The 10 Best Soft Sugar Cookie mixes (2023 reviews)

We consider a soft sugar cookie mix to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Betty Crocker Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best With pumpkin: Buy: Betty Crocker Soft Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best For party OF two: Buy: Duncan Hines Soft Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best With Sprinkle: Buy: Good Dees Soft Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best For someone: Buy: Pyure Soft Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best Gluten Free Mix: Buy: Gfjules Soft Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best For Cookie cutter: Buy: moms Place Gluten Free Soft Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best With ingredient: Buy: Whimsy Cookie Co. Soft Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best For gift: Buy: Whimsy Cookie Co. Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best portion size: Buy: miss Jones Baking Soft Sugar Cookie Mix READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Betty Crocker Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

Betty Crocker line of mix come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. It makes better cookie dough than it does cookies. They have all the great characteristics of a tried-and-true, classic chocolate chip cookie, chewy not brittle, moist not dry, smooth not gritty, flexible not crumbly, and plenty of chocolate chips. For those of you who really need to avoid gluten, this mix calls for gluten free vanilla extract.

These cookies are good, chewy and have great flavor. They will of course have the white chocolate chips in them as well. The dough is a little crumbly but don't worry, the cookie is great and they are not dry or crumbly. It will continue to cook for a few min after you pull them out.

• You will have fairly simple, and absolutely delicious vegan, gf cut-out cookies
• Easy to make, makes a pretty cookie but lacking in flavor
• New and hot release

Best With pumpkin: Betty Crocker Soft Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The betty crocker soft sugar cookie mix might be a relatively new release, but it's still nothing short of impressive this year, thanks to multiple price cuts and added new features over the past few months. These are simple to make, all you need is butter and eggs and they don’t have that artificial flavor of those you buy packaged at the store. It's also the perfect cookie mix to use with cannabutter (LEGALLY ONLY, PLEASE) because the ginger covers the cannabis flavor. The unique combination of sweetness and salty flavours is delicious. They baked up crisp, delicious and best of all not too sweet.

These are soft and chewy, with a little tanginess from the ginger, but not an overwhelming spiciness that you often get from gingerbread. It is best chilled for use with cut outs.

• Highly recommended when you're churning out cookies as gifts, etc
• Very sweet but nice blend of salty and sweet
• Easy to use and tasted great

Best For party OF two: Duncan Hines Soft Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable mix, duncan hines soft sugar cookie mix should be your first option for buying. If you have a small family or if it's just you and you like sugar cookies this one is a must to buy. This particular mix is very very simple to make. It is overwhelmingly sweet but has a pleasant, soft texture when made in the microwave. It doesn't get any better for chocolate lovers.

This one is super sweet, and doesn't taste quite the same. The thickness of the Cookie brownie is just right. It’s super easy and no pan tossing afterwards. This is one such item that you will love the flavor and how easy it is to prepare, with only one bowl to wash up afterwards.

• Delicious so chocolaty lots of chocolate chunks and easy fast to make
• A true mouth watering deep chocolate flavor without overwhelming sugar taste
• Cool & top with white chocolate syrup
• Tastes like a good chocolatey, chewy brownie

Best With Sprinkle: Good Dees Soft Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The good dees soft sugar cookie mix's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. Chewy and thick, it will satisfy your sugar free cravings for cookies. These are perfect to decorate for christmas cookies. The texture is smooth and creamy, with a distinct taste of sunflower seeds that compliments the chocolate perfectly.

These are not too sweet and have a lot of pecans in them. The mix needs 1 egg, 1/2 cup of butter or coconut oil. These are easy to mix up and throw in the oven. They have a pleasant texture, great taste, slightly nutty with a hint of sunflower seed from the flour. These are easy to decorate for christmas cookies.

• Make the dough and freeze for portion control
• Perfect for a sugarless, flourless treat
• When baked correctly, tastes nice soft and delicious
• Perfect base for making different flavors

Best For someone: Pyure Soft Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for appropriate and satisfactory mix, pyure soft sugar cookie mix is your end point. THEY TASTE AMAZING SOOOOOO GOOD BUTTERY AND CHEWY. It is perfect for keto diet, diabetic chocolate chip cookies, gluten-free, paleo, vegan, plant-based, candida, low carb and low sugar lifestyles. The texture however is fantastic, the cookies are very gooey.

