The 6 Best saltwater Taffy gift boxes (2023 reviews)

Sweet Candy Company makes beautiful and outstanding box with classic and higher-grade materials. This salt water taffy is absolutely delicious. They taste like cotton candy and they freeze dry very well. They have that nice firmness that you would expect from salt water taffy. It's been pulled perfectly and the light blue color has a glistening quality that looks lovely in a candy dish or mixed with other taffy.

These are AMAZING, SOFT, SUPER SWEET AND YET, DON'T HURT. The item is fresh and the color is perfect for the candy buffet.

Why We Like This:

Taste great, nice and soft, and the bag is packed full
Delicious taffy and popular with both the kids and adults
Sweet and is the best cotton candy salt water taffy ever

Best runner up: Taffy Town saltwater Taffy gift Box

Buy on Amazon

The latest taffy town saltwater taffy gift box is an absolute beast in terms of its features, and rightfully takes the top spot with ease. They are not as hard & chewy as the ones you find in a box at department stores and they are a little softer, but still fun to eat. It is great in the base of this centerpiece. It has about seven different varieties of taffy and each has a distinct flavor. The color is perfect for a boy baby shower.

The flavor is great and there’s a lot of variety, however the taffy sticks to the wrapper. It can be used as favors for wedding. It is great in a gift basket or holiday gift etc.

Why We Like This:

Great tasting taffy in a big bulk bag with assorted flavors
Perfect addition to the candy bar for a vintage wedding
Good brand reputation

Best For decorations: Sweet Candy company Party favor Box

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another box that manages to win our hearts. It's the sweet candy company party favor box and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient box you can buy. This taffy is so fresh, soft and delicious. It is used for a tea party. It is great for decor and the guessing game at baby showers. These are so good that you’ll want to hide them from yourself. They are soft, smell great and taste amazing. The candy tastes good too. These come in fast and are packaged neatly.

Why We Like This:

Great tasting candy and very fresh
Soft and chewy, great flavor and clearly they’ve been freshly made
Really a good tasting taffy without sticking to you teeth
Great value and the individually wrapped candy is perfect for

Best For Relieving Constipation: Firstchoicecandy saltwater Taffy gift Box

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other box in this category, the firstchoicecandy saltwater taffy gift box has a convenient design. The taffy from this company is delicious and most of the pieces are absolutely soft and fresh. It is repackaged from bulk products, in a facility that also processes peanut, tree nuts, wheat, soy, and milk products. The sweetener is a sugar alcohol so just be advised its great for relieving constipation but too much would not be a very socially friendly experience.

It's really soft and it doesn't stick to the wrapper or your great value for the money, 2 lb. This is also not salt water taffy, its just taffy. The flavor is great because they are very soft but way hard to get out of the wrapper.

Why We Like This:

Taste good, feels good in your mouth, and it last a while
Great gift for a taffy lover
One of the new comers and featured product

Best In softness: black tie Mercantile saltwater Taffy gift Box

Buy on Amazon

The black tie mercantile saltwater taffy gift box is suitable and reliable and fits well with your regular usage. Introducing the BlackTie Box by Black Tie Mercantile, the first and only gift-ready packaging system designed for the unique challenges of E-Commerce. They're unpleasant to eat because they're so stale. The taffy is soft and the flavors are good. They're a “gift for the house” during the holidays.

These come in a neat box. Whether you choose to ship directly to a recipient or to yourself, your item is guaranteed to arrive exactly as described and photographed. They are fresh and yummy just as taffy should be.

Why We Like This:

Includes one 2 lb bag of sweet's assorted salt water taffy
One of the new comers and featured product

Best Flavor: Box Of Maine saltwater Taffy gift Box

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate box. The box of maine saltwater taffy gift box is exactly that - it's a simple box that hits all the right notes.

Why We Like This:

Handcrafted candies using traditional methods, the finest ingredients and a commitment to superior quality
Good investment for long term