The 6 Best Toilet Flanges With Rubber Gasket (2022 reviews)

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a flange. The old old cast iron flange is exactly that - it's a simple flange that hits all the right notes. The old old cast iron flange is residential, it is durable and has a great design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, it saves money and it is great for brand name.

Above all, the old old cast iron flange is very functional and it is made for easy install.

Most buyers agree that the flange is made of different materials. Also, they say that the flange reduces the effective diameter of the pipe. Moreover, they also found that this flange does provide 2 holes at the very edge and it is helpful. In conclusion, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the flange suits the purpose.

Top Customer Quotes:

No need to tear up the existing floors.
This is good as the tile adheased to the floor.
This will prevent the gurgling from a nearby sink or drain pipe.
This is a perfect replacement flange for old 4 " cast iron pipes.

Best For Perfect Fit: Danco Toilet Flange With Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another flange that manages to win our hearts. It's the Danco Toilet Flange With Rubber Gasket and it's widely considered as one of the most convenient flange you can buy. The Danco toilet flange with rubber gasket is the perfect solution for fixing those wobbly or leaking toilets and broken or damaged flanges. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. These problems are usually difficult to fix, but hydroseat allows for a simple and easy way to fix those time - consuming problems.

The flange offers an easy, one-piece installation that fixes broken or damaged flanges, and wobbly or leaking toilets. Most importantly, the danco toilet flange with rubber gasket features a self-centering rubber funnel that fits any toilet or closet flange.

Almost all buyers agree that the flange can be used by someone who is not a plumber. In addition, a few strongly agree that the flange is easy to install, excellent quick fix to a broken flange. And, they say that the flange is a fairly painless process.

Customers say that getting a wax rings with plastic insert, along with flange is useful.

Top Customer Quotes:

This works well for older plumbing.
This is easy to use and worked the first time.
This is ingeniously designed, a single piece that seals securely.
This is rock solid with zero toilet wobble once installed.

Best For Stainless Steel: Sioux Chief Mfg Closet Flange

Buy on Amazon

The features department is where Sioux chief mfg closet flange truly manages to shine. The Sioux chief mfg closet flange is chemical and heat-resistant. A strong, adjustable stainless steel swivel ring means you adjust the ring, not the flange. Also, the flange has saved so much time and has a great design. Most importantly, the Sioux Chief Mfg Closet Flange works great, It comes with great parts and has an adjustable design.

Most customers found that the flange is used to seal a cast iron pipe. Also, they say that the flange is used to go inside a 4 inch cast-iron pipe.

Customers discovered that getting a different toilet flange, along with flange is useful.

Top Customer Quotes:

This can clamp around a pipe and also fit in the inside of the pipe.
This fits inside the existing 4” pipe.
This will work with the cast iron pipe.
This is perfect for new installations.

Best For Tile Floor: Oatey Toilet Flange With Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Oatey Toilet Flange With Rubber Gasket is suitable and reliable and fits well with your regular use. The oatey toilet flangewith rubbergasket includes gaskets, ½” spacer, closet bolts and shims. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, the flange is perfect for use in tight spaces and where the fitting is close to the sub-floor.

Lastly, the oatey toiletflange withrubber gasket is designed for use overlaying, replacing or tiling bathroom floors and provides easy, hassle-free use.

Almost all buyers found that the flange is a seal between the old flange and the new one. Further, they say that the flange is perfect and for a great price. To sum up, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the flange suits the purpose.

Customers discovered that getting a wax rings with plastic insert and replace cast iron toilet flanges with pvc, with this flange made their life much easier.

Why We Like This:

This is convenient, it is great for brand name and has a great design.
Four mounting slots for proper fit and alignment of closet bolts to the toilet.
Good brand reputation.

Best For High Quality: Sioux Chief Mfg Toilet Flange With Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Sioux chief mfg toilet flange with rubbergasket is capable of outshining several other flanges featured in this list in overall features in its price range. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, the flange is chemical and heat-resistant. To sum up, with a 4.3 rating and more than 472 buyers, the Sioux chief mfg toiletflange withrubber gasket stands as the best choice.

Most customers quickly discovered that the flange had worked flawlessly for months now. Also, they strongly agree that the flange is 3.5" from the bottom of the flange to the end of the pipe drop. And, they say that the ring flexible ring slides inside the old inner diameter pipe, and seals the system.

Top Customer Quotes:

It does not properly rest on the floor as it sits on the wax ring.
A strong, adjustable stainless steel swivel ring means you adjust the ring, not the flange.
This is where the Sioux chief kit really works its magic.
The same kit number as new, including flangewith stainless ring.

Best For Retrofit Or Remodel Applications: Sioux Chief Toilet Flange With Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase flange for their daily usage, but the Sioux Chief Toilet Flange With Rubber Gasket would be an anomoly. closet flanges shall have three screw holes for securing them to the floor, and two closet bolt slots. Moreover, the flange is perfect for retrofit or remodel applications. When it comes to finding a reliable flange, the sioux chief toilet flange with rubber gasket is definitely your first choice.

"Once you get this level on the floor, square with the back wall. " - says, one customer. In short, many customers have used the flange for more than a few months without letup, and it shows no sign of giving up.

Few customers bought different toilet flange, along with the flange.

Why We Like This:

Integral neoprene cover/cap removed with a utility knife after test.
Flange shall have an integral neoprene test cap and be upc listed.
Installation push flange over 4" cast iron DWV pipe.
Easy compression installation with neoprene gasket.