The 5 Best spicy Pepper Jack Cheese (2023 reviews)

It is important to have the well suited spicy pepper jack cheese. In the following post, we will help you to select the best spicy pepper jack cheeses.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Sargento Pepper Jack Cheese READ REVIEW

Best Runner up: Buy: Tillamook spicy Pepper Jack Cheese READ REVIEW

Best for snacks: Buy: Happy Belly spicy Pepper Jack Cheese READ REVIEW

Best value for money: Buy: Happy Belly sliced Cheese READ REVIEW

Best flavor: Buy: Sargento spicy Pepper Jack Cheese READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Sargento Pepper Jack Cheese

Buy on Amazon

The sargento pepper jack cheese is capable of outshining several other cheese featured in this list in overall features. Sargento pepper jack cheese slices add a burst of heat to a turkey or roast beef sandwich and makes a great snack when served with crackers. It is made from cow milk. It is a decent flavor of pepper, but not too spicy to eat.

This cheese is thinly sliced with good flavor and little spicy heat. The fresh-lock packaging keeps cheese fresh longer, but use within five days upon opening for maximum freshness. It does not contain meat or eggs. It is perfect for sandwiches or atop crackers.

• Great taste thick slices great on burgers
• Excellent texture and moderately hot flavor were pleasing
• Good brand reputation

Best Runner up: Tillamook spicy Pepper Jack Cheese

Buy on Amazon

Offering a creamy and spicy jack flavor, tillamook farmstyle thick cut pepper jack cheese delivers the tastiest, thick slices that make a perfect addition to your burger or sandwich. Packed with delicious, bold flavor, this versatile block cheese is ideal for shredding, slicing, or snacking. It is made with monterey jack cheese and jalapeos.

This cheese has a very nice flavor, not overwhelming, but definitely the pepper jack. It melts well for cheeseburgers. It is ideal for shredding, slicing, or snacking.

• Cultured pasteurized milk, jalapeno peppers, salt, enzymes
• Made from high quality milk, from cows not treated with artificial growth hormone rbst
• Creamy and spicy jack flavor made with monterey jack cheese and jalapeños
• Bigger, meltier, tastier slice of cheese, perfect for your burger or sandwich

Best for snacks: Happy Belly spicy Pepper Jack Cheese

Buy on Amazon

The happy belly spicy pepper jack cheese is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily purpose. Happy belly dairy products are a great-tasting way to get your dairy each day. This brand has a milder pepper flavor than some national brands. It offers spicy bits of peppers blended into a savory, creamy cheese. It melts well and is pretty good over a burger or in sandwiches. This is your basic jack cheese with peppers mixed in. It taste like pepper jack cheese and it is good for snacks or to slice for sandwiches.

• Grates well and consistency is good
• Has a good taste and is a great value
• Tasty flavor, very good color and texture, good value for cost

Best value for money: Happy Belly sliced Cheese

Buy on Amazon

Happy Belly has been making decent quality cheese for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and rightly choosen materials. Happy Belly dairy products are a great-tasting way to get your dairy each day. This brand has a very good flavor to their cheese. It has a creamy flavor with a hint of spice. The flavors are just right & the slices are so easy to separate because of the papers between them.

These slices are great and the package is not too big so you'll certainly use it up before they go bad. It comes in a convenient resealable pack. It has great flavor and the thickness is amazing.

• Melts great on sandwiches and burgers
• Just lovely cheese with sheets between the slices and a nice kick
• Taste was fresh and creamy, and a good peppery kick
• Thick enough to only need one slice on a sandwich too

Best flavor: Sargento spicy Pepper Jack Cheese

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cheese in this category, the sargento spicy pepper jack cheese has a convenient design. The Sargento fiesta pepper jack brings added heat and delicious flavor to nachos and tex-mex recipes. The unique pepper blend adds vibrant color and a nice kick of heat to all your favorite recipes and snacks. Lots of heat and the cheese is creamy and has incredible amounts of flavor.

• Lot of satisfied buyers
• Good brand reputation