The 7 Best thick Apple Butter (2023 reviews)

We consider a thick apple butter to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Amish Wedding thick Apple Butter Buy: READ REVIEW

Musselmans thick Apple Butter Buy: READ REVIEW

Mccutcheons thick Apple Butter Buy: READ REVIEW

Dickinsons thick Apple Butter Buy: READ REVIEW

Dillman farm family owned since 1970 thick Apple Butter Buy: READ REVIEW

Walden Farms Fruit Spread Buy: READ REVIEW

Walden Farms thick Apple Butter Buy: READ REVIEW

Amish Wedding thick Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

There are so many apple butter products out there but this one is the best flavor thickness and goes with so many things and does not overpower it. Old-fashioned, all-natural apple butter for prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in amish wedding foods' apple butter. It is delicious on toast alone or with butter or cream cheese. It is good as a cracker barrel’s apple butter. Creamy and delicious, this apple butter is the best topping for warm muffins and morning toast. The mix of flavors are the best ever. It is good as a cinnamon apple sauce rather than apple butter.

• Homemade quality and flavor with a little hint of cinnamon
• Very tasty and just the right amount of sugar
• Delivers what they promise

Musselmans thick Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The musselmans thick apple butter is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily usage. This type of apple butter would also be a good stand. It is both sweet & spicy, like that of a good apple cider. It is marvelous on slightly toasted bread. It is simply like any jelly or preserves that you would apply on toast. It has the best flavor. The texture is like a smooth slightly thicker applesauce and tastes like apple cider almost. It is non gmo, non high fructose corn syrup, gluten free, dairy free and 30 cals per serving. It simply has the best taste and lowest added sugar of any apple butter out there.

• Sweetness is perfect hand taste is great definitely will buy again
• Feel great about the simple ingredients too with no high fructose corn syrup
• Low sugar and no high fructose corn syrup

Mccutcheons thick Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

Apple butter is a highly concentrated form of apple sauce produced by long, slow cooking of apples with cider or water to a point where the sugar in the apples caramelizes, turning the apple butter a deep brown. This is by far the most scrumptious apple butter out there. If you like sweet & mild yet flavorful apple butter, this is it. It can be used as a gift for apple lovers, teachers, hostesses, or any time you need a gift for the holiday's, and of course for yourself.

The Apple Butter Pull Apart Bread comes out perfect. This apple butter is almost as good as homemade. It’s so delicious, perfectly sweet. This is a perfect replacement to making it with family.

• Not too sweet and just the right amount of spice
• Great taste and smooth the way apple butter should be
• Wonderful on hot homemade buttered biscuits
• Not to thick, not runny, and good taste, and natural

Dickinsons thick Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate butter. The dickinsons thick apple butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. Recreating the flavor of a baked-from-scratch pie, Dickinson's Fruit Butters are rich, dark and thick, with hints of cinnamon and sugar. They make a variety of fruit products all extremely well. This is chunky like fine apple sauce and has the tartness of fresh apples.

• Very flavorful & easily spreads as it's not too thick
• Ingredients apples, high fructose corn syrup, corn syrup, vinegar, sugar, spices, salt
• Good brand reputation

Dillman farm family owned since 1970 thick Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate butter. The dillman farm family owned since 1970 thick apple butter is exactly that - it's a simple butter that hits all the right notes. If you are eating a low carb or sugar-free diet, this apple butter is probably the right level of sweetness for you. It is made with sweeter apples that have more natural sugars and taste too sweet. It does not taste "sweet" but it is really good. It also fits into a low carb lifestyle at just 2 grams of carbohydrate per tablespoon serving.

This apple butter is delicious and the ingredient list is as simple as it gets, just organic apples and organic cinnamon. The Tasty product has the right amount of organic cinnamon and the best part is that it is made from organic apples on a family owned farm. The apple butter has a thick consistency.

• Exceptional organic apple butter with only 2 ingredients
• Organic, no sugar added, crisp clean taste with just the right amount of sweetness
• Nice topping for bagel chips, biscuits, crackers, etc
• Delicious flavor on bread, peanut butter, waffles

Walden Farms Fruit Spread

Buy on Amazon

The walden farms fruit spread's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. Start your day off right with this apple butter spread and your entire day will be awesome. It's thicker than usual apple butters, but it is still amazing. It also doesn't have all the calories apple butter has. It is absolutely delicious and very healthy.

This does actually taste like cinnamon apple butter, but there is an odd chemical flavor behind all walden farms products. The flavor is delicious and you can’t tell it is sugar free. It does not spread like jam so it can be a little messy as the gel lacks coherence as it is sugar free.

• Tastes really good considering zero calories
• Good brand reputation

Walden Farms thick Apple Butter

Buy on Amazon

The walden farms thick apple butter should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. Start your day off right with this apple butter spread and your entire day will be awesome. A balance of real apple and natural flavors, this apple butter fruit spread is the perfect way to start your day. It offers a full line of specialty condiments and food enhancers with zero calories, zero net carbs, zero sugar, zero fat. It is made with concentrated fruit extracts and natural flavors and is perfect for toast, bagels, muffins or as a mix-in with yogurt. Make this amazing spread to impress guests, serve at parties, or simply enjoy magical mornings every day.

The Orthodox Union certifies all Walden Farms products to be Kosher. It can be used as a flavor enhancement and it is perfect. For a more exciting breakfast time, spread this apple butter on toast, muffins, pancakes, and oatmeal, or add it to cottage cheese, yogurt, and other baked goods.

• Lot of satisfied buyers
• One of the new comers and featured product