The main ingredient is chickpea flour and it contains almonds. The texture is chewy and yummy. It’s also available in a gluten free brownie mix. These cookies are so easy and quick to make. It makes a full 8x8 pan and they are super moist.

• Added a little extra approved mini chocolate chip morsels
• Enjoy your favorite keto sweets while keeping carbs low
• Simple, quick, and the taste was great

Best Gluten Free Mix: Gfjules Soft Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

Stock up on this great, versatile mix, so you can be festive and creative and slightly indulgent with a gluten free cut-out cookie mix no one would ever suspect to be lacking anything. This cookie mix is awesome, just like Jules G-Free flour and bread mix. They taste delicious and they are super soft. It makes a large batch additionally it is perfect as the first time.

They cook perfectly and taste amazing. It is unavoidable with gluten free mixes.

• A very soft (not grainy) cookie that held together well
• Bakes perfectly and works for all shapes also
• Good investment for long term

Best For Cookie cutter: moms Place Gluten Free Soft Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The moms place gluten free soft sugar cookie mix should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. Fluffy and soft, These cookies are so festive and no one will know they are gluten free. They bake up puffy and spread and as such do not hold the shape of the cookie cutter. These make incredible sugar cookies. They are light and just sweet enough to eat alone or be complimented by icing. They are soft and perfectly flavored. They are a lot of fun to make on Christmas Eve and rolling in the dough out, a little thicker makes them fluff up.

• Soft and sweet and so tasty
• Add your own butter, sour cream, and eggs
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best With ingredient: Whimsy Cookie Co. Soft Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

These bags of cookie mix make great cookies. It is easy to make the perfect sugar cookies with this mix. While they do call for an extra ingredient over other ready-to-make mixes, it ensures the end product is high-quality and delicious. It is easy to make biscuits following the instructions on the package which kids can deal with it.

This cookie mix has easy-to-follow instructions, with a few added ingredients that most people already have on hand, and they cook up just as stated. It is one more ingredient than most ready-to-make mixes call for, most mixes add in a powdered extract that tends to lose its potency. They are the right amount of crispy yet soft.

• Lots of buttery, calorie ridden, sugary sweet yumminess
• Very easy to make with great results
• Super easy to make and yummy

Best For gift: Whimsy Cookie Co. Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The whimsy cookie co. sugar cookie mix should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. It’s easy to make sugar cookies and icing, because you add your own butter & egg. This mix makes very good sugar cookies partly because you add your own butter & egg. It is made by adding one egg, 1 1/2 sticks of butter and 1/3 cup of water. The flavor is good and cotton candy-like.

The cookies and icing both have a great flavor. They come simply taped together back to back. This dough is perfect for younger children as there are minimal steps and the only measuring they need to worry about is the butter. It does not use royal icing but it's a very good, softer, icing.

• Recommended to try for a good, homemade tasting sugar cookie
• Easy to make, lots of icing
• Definitely a stress free time with scrumptious results

Best portion size: miss Jones Baking Soft Sugar Cookie Mix

Buy on Amazon

The miss jones baking soft sugar cookie mix is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your regular usage. Miss Jones Baking Co.'s everyday delicious chocolate chip cookie mix has 25% more chocolate chips than the leading brand, delivering gooey deliciousness in every bite. It is made with real ingredients and not a bunch of chemical replacements/additives. The texture is nice, soft and fluffy, and they come together quickly and easily.

The cookies come out moist and the mega chocolate chips are scrumptious. It is made with 100% whole wheat flour, so you can feel good about feeding your loved ones a more nutritious treat. There are plenty of chocolate chips and the cookie tastes so buttery. If you don't mind "healthy" tasting cookies these are a good option, however not as chewy as the naughty version. For a healthier cookie option these are very easy and quite tasty.

• Really great for being more healthy
• Perfect, fresh baked chocolate chip cookie
• Delicious and low in sugar compare with other brands