very nice finish.
• This can sometimes be quite a chore.
• This is a very well made and solid piece of hardware.

Best For Oil Rubbed Bronze: Kingston Brass Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate gasket. The Kingston brass replacing tuboverflow gasket is exactly that - it's a simple gasket that hits all the right notes. The Kingston brass replacingtub overflow gasket works great and it looks very nice. These unassuming little parts connect your supply lines outside the bathtub to the inlets of your tub filler with a touch of style. In addition, it includes threaded adapter bushing, strainer, overflow plate and bath shoe.

The gasket fits 1-1/2" and 1-3/8" drain shoe sizes. In addition, this includes complete instructions and it is designed for long-lasting durability. Most importantly, the Kingston Brass Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket is built for durable and reliable long - term use.

Most buyers found that the gasket works well so far and also are replaced at no cost. In addition, a few also found that the gasket includes a plastic "enlarger" which can screw on the threads of the smaller size, so it's a two-for-one. Without any doubt, this gasket passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• High quality zinc and abs construction.
• Threaded adapter bushing fits 1-1/2" and 1-3/8" drain shoe sizes.
• This looks amazing, is great for high quality and it is made for simple installation.
• Easy to work toe tap drain.

Best For Good Seal: Westbrass Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate gasket. The Westbrass Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket is exactly that - it's a simple gasket that hits all the right notes. The westbrass replacing tub overflow gasket fits all round, 2 hole overflow elbows. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, the gasket feels very and it works great.

Lastly, the westbrass replacing tub overflow gasket has included components and it is inexpensive.

Most buyers opine that the gasket is the single best item ever invented. In addition, a few strongly agree that the gasket has instructions on Amazon but the font is tiny and cannot be zoomed in nor is there a video.

• This does the job and it looks good.
• This is better looking than most standard overflows with the 2 screws showing.
• This is an elegant looking overflow cover.
• Replaces simple covers with a closing overflow for that extra-deep bathing experience.

Best For Tip Toe: Dorence Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Best part: Dorence replacing the tub overflowgasket costs comparatively little and it is available to ship in 24 hours. Further, the dorence replacing the tuboverflow gasket is designed to fit bath tub drain brands. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, it fits perfectly, is made for excellent fit, It is great for tip toe and has a modern style. look. Above all, the Dorence Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket comes in best suited oil rubbed bronze color.

Almost all customers opine that the gasket fits with the plumber's putty to seal the tub drain. And, a few also found that the gasket is because there's white tape overlapping the original to "reseal" the box. Further, they strongly agree that the gasket is also a very heavy, good quality piece. Overall, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the gasket suits the purpose.

• Above the floor * easy do-it-yourself installation.
• This is built with a great chrome finish.
• It is easy to follow instructions with great results.
• It is easy to remove the stopper to clean hair out of the drain.

Best For Worth The Investment: Bluevue Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase gaskets for their daily purpose, but the Bluevue Overflow Gasket would be an anomoly. And, it is an ideal solution for old tubs' overflow gasket replacement. Bluevue's revolutionary leak-proof gasket solves those problems and more. Lastly, the bluevue overflow gasket does the job, is worth the investment, It works like a charm and has a great design.

Most customers find that the gasket is easy to install, but buy the complete kit with the overflow plate. Further, they strongly agree that the gasket design is dumb, and this piece solves most of the problems with failing o rings. Moreover, they also found that the last issue is that this gasket does not include screws for the retainer bracket.

• For two-hole overflows, cover not included.
• If you have a bathtub, you have a leak waiting to happen.
• This is used to ........which is great.
• These make one way you want it.

Best For Heavy Duty: Bluevue Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate gasket. The Bluevue Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket is exactly that - it's a simple gasket that hits all the right notes. The bluevue replacingtub overflow gasket is inexpensive, is perfect for high quality, It is totally effective and has a simple design. Say goodbye to overflowgasket and bathtub leaks with Bluevue’s revolutionary overflow gasket. The big gasket works for center hole overflow pipes and overflows with one screw on each side.

The gasket is used for very high quality, it works great and has a modern design. Finally, the bluevue replacing tub overflow gasket is intended for overflows secured with single-screw and/or double-screw mounts.

Almost all buyers opine that the gasket is not what is installed on every single tub from the very beginning. And, they strongly agree that the gasket is a far superior idea made capable because of silicone injection molding. And, they also found that the gasket is easy to install, and has worked great. Without any doubt, this product passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This can be used in every bathtub.
• A newer, quicker solution for overflow gasket leaks and repair.
• Low-cost, daily installation in 3 minutes without the help of a licensed professional.
• Manufacturer says: this kit includes a big (larger-sized) leak-proof gasket and a bluevue cover.

Best For High Quality Material: Artiwell Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The artistic replacing tub overflow gasket's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The Artiwell Replacing Tub Overflow Gasket is designed for long-lasting durability. Includes both drain rubber gasket and no putty gasket. You needn’t the putty for the installation, with easy illustrated do it yourself instructions. And, it is easy to use, It is great for high quality and has a great design. Finally, the artiwell replacing tub overflow gasket fits 1-1/2" and 1-3/8" drain shoe sizes.

"Hi, if you can remove the part as shown in the directions, you would not need a plumber. " - says, one customer. To sum up, many buyers have used the gasket for more than a few months without letup, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• The manufacturer says: We are proud of the products we sell, you will be too.
• New and hot releases.